THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL TRIBUNAL FOR THE FORMER YUGOSLAVIA
CASE NO. IT-05-88-PT
THE PROSECUTOR OF THE TRIBUNAL
AGAINST
ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR
RADIVOJE MILETIC
MILAN GVERO
VINKO PANDUREVIC
LJUBISA BEARA
VUJADIN POPOVIC
DRAGO NIKOLIC
MILORAD TRBIC
LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN
CONSOLIDATED AMENDED INDICTMENT
The Prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, pursuant to her authority under Article 18 of the Statute of the Tribunal, charges:
ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR
VINKO PANDUREVIC
LJUBISA BEARA
VUJADIN POPOVIC
DRAGO NIKOLIC
MILORAD TRBIC
LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN
with GENOCIDE, CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT GENOCIDE, CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY, and VIOLATION OF THE LAWS OR CUSTOMS OF WAR, including; Extermination, Murder, Persecutions, Forcible Transfer and Deportation, as set forth herein; and,
RADIVOJE MILETIC
MILAN GVERO
with CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY, and VIOLATION OF THE LAWS OR CUSTOMS OF WAR, including; Murder, Persecutions, Forcible Transfer and Deportation as, as set forth herein.
THE ACCUSED
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, son of Stanko, was born on 27 November 1948 in the Glamoc Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
- RADIVOJE MILETIC, son of Mitar, was born on 6 December 1947 in Stovic, Foca Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
- MILAN GVERO, son of Dorde, was born on 4 December 1937 in Mrkonjinic Grad, Mrkonjinic Grad Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
- VINKO PANDUREVIC, son of Jovan, was born on 25 June 1959 in Jasik, Sokolac Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
- LJUBISA BEARA, son of Jovan, was born on 14 July 1939 in Sarajevo, Sarajevo Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
- VUJADIN POPOVIC, son of Vicentije, was born on 14 March 1957 in Popovici, Sekovici Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
- DRAGO NIKOLIC, son of Predrag, was born on 9 November 1957 in Brana Bacic, Bratunac Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
- MILORAD TRBIC, son of Mihajlo was born on 22 February 1958 in Ponijevo, in Zenica Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
- LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN, son of Milorad, was born on 27 February 1960 in Han Pijesak, Han Pijesak Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina.
SUPERIOR AUTHORITY / POSITION OF THE ACCUSED
ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR was the Assistant Commander for Intelligence and Security of the Main Staff of the VRS. In this position, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR was one of seven Assistant Commanders who reported directly to the Commander of the Main Staff, General Ratko Mladic. ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR was in charge of the Intelligence and Security branches of the VRS and in this capacity, inter alia, supervised the work of the 10th Sabotage Detachment of the VRS and the 65th Protection Regiment of the VRS.
RADIVOJE MILETIC
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment, RADIVOJE MILETIC was Chief of Operations and Training and Deputy Chief of Staff and was Standing in for the Chief of Staff, of the Main Staff of the VRS. As standing in for the Chief of Staff, he acted as principal adviser to the Commander and inter alia, was the primary facilitator through which the Commander’s intent, orders and directives were organised and processed for execution by the Staff and subordinate units.
MILAN GVERO
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment, MILAN GVERO was the Assistant Commander for Morale, Legal and Religious Affairs of the Main Staff of the VRS. In this position, MILAN GVERO was one of seven Assistant Commanders who reported directly to the Commander of the Main Staff, General Ratko Mladic.
VINKO PANDUREVIC
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment, VINKO PANDUREVIC, was a Lt. Colonel in command of the Zvornik Brigade of the Drina Corps of the VRS. As a brigade commander he was, inter alia, responsible for planning and directing the activities of all the subordinate formations of his brigade, in accordance with the directives received from his higher command.
LJUBISA BEARA
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment, LJUBISA BEARA was a Colonel and was the Chief of Security of the Main Staff of the VRS. As Chief of Security he reported to his superior, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR. As part of his job he was, inter alia responsible for managing the Main Staff units of the Military Police, including the 65th Protection Regiment and proposing ways to utilise the Military Police. He was also responsible, in general, for co-ordinating with the bodies of the MUP (Ministry of the Interior) in the six VRS Corps zones of responsibility
VUJADIN POPOVIC
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment, VUJADIN POPOVIC was a Lieutenant Colonel and was the Assistant Commander of Security on the staff of the Drina Corps. As Assistant Commander of Security for the Drina Corps, he reported to his commander, the Commander of the Drina Corps. He was, iner alia, responsible for managing the units of the Drina Corps Military Police, and proposing ways to utilise those units. He was also responsible, in general, for co-ordinating with the bodies of the MUP in the Drina Corps zone of responsibility
DRAGO NIKOLIC
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment, DRAGO NIKOLIC was a 2nd Lieutenant and served as Chief of Security for the Zvornik Brigade. As Chief of Security DRAGO NIKOLIC reported to his commander VINKO PANDUREVIC. He was, inter alia, responsible for managing the brigade Military Police Company and proposing ways to utilise the Military Police. He was also responsible, in general, for co-ordinating with the bodies of the MUP (Ministry of the Interior) within the brigade zone of responsibility.
MILORAD TRBIC
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment MILORAD TRBIC was an assistant to and directly reported to Lieutenant Drago Nikolic, the Chief of Security of the Zvornik Brigade. MILORAD TRBIC held the official rank of Captain. As an assistant to Lieutenant Drago Nikolic, MILORAD TRBIC was responsible, inter alia, for helping Drago Nikolic in managing the Military Police Company.
LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN
- During the time period relevant to the events described in this Indictment LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN was Deputy Commander of the Republika Srpska Ministry of Interior (MUP) Special Police Brigade (SPB). On 10 July 1995, he was appointed Commander of a joint force of MUP units and was ordered to report to Bratunac to Radislav Krstic, then Chief of Staff of the Drina Corps of the Army of Republika Srpska (VRS). As the commander of the joint MUP forces, he was, inter alia, responsible for planning and directing the activities of all the subordinate formations under his command, in accordance with the directives received from his higher command.
BACKGROUND
- On 12 May 1992, Momcilo Krajisnik, President of the RS National Assembly executed the following "DECISION ON STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES OF THE SERBIAN PEOPLE IN BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA," which was published in the Official Gazette of the Republika Srpska on 26 November 1993:
"The strategic objectives or priorities of the Serbian people in Bosnia and Herzegovina are to:
in relevant part
Establish State borders separating the Serbian people from the other two ethnic communities.
Establish a corridor in the Drina River valley, that is, eliminate the Drina as a border separating Serbian States.
- After armed conflict erupted in the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH) in the spring of 1992, Bosnian Serb military and paramilitary forces attacked and occupied cities, towns, and villages, including Bijeljina and Zvornik, in the eastern part of the country and participated in an ethnic cleansing campaign that resulted in an exodus of Bosnian Muslim civilians to enclaves in Srebrenica, Gorazde, and Zepa.
- On 19 November 1992, General Ratko Mladic issued Operational Directive 04. This Directive ordered the Drina Corps, one of the five VRS army corps, to "inflict the heaviest possible losses on the enemy, and force him to leave the Eastern Bosnia areas of Birac, Zepa and Gorazde areas together with the Bosnian Muslim population.
- On 16 April 1993, the Security Council of the United Nations, acting pursuant to Chapter VII of its Charter, adopted Resolution 819, in which it demanded that all parties to the conflict in the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina treat Srebrenica and its surroundings as a "safe area," which was to be free from any armed attack or any other hostile act. On 6 May 1993, the Security Council adopted Resolution 824, which declared Srebrenica and Zepa "safe areas."
- On 4 July 1994, Lieutenant Colonel Slavko Ognjenovic, then Commander of the Bratunac Brigade of the Drina Corps, issued a report to all members of the Bratunac Brigade stating in relevant part: "We must continue to arm, train, discipline, and prepare the RS Army for the execution of this crucial task — the expulsion of Muslims from the Srebrenica enclave. There will be no retreat when it comes to the Srebrenica enclave, we must advance. The enemy’s life has to be made unbearable and their temporary stay in the enclave impossible so that they leave the enclave en masse as soon as possible, realising that they cannot survive there."
- On 8 March 1995 President Radovan Karadzic set out in Directive 7 the order to remove the Muslim population for the Srebrenica and Zepa enclaves. On 11 and 12 July 1995 the Srebrenica enclave was taken over by VRS and MUP troops and the plan to remove the Muslim population from Srebrenica was implemented, along with the plan to murder all the able bodied men of Srebrenica.
- By November 1, 1995 the entire Muslim population had been either removed or fled from Srebrenica and Zepa and over 7000 Muslim men and boys from Srebrenica had been murdered by VRS and MUP forces.
COUNT 1
(Genocide)
By their acts and omissions described in the paragraphs below, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN committed:
- Between 11 July 1995 and 1 November 1995, ZDRAVKO
TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN
POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN with intent to destroy a part of
the Bosnian Muslim people as a national, ethnical,
or religious group:
- killed members of the group by summary execution,
including both planned and opportunistic summary
executions, as described in this Indictment;
and,
- caused serious bodily or mental harm to both
female and male members of the Bosnian Muslim
populations of Srebrenica and Zepa, including
but not limited to the separation of able bodied
men from their families and the forced movement
of the population from their homes to areas outside
the RS.
The Operation to Murder the Able Bodied Muslim
Men
- On the evening hours of
11 July and morning of 12 July, at the same time
the plan to forcibly transport the Muslim population
from Potocari was developed, Ratko Mladic and members
of his staff developed a plan to murder the hundreds
of able bodied men identified from the crowd of Muslims
in Potocari. LJUBISA BEARA, Chief of the Main
Staff Security Organ, was given authority for organising,
co-ordinating and facilitating the detention, transportation,
summary execution and burial of the Muslim victims. LJUBISA
BEARA was supervised in this task by ZDRAVKO
TOLIMIR, Assistant Commander for Security and
Intelligence, Main Staff. LJUBISA BEARA was
assisted in these tasks by the respective Corps and
Brigade security officers involved in these events
namely, VUJADIN POPOVIC, Drina Corps, Chief
of Security, Momir Nikolic, Bratunac Brigade Chief
of Security, DRAGO NIKOLIC, Zvornik Brigade
Chief of Security and MILORAD TRBIC, security
officer of the Zvornik Brigade. The above-named security
officers relied upon commanders Ratko Mladic, Radislav
Krstic, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN, Vidoje
Blagojevic and others, for the men, materials, directions
and orders, to carry out the murder operation.
- The plan to murder the able bodied men of Srebrenica
began on the afternoon of 12 July with the forcible
separation of the able bodied men in Potocari from
their families. From the afternoon of 12 July through
the entire day of 13 July over 1000 Muslim able bodied
men were separated from their friends and families
and transported to Bratunac and held temporarily
in buildings and vehicles through 14 and 15 July.
- On the morning of 13 July and continuing all
that day, over 6000 able-bodied Muslim men surrendered
to or were captured by Bosnian Serb forces stationed
along the road between Bratunac, Konjevic Polje and
Milici. The majority of those prisoners were transported
to Bratunac or Kravica where they were temporarily
detained in buildings and vehicles, along with the
Muslim men who had been separated in Potocari.
- The large scale systematic murder of Muslim
men from Srebrenica began on the morning of 13 July
at approximately 11:00 hours and continued through
July 1995 as set forth in specific detail below,
including but not limited to the following:.
30.1 Bratunac Brigade HQ: On 13 July 1995,
six Bosnian Muslim men from Srebrenica were captured
by MUP forces, turned over to and interrogated by
security personnel from the Bratunac Brigade at the
Bratunac Brigade Headquarters. They were then placed
among the other Muslim prisoners in Bratunac, and
thereafter summarily executed by unknown persons.
The identification details for these six Bosnian
Muslim men are as follows:
- Zazif AVDIC, son of Ramo, date of birth: 15 September 1954.
- Munib DEDIC, son of Emin, date of birth: 26 April 1956.
- Aziz HUSIC, son of Osman, date of birth: 08 April 1966.
- Resid SINANOVIC, son of Rahman, date of birth: 15 October 1949.
- Mujo HUSIC, son of Osman, date of birth: 27 August 1961.
- Hasib IBISEVIC, son of Ibrahim, date of birth: 27 February 1964.
30.2 Jadar River: At approximately 1100
hours on 13 July 1995, working with individuals
and units of the VRS and/or MUP, a small squad
of soldiers consisting of at least one Bratunac
police officer (Bratunac MUP) captured approximately
16 Bosnian Muslim men from the column of men retreating
from the Srebrenica enclave, transported them from
Konjevic Polje to an isolated area on the bank
of the Jadar River, and summarily executed 15 of
them. One individual was wounded and managed to
escape.
30.3 Cerska Valley: On 13 July 1995, in
the early afternoon hours, VRS and/or MUP soldiers
transported about 150 Bosnian Muslim men to an
area along a dirt road in the Cerska Valley about
three (3) kilometres from Konjevic Polje, summarily
executed them and, using heavy equipment, covered
them with dirt.
30.4 Kravica Warehouse: On 13 July 1995,
MUP Special Police Forces under the command and
control of LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN captured
hundreds of Muslim men from Srebrenica and placed
them in an agricultural warehouse in the village
of Kravica and guarded them there. In the early
evening hours, VRS and/or MUP Special Police Forces
summarily executed over 1000 Bosnian Muslim men
detained in a large warehouse in the village of
Kravica. The soldiers used automatic weapons, hand
grenades, and other weaponry to kill the Bosnian
Muslims inside the warehouse. On 14 July 1995,
heavy equipment arrived and removed the victims’ bodies
to two large mass graves located in the nearby
villages of Glogova and Ravnice.
30.5 Luke School near Tisca: Throughout
the day on 13 July 1995, VRS and/or MUP soldiers
transported Bosnian Muslim women and children who
had been separated from male members of their families
in Potocari to an area near the Luke School near
Tisca village. VRS soldiers from the Vlasenica
Brigade of the Drina Corps identified and separated
some remaining Bosnian Muslim men and boys and
some of the Bosnian Muslim women from this group
at Luke School, while the rest of the group was
forcibly transferred to Bosnian Muslim territory.
Throughout the day on 13 July 1995, VRS soldiers
forced the selected Bosnian Muslim men and women
to walk to the nearby school, where they were abused
and assaulted. On or about the evening of 13 July
1995 and the day of 14 July 1995, VRS and/or MUP
soldiers loaded 25 Bosnian Muslim men from the
school onto a truck, drove them to an isolated
pasture nearby, and summarily executed them with
automatic weapons.
30.6 Orahovac (near Lazete): In the late
evening hours of 13 July and during the day of
14 July 1995, DRAGO NIKOLIC and MILORARD
TRBIC, working
together with, personnel from the Military Police
Company of the Zvornik Brigade and Military Police
Platoon of the Bratunac Brigade, under the supervision
of VUJADIN POPOVIC and LJUBISA BEARA and
under orders from their superior command, including
Deputy Commander of the Zvornik Brigade, Dragan
Obrenovic, organised and facilitated the transportation
of hundreds of Bosnian Muslim males from in and
around Bratunac to the school in Orahovac, with
knowledge that those prisoners were to be collected
and summarily executed. On 14 July 1995, VRS personnel,
including members of the Military Police Company
of the Zvornik Brigade, guarded and blindfolded
the Bosnian Muslim males detained at the Grbavci
School. MILORAD TRBIC was present at the
school in Orahovac and personally supervised the
Zvornik Brigade Military Police in the guarding
of the Muslims at the school. In the late morning
to early afternoon Zvornik Brigade Military Police
officers, with the knowledge and authorization
of MILORAD TRBIC, removed at least two Muslim
prisoners and summarily executed them by automatic
rifle fire. In the early afternoon of 14 July 1995,
Zvornik Brigade personnel under the supervision
of MILORAD TRBIC transported these Bosnian
Muslim males from the school at Orahovac to a nearby
field, where personnel, including members of the
4th Battalion of the Zvornik Brigade,
ordered the prisoners off the trucks and summarily
executed them with automatic weapons. MILORAD
TRBIC personally executed several of the Muslim
victims at the execution field. Approximately 1000
Bosnian Muslim males were killed. On 14 and 15
July 1995, members of the Zvornik Brigade Engineering
Company, used heavy equipment to bury the victims
in mass graves at the execution site, while the
executions continued. On the evening of 14 July,
lights from the engineering machinery illuminated
the execution and burial sites during the executions.
At all times on 14 July in Orahovac, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD
TRBIC, and all other Zvornik Brigade personnel
were under the command and control of their commander VINKO
PANDUREVIC.
30.7 The Petkovci School: On 14 July 1995,
VRS and/or MUP personnel, under the supervision
of VUJADIN POPOVIC and LJUBISA BEARA,
transported approximately 1000 Bosnian Muslim males
from detention sites in and around Bratunac. On
14 July and during the early morning hours of 15
July 1995, VRS and/or MUP personnel struck, beat,
assaulted, and shot with automatic weapons Bosnian
Muslim males detained at the school. The Petkovci
School was located in the zone of responsibility
of the Zvornik Brigade.
30.8 The "Dam" near Petkovci: On or
about the evening of 14 July 1995 and the early
morning hours of 15 July 1995, VRS personnel
from the Zvornik Brigade, under the command
and control of VINKO PANDUREVIC, including
drivers and trucks from the 6th Infantry
Battalion, transported the surviving members
of the group of approximately 1000 Bosnian Muslim
males from the school at Petkovci to an area
below the Dam near Petkovci. VRS or MUP soldiers
assembled them below the Dam and summarily executed
them with automatic weapons. In the morning of
15 July 1995, working together with other individuals
and units, VRS personnel from the Engineering
Company of the Zvornik Brigade used excavators
and other heavy equipment to bury the victims
while the executions continued.
30.9 Kula School near Pilica: On or
about 14 and 15 July 1995, VRS and/or MUP personnel,
under the supervision of VUJADIN POPOVIC and LJUBISA
BEARA, transported approximately 1200 Bosnian
Muslim males from detention sites in Bratunac
to the school at the village of Kula near Pilica.
On or about 14 and 15 July 1995, VRS military
personnel with automatic weapons summarily
executed many of the Bosnian Muslim males who
were being detained at the school. On 17 July
1995, VRS personnel from the "R" Battalion
of the Zvornik Brigade, under the command and
control of VINKO
PANDUREVIC, retrieved the bodies of the victims
from the Kula School and transported them to
the Branjevo Military Farm. On 17 July 1995,
the Engineering Company of the Zvornik Brigade,
under the command and control of VINKO PANDUREVIC,
buried the victims of the Kula School executions
in a mass grave at the Branjevo Military Farm.
30.10 Kozluk: On 15 July 1995, working
together with other individuals and units, VRS
and/or MUP personnel, under the supervision of VUJADIN
POPOVIC and LJUBISA BEARA, transported
to an isolated place near Kozluk, in the Zvornik
Brigade zone of responsibility, and summarily
executed with automatic weapons about 500 Bosnian
Muslim males who had been captured from the column
of men retreating from the Srebrenica enclave
or had been separated in Potocari. On 16 July
1995, working together with other individuals
and units, VRS soldiers from the Engineering
Company of the Zvornik Brigade, under the command
and control of VINKO PANDUREVIC buried
the victims of the executions in a mass grave
nearby.
30.11 Branjevo Military Farm: On the
morning of 16 July 1995, VRS personnel, under
the supervision of VUJADIN POPOVIC and LJUBISA
BEARA,
transported from the Kula school by bus to the
Branjevo Military Farm the remaining members
of the group of approximately 1200 Bosnian Muslim
males who had surrendered or been captured from
the column of men retreating from the Srebrenica
enclave or had been separated in Potocari. After
the Bosnian Muslim males arrived at the Branjevo
Military Farm, members of the 10th Sabotage
Detachment working together with other unknown
soldiers, summarily executed them by automatic
weapon fire. On 17 July 1995, VRS personnel from
the Engineering Company of the Zvornik Brigade,
under the command of VINKO PANDUREVIC buried
hundreds of victims in a nearby mass grave.
30.12 Pilica Cultural Centre: On 16
July 1995, VRS personnel who had participated
in the executions at the Branjevo Farm travelled
a short distance to the village of Pilica and
worked with other VRS and/or MUP personnel, under
the supervision of VUJADIN POPOVIC and LJUBISA
BEARA, in summarily executing, with automatic
weapons, approximately 500 men inside the Pilica
Cultural Centre who had surrendered or been
captured from the column of men retreating
from the Srebrenica enclave or had been separated
in Potocari. On 17 July 1995, VRS personnel
from the "R" Battalion
of the Zvornik Brigade, under the command and
control of VINKO PANDUREVIC retrieved
the bodies of the victims from the Pilica Cultural
Centre and transported them to the Branjevo Military
Farm. On 17 July 1995, the Engineering Company
of the Zvornik Brigade buried the victims of
the Pilica School executions in a mass grave
at the Branjevo Military Farm.
30.13 Executions near Nezuk: On 19 July
1995, VRS personnel from the 16th Brigade
of the 1st Krajina Corps, re-subordinated
to the command of the Zvornik Brigade, under
the command of VINKO PANDUREVIC captured
approximately 10 Bosnian Muslim males from Srebrenica
near the town of Nezuk. Shortly after their capture
the victims were summarily executed by their
captors.
30.14 Execution of 4 Branjevo Farm Survivors: On
or about 19 July 1995, four Bosnian Muslim men
who had survived the Branjevo Farm execution
were captured from the column by VRS and/or MUP
forces in the Zvornik Brigade zone of responsibility
and turned over to Zvornik Brigade Security personnel
under the supervision of DRAGO NIKOLIC.
The four Muslims were interrogated on 22 July
1995 by Zvornik Brigade personnel regarding assistance
they had received from Zvornik Brigade soldiers
after their escape for the Branjevo Farm executions.
The Muslims were kept in custody for a few days
and were then summarily executed by Zvornik Brigade
personnel. These summary executions were carried
out and with the knowledge and authorization
of VINKO PANDUREVIC and with the knowledge
and assistance of DRAGO NIKOLIC. The Muslim
victims were identified as:
(1) Sakib KIVIRIC, son of Salko, date of birth: 24 June 1964;
(2) Emin MUSTAFIC, son of Rifet, date of birth: 7 October 1969;
(3) Fuad DJOZIC, son of Senusija, date of birth: 2 May 1965; and,
(4) Almir HALILOVIC, son of Suljo, date of birth: 25 August 1980.
30.15 Execution of injured Muslims from
the Milici Hospital: On approximately 13
July 19 Muslim men from Srebrenica were wounded
as they tried to escape from the Srebrenica
enclave. These men surrendered or were captured
on about 13 or 14 July and were admitted to
the Milici hospital and treated. On about 14
July 11 of the wounded Muslim prisoners from
Srebrenica were transferred from the Milici
hospital to the Zvornik Hospital on orders
from the Main Staff. A few days later those
Muslim prisoners were transferred from the
Zvornik Hospital to the infirmary of the Zvornik
Brigade. On or shortly after 20 July 1995 those
11 Muslim men were removed from the Zvornik
Brigade Headquarters and summarily executed
by the VRS. The removal of those prisoners
and summary executions was done with the knowledge
and under the authority of VINKO PANDUREVIC and
knowledge and assistance of VUJADIN POPOVIC and DRAGO
NIKOLIC. The victims were identified as:
- Aziz BECIROVIC, son of Nezir, born 16 September 1973 in Opetci, Srebrenica Municipality;
- Mensur SALKIC, son of Sukrija, born 25 December 1970 in Osati, Srebrenica Municipality;
- Behaija KURTIC, son of Ahmet, born 18 January 1964 in Joseva, Bratunac Municipality;
- Izet HALILOVIC, son of Ramo, born 1951 in Srebrenica, Srebrenica Municipality;
- Behudin LOLIC, son of Ramiz, born 4 January 1967 in Donji Potocari, Srebrenica Municipality;
- Huso SALIHOVIC, son of Mesan, born 10 May 1974 in Skugrici, Vlasenica Municipality;
- Vahdet SULJIC, son of Alija, born 3 June 1968 in Pusmulici Srebrenica Municipality;
- Remzija IBISEVIC, son of Ibrahim, born 20 July 1943 in Glogova, Bratunac Municipality;
- Mujo BECIC, son of Hakija, born 26 February 1970 in Srebrenica, Srbrebrenica Municipality;
- Sulejman BEGOVIC, son of Mustafa, born 3 March 1970 in Bukovica, Vlasenica Municipality; and,
- Mehmedalija HAMZABEGOVIC, son of Ibrahim, born 15 February 1957 in Glodi, Zvornik Municipality.
30.16 Execution of 6 Muslim men and boys near
the town of Trnovo: Sometime in July or August
1995, after the fall of the Srebrenica enclave,
a Serbian unit working with the VRS and/or RS MUP
summarily executed 6 Muslims from Srebrenica near
the town of Trnovo in Bosnia and Hercegovina including:
- Azmir ALISPAHIC, son of Alija born, 2 October 1978 in Srebrenica, Srebrenica Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina
- Safet FEJZIC, son of Sakib, born 3 January 1978, in Srebrenica, Srebrenica Municipality, Bosnia and Hercegovina
Opportunistic Killings
- During and after the campaign of forcible transfer and organised executions, the opportunistic killing of captured Bosnian Muslim men from the Srebrenica enclave by VRS and MUP personnel continued through July and August. These opportunistic killings, were the natural and foreseeable consequence of the Joint Criminal Enterprise to forcibly transfer the population of Srebrenica. They were also the natural and foreseeable consequence of the Joint Criminal Enterprise to murder all the able bodied Muslim men from Srebrenica:
31.1 Potocari
- On 12 July, the bodies of nine Bosnian Muslim men who had been shot, were found in the woods near the UN Compound on the Budak side of the main road.
- On 12 July, the bodies of nine or ten Bosnian Muslim males were found about seven hundred metres from the UN Compound behind the White House in a creek.
- On the morning of the 13 July, the bodies of six Bosnian Muslim women and five Bosnian Muslim men were found in a stream near the UN Compound in Potocari.
- On 13 July, one Bosnian Muslim man was taken behind a building near the "White House" and summarily executed.
31.2 Bratunac town
- On 12 July, beginning at approximately 2200 hours and continuing through 13 July, more than 50 Bosnian Muslim men were taken from a hangar behind the Vuk Karadzic elementary school in Bratunac and summarily executed.
- On 13 July, at approximately 2130 hours, two Bosnian Muslim men were taken off a truck in Bratunac town, taken to a nearby garage, and summarily executed.
- On 13 July, in the evening, a Bosnian Muslim man who was mentally retarded was taken off a bus parked in front of the Vuk Karadzic elementary school in Bratunac and summarily executed.
- Between the evening of 13 July and the morning
of 15 July 1995, Bosnian Muslim males were frequently
and consistently killed, both inside and outside
the Vuk Karadzic elementary school by VRS and or
MUP personnel.
31.3 Kravica Market: During the night between
13 July and 14 July near a supermarket in Kravica,
a VRS or MUP soldier placed his rifle barrel into
the mouth of a Bosnian Muslim prisoner and summarily
executed the man. Also during this period, VRS and/or
MUP soldiers struck, beat with rifle butts, and summarily
executed Bosnian Muslim prisoners who had surrendered
or been captured from the column of men retreating
from the Srebrenica enclave or had been separated
at Potocari and were detained on trucks near the
supermarket.
31.4 Petkovci School: On 14 and the early
morning hours of 15 July 1995 VRS and or MUP personnel
beat, abused and killed many Bosnian Muslim men
being detained in the Petkovci School, just prior
to those men being transported to the Dam near
Petkovci for summary execution.
Re Burial Operation
- From about 1 August 1995 through about 1 November
1995, VRS and MUP personnel participated in an
organised and comprehensive effort to conceal the
killings and executions in the Zvornik and Bratunac
Brigade zones of responsibility by reburying bodies
exhumed from initial mass graves at the following
locations: Branjevo Military Farm; Kozluk; the "Dam" near
Petkovci; Orahovac; and Glogova; and transferring
them to secondary graves at: twelve sites along
the Cancari Road (containing bodies from Branjevo
Military Farm and Kozluk); four sites near Liplje
(containing bodies from the "Dam" near Petkovci);
seven sites near Hodzici (containing bodies from
Orahovac); and seven sites near Zeleni Jadar (containing
bodies from Glogova). This reburial operation was
a natural and foreseeable consequence of the execution
and original burial plan conceived by the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and was done on orders from
Ratko Mladic with the knowledge and assistance
of VUJADIN POPOVIC, VINKO PANDUREVIC, DRAGO
NIKOLIC AND MILORAD TRBIC.
The Destruction of the Women and Children
- The forcible transfer of the women and children
as described in this indictment created conditions
known to the accused that would contribute to the
destruction of the entire Muslim population of
Eastern Bosnia, including but not limited to the
failure in part, of the population to live and
reproduce normally.
COUNT 1: Genocide, punishable under Articles
4(3)(a) and 7(1) (BOROVCANIN limited to
Aiding and Abetting Genocide) and for VINKO
PANDUREVIC AND LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN, under Article
7 (3) of the Statute of the Tribunal.
COUNT 2
(Conspiracy to Commit Genocide)
By their acts and omissions described in the paragraphs
below, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA
BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, AND MILORAD
TRBIC committed:
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA
BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, and MILORAD
TRBIC entered an agreement with several others,
including General Ratko Mladic, the Commander
of the VRS, General Milenko Zivanovic, Commander
of the Drina Corps through about 2000 hours on
13 July 1995; General Radislav Krstic, Chief
of Staff/Deputy Commander through about 2000
hours on 13 July 1995 and, thereafter, Commander
of the Drina Corps and others (see Attachment
A for a list of the members of the Conspiracy)
to kill the able-bodied Muslim men from Srebrenica
that were captured or surrendered after the fall
of Srebrenica on 11 July 1995 and remove the
remaining Muslim population of Srebrenica and
Zepa from the Republika Srpska with the intent
to destroy those Muslims. The underlying facts
and agreement of the Conspiracy to commit genocide
are identical to the facts and agreement identified
in Joint Criminal Enterprise mentioned in this
Indictment.
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA
BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC and MILORAD
TRBIC entered this agreement with the intent
to kill the Muslim men of Srebrenica and to cause
serious bodily or mental harm to the Muslims
of Srebrenica, and in furtherance of the intent
to destroy, in part, a national, ethnical, racial,
or religious group, as such.
The Conspiracy, Joint Criminal Enterprise and
Operation to Murder all the Able-bodied Muslim
Men from Srebrenica
- On or about 12 July 1995 the Conspiracy, Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation was implemented. ZDRAVKO
TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN
POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN, together with other VRS and MUP
officers and units as identified in this Indictment
in Attachment A, were members of
and knowingly participated in a Conspiracy, Joint
Criminal Enterprise, and Operation, the common
purpose of which was to, summarily execute and
bury thousands of Bosnian Muslim men and boys aged
16 to 60 from captured from the Srebrenica enclave
from 12 July 1995 until about 19 July 1995. The
last known primary burial of Srebrenica victims
occurred on or about 19 July 1995 in Glogova. The
initial plan was to summarily execute more than
1000 Bosnian Muslim men and boys, aged 16 to 60,
who were separated from the group of Bosnian Muslims
in Potocari on 12 and 13 July. On 12 or 13 July,
this plan was broadened to include the summary
execution of over 6000 men and boys, aged 16 to
60, who were captured from the column of Bosnian
Muslim men escaping the Srebrenica enclave from
12 July through about 1 November 1995. (For the
actual execution of the Conspiracy, Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation, including involvement
of the Accused, see paragraphs 27 to 32 and 38
to 44 of this Indictment).
- Although the Conspiracy, Joint Criminal Enterprise
and Operation contemplated organised and systematic
executions, it was foreseeable to, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR,
VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC,
DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN that
individual opportunistic killings and persecutory
acts, such as those described in paragraphs 31
and 48 of this Indictment, would be carried out
by VRS and MUP forces during and after the Joint
Criminal Enterprise. VRS and MUP forces carried
out such opportunistic criminal acts from 12 July
1995 to about 1 November 1995. The implementation
of this Joint Criminal Enterprise resulted in the
summary execution of over 7000 Bosnian Muslim men
and boys from the Srebrenica enclave.
ACTIONS OF THE ACCUSED IN FURTHERANCE OF THE JOINT
CRIMINAL ENTERPRISE, CONSPIRACY AND OPERATION TO
SUMMARILY EXECUTE AND BURY THE ABLE BODIED MUSLIM
MEN FROM SREBRENICA
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, acting individually or
in concert with other members of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation to summarily
execute and bury the able bodied Muslim men from
Srebrenica, committed acts in furtherance of the
Joint Criminal Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation
including but not limited to the following (see
also paragraphs 1, 10, 27, 31, 34 to 37, 54, 66-70,
74, 83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
- With full knowledge of the plan to summarily
execute the able-bodied men of Srebrenica, he
assisted in and facilitated the forcible transfer
and deportation of the Muslim population of Srebrenica,
as described in paragraphs 61 to 64 of this Indictment.
- On 13 July 1995, he assisted in the operation
to detain and execute the able-bodied men of
Srebrenica by proposing to his commander Ratko
Mladic that the hundreds of Muslim prisoners
being detained along the Konjevic Polje - Bratunac
road be secreted from international forces by
being placed in buildings so they could not be
viewed from the air.
- He supervised the 10th Sabotage
Detachment on 16 July 1995 when elements of this
unit summarily executed more than 1700 Muslim
men and boys at the Branjevo Military Farm and
the Pilica Cultural Centre.
- As Assistant Commander for Intelligence and
Security of the Main Staff, and by virtue of
the authority vested in him by his commander,
Ratko Mladic, he had responsibility for
the handling of all of the Bosnian Muslim prisoners
taken after the fall of the Srebrenica enclave
and to ensure their safety and welfare. He failed
to do so.
- VINKO PANDUREVIC, acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation to summarily
execute and bury the able bodied Muslim men from
Srebrenica, committed acts in furtherance of the
Joint Criminal Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation
including but not limited to the following (see
also paragraphs 4, 13, 16, 27, 30.6, 30.8 to 30.15,
31, 32, 34 to 37, 54 to 55, 67, 77, 80(a)(iii),
83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
- On 12 or 13 July 1995, with full knowledge
of the plan to summarily execute the able-bodied
men of Srebrenica, he authorised the transport,
detention and summary execution of hundreds of
Bosnian Muslim men from Srebrenica, to detention
sights in the Zvornik Brigade zone of responsibility,
including at least 2 Muslim men killed at the
school in Orahovac on 14 July 1995, approximately
1000 Muslim men executed at Orahovac on 14 July
1995, approximately 1000 Muslim men executed
at the Dam near Petkovci on 14 and 15 July.
- On 15 July 1995, he personally authorised the
detention, summary execution and burial of thousands
of Bosnian Muslim men from Srebrenica held in
schools in Rocevic, Kula, and the Pilica Cultural
Centre.
- He remained in command and present in the Zvornik
Brigade zone of responsibility from 15 July through
August, 1995 and had knowledge of, and assisted
in the following summary executions:
- the execution of 500 to 1000 Muslim men on
the banks of the Drina River near the town
of Kozluk;
- the execution of approximately 1200 Muslim
men at the Branjevo Military farm on 16 July
1995;
- the execution of approximately 500 Muslim
men at the Pilica Cultural Centre on 16 July
1995;
- the summary execution on or shortly after
20 July of our Branjevo Farm as described in
paragraph 30.14 of this Indictment;
- the summary execution on about 16 July through
August 1 of 19 Muslim patients from the Zvornik
Brigade Infirmary; and,
- as Commander of the Zvornik Brigade, he had
responsibility for all the Bosnian Muslim prisoners
detained in the Zvornik Brigade zone of responsibility
after the fall of the Srebrenica enclave and
to ensure their safety and welfare. He failed
to do so.
- LJUBISA BEARA, acting individually or
in concert with other members of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation to summarily
execute and bury the able-bodied Muslim men from
Srebrenica, committed acts in furtherance of the
Joint Criminal Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation
including but not limited to the following (see
also paragraphs 5, 14, 27, 30.6 to 30.7, 30.9 to
30.12, 31, 34 to 37, 44(a)(iii), 63, 78, 83, 88
and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
- In furtherance of the plan to capture, detain,
transport and summarily execute able-bodied men
of Srebrenica and with full knowledge of the
plan to summarily execute such men:
- he organised and assisted in the gathering
together, detention, transportation and
execution of Muslim men from Srebrenica
along the Konjevic Polje - Milici road
Srebrenica on 13 July 1995;
- he assisted in the transportation and
organisation of Muslim men from Bratunac
to detention centers in the Zvornik area,
specifically the schools at Orhaovac, Petkovci,
Rocevic and Kula and the Pilica Cultural
Centre, from 13 through about 16 July 1995,
and oversaw and supervised their summary
execution;
- he participated in the effort by General
Krstic to capture Muslim men fleeing from
the Zepa enclave over the Drina River to
Serbia on about 1 and 2 August 1995; and,
- as Chief of Security of the Main Staff,
and by virtue of the authority vested in
him by his commander, Ratko Mladic, he had
responsibility for the handling of all
of the Bosnian Muslim prisoners taken after
the fall of the Srebrenica enclave and
to ensure their safety and welfare. He
failed to do so.
- VUJADIN POPOVIC, acting individually or
in concert with other members of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation to summarily
execute and bury the able-bodied Muslim men from
Srebrenica, committed acts in furtherance of the
Joint Criminal Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation
including but not limited to the following (see
also paragraphs 6, 15, 27, 30.6 to 30.7, 30.9 to
30.12, 30.15, 31, 32, 34 to 37, 55, 59, 61, 79,
83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
- In furtherance of the plan to capture, detain,
transport and summarily execute able bodied
men of Srebrenica and with full knowledge of
the plan to summarily execute such men
- he was a participant at the meeting at the
Hotel Fontana at 10:00 hours 12 July 1995 with
General Mladic and his staff, DutchBat officers,
Muslim representatives from Srebrenica - the
purpose of which was to arrange for the departure
and transportation of the Muslims to leave
Srebrenica and to intimidate the Muslims so
they would leave the Srebrenica area;
- he was present on duty in Potocari on 12
July 1995 overseeing the transportation of
Muslims from Potocari to areas outside of the
RS;
- he assisted in the transportation and organisation
of Muslim men from Bratunac to detention areas
in Zvornik, specifically the schools at Orahovac,
Petkovci, Rocevic and Kula, and the Pilica
Cultural Centre from 13 through 16 July 1995,
and oversaw and supervised their summary execution;
and,
- as Assistant Commander for Security of the
Drina Corps, and by virtue of the authority
vested in him by his commander, he had
responsibility for the handling of all of the
Bosnian Muslim prisoners in the Drina Corps
zone of responsibility taken after the fall
of the Srebrenica enclave and to ensure their
safety and welfare. He failed to do so.
- DRAGO NIKOLIC, acting individually or
in concert with other members of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation to summarily
execute and bury the able-bodied Muslim men from
Srebrenica, committed acts in furtherance of the
Joint Criminal Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation
including but not limited to the following (see
also paragraphs 7, 16, 27, 30.6, 30.14, 30.15,
31, 32, 34 to 37, 80, 83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this
Indictment):
- In furtherance of the plan to capture, detain,
transport and summarily execute able bodied
men of Srebrenica and with full knowledge of
the plan to summarily execute such men
- he assisted in the transportation and organisation
of Muslim men from Bratunac to detention areas
in the Zvornik area including the schools at
Orahovac, Petkovci, Rocevic, Kula and the Pilica
Cultural Centre; from 13 through 16 July and
oversaw and supervised their summary execution;
and,
- as Assistant Commander for Security of the
Drina Corps, and by virtue of the authority
vested in him by his commander, he had
responsibility for the handling of all of the
Bosnian Muslim prisoners in the Drina Corps
zone of responsibility taken after the fall
of the Srebrenica enclave and to ensure their
safety and welfare. He failed to do so.
- LJUBISA BOROVCANIN, acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation
to summarily execute and bury the able bodied
Muslim men from Srebrenica, committed acts
in furtherance of the Joint Criminal Enterprise,
Conspiracy and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
9, 18, 27, 30.4, 31, 34 to 37, 61 to 63,
81, 83, 88 and 90 to 92 of this Indictment)
- In furtherance of the plan to capture, detain,
transport and summarily execute able bodied
men of Srebrenica and with full knowledge of
the plan to summarily execute such men:
- on 12 and 13 July 1995 he was present in
Potocari commanding MUP troops in the separation
of Muslim men from their families with full
knowledge that those men would be summarily
executed;
- on 13 July 1995, he was present along the
Bratunac - Konjevic Polje road, including
the Kravica Warehouse and commanded troops
there who assisted the VRS in capturing,
detaining, transporting and executing, hundreds
of able-bodied Muslim men and boys from Srebrenica,
with full knowledge that the Muslim men would
be executed;
- on 13 July 1995 he was personally present
at the Kravica warehouse when hundreds of
Muslim prisoners were in the process of being
summarily executed by or in the presence
of troops under his command and he did nothing
to prevent those executions and did nothing
to affect first aid or any medical treatment
of the remaining surviving Muslims at the
warehouse and did thereby encourage his men
and those working with his men to continue
to kill Muslim prisoners and let wounded
prisoners die from their wounds; and,
- as Commander of MUP forces in the area, he had
responsibility for all the Bosnian Muslim
prisoners detained by his troops after the
fall of the Srebrenica enclave and to ensure
their safety and welfare. He failed to do
so.
- MILORAD TRBIC, acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise, Conspiracy and Operation
to summarily execute and bury the able bodied
Muslim men from Srebrenica, committed acts
in furtherance of the Joint Criminal Enterprise,
Conspiracy and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
8, 17, 27, 30.6, 31, 32, 34 to 37, 82 to
83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
- In furtherance of the plan to capture, detain,
transport and summarily execute able bodied men
of Srebrenica and with full knowledge of the
plan to summarily execute such men:
- on 13 and 14 July 1995, he assisted in organising
the transportation, detention, security and
execution of Muslim men from Srebrenica transported
in busses and trucks from Bratunac to detention
sights in schools in the Zvornik area, including
Orahovac, Petkovci, Rocevic, Kula and the Pilica
Cultural Centre, with full knowledge that those
men were to be summarily executed;
- on 14 July 1995 he was present at the Orahovac
School supervising the detention of Muslim
prisoners awaiting execution at which time
a soldier guarding the Muslims summarily executed
at least two Muslim prisoners in his presence;
and,
- on 16 July 1995, as Duty Officer of the Zvornik
Brigade he communicated with various VRS officers,
including LJUBISA BEARA and others in
the organising of the operation to murder thousands
of Bosnian Muslim detained in schools in the
Zvornik Brigade zone of responsibility.
COUNT 2: Conspiracy to commit genocide, punishable
under Articles 4(3)(b) and 7(1) and VINKO PANDUREVIC Article
7(3), of the Statute of the Tribunal.
COUNT 3
(Extermination)
By their acts and omissions described in the preceding
paragraphs, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC,
LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD
TRBIC and LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN committed:
- And, as described in this Indictment, the
crime of Extermination was perpetrated, executed,
and carried out by and through the following
means:
The involvement of the accused as described
in detail in paragraphs 30 to 31 of this
Indictment in the murder of thousands of
Bosnian Muslim men and boys from the Srebrenica
enclave.
COUNT 3: Extermination, a CRIME
AGAINST HUMANITY, punishable under
Articles 5(b) and 7(1) and VINKO PANDUREVIC and LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN under Article 7 (3), of
the Statute of the Tribunal.
COUNTS 4 - 5
(Murder)
By their acts and omissions described in
the preceding paragraphs, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR,
RADIVOJE MILETIC, MILAN GVERO, VINKO PANDUREVIC,
LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC,
MILORAD TRBIC and LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN committed:
- The crime of Murder was perpetrated, executed,
and carried out by and through the means
identified in paragraphs 30 to 31 of this
Indictment.
- The crime of Murder was perpetrated, executed,
and carried out by and through the means
identified in paragraphs 30 to 31 of this
Indictment.
COUNT 4: Murder, a CRIME AGAINST
HUMANITY, punishable under Articles
5(a) and 7(1) and VINKO PANDUREVIC and LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN Article 7 (3), of the Statute
of the Tribunal.
and
COUNT 5: Murder, a VIOLATION
OF THE LAWS OR CUSTOMS OF WAR, punishable
under Articles 3 and 7(1) and VINKO
PANDUREVIC and LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN Article
7 (3), of the Statute of the Tribunal.
COUNT 6
(Persecutions)
By their acts and omissions alleged in the
preceding paragraphs, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR,
RADIVOJE MILETIC, MILAN GVERO, VINKO PANDUREVIC,
LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC,
MILORAD TRBIC and LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN committed:
- As described in paragraphs 27 to 31 and
50 to 71 of this Indictment, the crime of
persecutions was perpetrated, executed, and
carried out by and through the following
means:
- the murder of thousands of Bosnian Muslim civilians,
including men, women, children, and elderly persons,
as described in paragraphs 30 to 31 of this Indictment;
- the cruel and inhumane treatment of Bosnian
Muslim civilians, including murder and severe
beatings at Potocari and in detention facilities
in Bratunac and Zvornik;
- the terrorising of Bosnian Muslim civilians
in Srebrenica and at Potocari;
- the destruction of personal property and effects
belonging to the Bosnian Muslims; and
- the forcible transfer of Bosnian Muslims from
Srebrenica and Zepa by means of the forced bussing
of the women and children to Bosnian Muslim-controlled
territory and the forced bussing of the men,
separated at Potocari or captured or having surrendered
from the column, up to the Zvornik area, where
they were ultimately executed and the deportation
of the Bosnian Muslim men from Zepa who were
forced to flee to their homes in Zepa to Serbia.
COUNT 6: Persecutions on political, racial
and religious grounds, a CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY,
including Murder, Cruel and Inhumane Treatment, Terrorising
the Civilian Population, Destruction of Personal
Property, and Forcible Transfer, punishable under
Articles 5(h) and 7(1) and VINKO PANDUREVIC and LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN under Article 7 (3), of the
Statute of the Tribunal.
COUNT 7
(Forcible Transfer)
By their acts and omissions described in the preceding
paragraphs, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, RADIVOJE MILETIC,
MILAN GVERO, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN
POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD TRBIC and LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN committed:
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, RADIVOJE MILETIC, MILAN
GVERO,VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA,
VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD
TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN, together
with other VRS and MUP officers and units
and RS officials, as identified in this
Indictment in Attachment A,
were members of and knowingly participated
in a Joint Criminal Enterprise, and Operation,
the common purpose of which was to force
the Muslim population out of the Srebrenica
and Zepa enclaves to areas outside the
control of the RS from about 8 March 1995
through the end of August 1995.
The Operation to Remove the Muslim Population
from Srebrenica and Zepa
- On
8 March 1995, RS President Radovan Karadzic
issued Operational Directive 7 from the
Supreme Command of the VRS. Directive 7
was drafted by RADIVOJE MILETIC.
This Directive ordered "complete the physical
separation of the Srebrenica and Zepa enclaves
as soon as possible, preventing even communication
between individuals between the two enclaves.
By planned and well-thought-out combat
operations, create an unbearable situation
of total insecurity, with no hope of further
survival or life for the inhabitants of
Srebrenica or Zepa." (See Attachment
B to this Indictment for a detailed
outline of the structure of the RS Armed
Forces relevant to these facts).
- Continuing in March 1995 through July 1995
the VRS deliberately restricted humanitarian
aid and relief supplies to the Muslim inhabitants
of Srebrenica and Zepa as part of the organized
effort to make life impossible for the Muslims
and remove them. RADIVOJE MILETIC, under
the command of Ratko Mladic played
a central role in organizing and facilitating
the effort to restrict aid and supplies to
the Srebrenica and Zepa enclaves.
- Continuing in March 1995 through the fall
of the enclaves in July 1995 the VRS shelled
and sniped various civilian targets in the
Srebrenica and Zepa enclaves, as part of
the effort to make life for the Muslims in
the enclave impossible and remove them.
- On 3 June 1995, VRS forces attacked United
Nations observation post (OP) Echo as a prelude
to the major attack on the enclave. On 2
July 1995, Drina Corps Commander General
Milenko Zivanovic ordered the attack on the
Srebrenica enclave with the purpose to separate
the Srebrenica and Zepa enclaves and reduce
the Srebrenica enclave to its urban area.
The purpose of reducing the enclave to its
urban area was to force the Muslim population
into the small town of Srebrenica and thereby
create conditions where it would be impossible
for the entire Muslim population to sustain
itself and require its departure from the
area.
- On or about 6 July 1995, pursuant to General
Zivanovic’s order of 2 July 1995, units of
the Drina Corps shelled Srebrenica and attacked
OPs manned by the UN Dutch Battalion (DutchBat),
which were located in the enclave. Among
the Drina Corps units engaged in the attack
were elements of the Zvornik Brigade commanded
personally by VINKO PANDUREVIC. On
9 July 1995, President Karadzic modified
the original order and approved the takeover
of the Srebrenica enclave. The order was
transmitted by General ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR to
General Radislav Krstic and General MILAN
GVERO at the Drina Corps Forward Command
Post. The Drina Corps attack on the Srebrenica
enclave, including the shelling, and attacks
on other UN Ops, and Muslim civilian targets
in Srebrenica continued through 11 July 1995,
when forces from the Zvornik Brigade, the
Bratunac Brigade, the 10th Sabotage
Detachment, and other units of the VRS entered
Srebrenica. On 11 July 1995, NATO planes
dropped bombs in an attempt to stop the VRS.
Despite these efforts, Srebrenica fell to
the VRS on 11 July 1995.
- Immediately after the fall of Srebrenica
on 11 July 1995, in the late afternoon, senior
VRS officers including Ratko Mladic, Milenko
Zivanovic, Radislav Krstic, VINKO PANDUREVIC, and VUJADIN
POPOVIC entered the town.
- On 10 and 11 July thousands of Bosnian
Muslims from the enclave, including women,
children, and some men, fled to the UN Compound
in Potocari, where they sought the protection
of the DutchBat. Meanwhile, at the same time,
approximately 15,000 Bosnian Muslim men from
the enclave, with some women and children,
gathered at the villages of Susnjari and
Jaglici and fled on 11 July in a huge column
through the woods towards Tuzla. Approximately
one third of this group consisted of armed
Bosnian Muslim military personnel. The rest
were civilians and unarmed military personnel.
- On the evening of 11 July 1995 and the
morning of 12 July 1995, three critical meetings
concerning the fate of the refugees who had
fled to Potocari took place at the Hotel
Fontana in Bratunac. At the first meeting,
held at approximately 2000 hours on 11 July,
Ratko Mladic, and a Main Staff Intelligence
officer, Colonel Radoslav Jankovic met with
other members of the VRS and with the DutchBat
command. Ratko Mladic intimidated
and threatened the DutchBat commander.
- Ratko Mladic, Radislav Krstic, Radoslav
Jankovic and other members of the VRS convened
the second meeting at approximately 2300
hours on 11 July 1995. Members of the DutchBat
command and a representative of the Bosnian
Muslim refugees at Potocari attended the
meeting. At this second meeting, Ratko Mladic
intimidated and threatened the Bosnian Muslim
representative. During the evening of 11
July 1995 and into the early morning of 12
July 1995, the plan to transport the Srebrenica
Muslims from Potocari was developed by General
Mladic and his staff.
- Ratko Mladic, Radislav Krstic, Radoslav
Jankovic, VUJADIN POPOVIC and other
VRS and Bosnian Serb civilian representatives
convened a third meeting at about 1000 hours
on 12 July 1995. DutchBat officers and representatives
of the Bosnian Muslim refugees also attended
this meeting. At this meeting, it was explained
that the VRS would supervise the "evacuation" of
refugees from Potocari and that Ratko Mladic
wanted to screen men between the ages of
16 and 60 to determine whether there were
any war criminals among them.
- The Bosnian Muslim refugee population remained
in and around Potocari from 11 July until
13 July 1995. Throughout this time, members
of the VRS and the RS Ministry of Internal
Affairs (MUP) terrorised them.
The Operation to Forcibly Move out the Muslim
Population
- In the afternoon of 12 July 1995, in the
presence of Ratko Mladic, Radislav Krstic, VUJADIN
POPOVIC, LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN and others,
approximately 50 to 60 buses and trucks arrived
near the UN military compound in Potocari.
At this time and continuing throughout the
entire day of 13 July, thousands of Bosnian
women, children and elderly men were loaded
on busses and trucks and transported by the
Bosnian Serb forces from Potocari to the
confrontation line near Kladanj, where they
were released and walked the approximately
5 kilometres to BiH Army held lines outside
Kladanj. MUP Special Police forces under
the command of LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN worked
together with elements of the Bratunac Brigade
and other VRS units in moving the Srebrenica
population out of the enclave.
- On the afternoon of 12 July, as the Bosnian
Muslim women, children, and men started to
board the buses and trucks, MUP Special Police
forces under the command of LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN and
VRS soldiers separated over 1000 able bodied
Bosnian Muslim men from the women and children
and transported these men to temporary detention
sites in Bratunac. The separation of able
bodied men from the crowd in Potocari continued
all day on 12 and 13 July, until the entire
Muslim population had been removed from the
area of Potocari.
- Between 12 July 1995 and about 17 July
1995, approximately 6000 Bosnian Muslim men
from the column of men escaping the Srebrenica
enclave were captured by or surrendered,
to MUP forces, under the command of LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN and
VRS forces, including the Military Police
company of the 65th Protection
Regiment of the Main Staff, supervised by LJUBISA
BEARA, in the Nova Kasaba, Konjevic Polje,
and Kravica areas. The majority of the prisoners
captured from the column on 13 July 1995
were taken to the same temporary detention
sites in and around Bratunac as those men
separated from Potocari. On 13 July LJUBISA
BEARA was present in the area of Nova
Kasaba co-ordinating the capture and surrender
of Muslim men. Those Bosnian Muslim prisoners
who were temporarily detained in Bratunac
on 12 and 13 July were thereafter transported
to the Zvornik area between 13 and 15 July
1995.
- Beginning around 12 July 1995 and continuing
through about 16 July 1995, members of the
VRS and the MUP confiscated and destroyed
personal property and effects belonging to
the Bosnian Muslim male prisoners, including
their identification documents and valuables.
This confiscation and destruction of personal
property and effects occurred in Potocari,
at various points of capture and collection
of men from the column along the Bratunac/Milici
road, and at various execution sites. In
addition, the prisoners in Potocari and in
Bratunac were not provided with food or medical
treatment, nor with any meaningful rations
of water, during their days in detention
pending execution. During this time, the
Muslim prisoners held in Potocari and Bratunac
were frequently beaten by their captors.
The Zepa Operation
- In early July 1995, at the same time as
it was attacking Srebrenica, the VRS made
preparations to attack the Zepa enclave and
force the Muslim population from the that
enclave. The VRS began firing on UN positions
around Zepa on 7 July 1995. They fired directly
on a UN checkpoint on 9 July 1995 and on
the town of Zepa on 10 July 1995. On 11 July
1995, the VRS shelled a village at Zepa.
- Three separate negotiations took place
between the VRS and Bosnian Muslim representatives
of the Zepa enclave, where VRS representatives
sought to force the population to leave the
enclave under threat of military attack.
The first set of negotiations took place
on 13 July 1995. At this meeting, the Rogatica
Brigade Commander, Colonel Rajko Kusic, accompanied
by General ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR and local
Bosnian authorities, met at the established
Ukrainian UNPROFOR checkpoint overlooking
Zepa. The Bosnian Serbs said that "Srebrenica
had fallen and so now it was [Zepa’s] turn."
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR offered the Bosnian
Muslim representatives of Zepa two alternatives:
either the entire population could be "evacuated" in
the same manner as Srebrenica or the Bosnian
Serbs would take military action. The Bosnian
Muslim representatives decided to reject
the Serb proposal as it stood. In the early
morning of 14 July 1995, the VRS command
launched a full scale attack on the Zepa
enclave. This attack was commanded by Drina
Corps Commander Radislav Krstic and included
elements of various Drina Corps brigade including
elements of the Zvornik Brigade commanded
personally by VINKO PANDUREVIC. In
the evening of 14 July 1995, Bosnian Serbs
entered the pocket from the north-west and
retook some land and burned villages. On
the morning of 15 July 1995 VINKO PANDUREVIC and
his troops were withdrawn from the Zepa operation
and sent back to the Zvornik area to assist
in the defence of Zvornik that had been threatened
by the advance of the Muslim men from Srebrenica.
- On 19 July 1995, the Serb shelling and
firing on Zepa stopped. Ratko Mladic met
with UNPROFOR General Rupert Smith at Han-Kram. ZDRAVKO
TOLIMIR and VRS Colonel Indjic accompanied
General Mladic. At the meeting, they discussed
Srebrenica, including the withdrawal of DutchBat,
the situation at Zepa, and the freedom of
movement for UNPROFOR and UNHCR. General
Mladic asserted, incorrectly, that Zepa had
fallen at 1330 hours that day.
- The second round of negotiations between
the VRS and the Bosnian Muslim representatives
of the enclave occurred on the afternoon
of 19 July 1995 at the Ukrainian checkpoint.
General Mladic and ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR met
with three members of the Bosnian Muslim
local civil authority. The VRS position required
that the Bosnian Muslims were to surrender
their arms under the control of the UNPROFOR,
and their names would be registered. They
were to be held by the Serbs as prisoners
of war, until exchanged within 5 to 15 days.
General Mladic gave a guarantee of their
safety. When the parties reached no agreement,
the VRS resumed its attack on Zepa on 21
July 1995.
- The third set of negotiations took place
on 24 July 1995. A Bosnian Muslim representative
of the Zepa enclave, Hamdija Torlak, was
present, as were General Mladic, Rajko Kusic,
the Commanding Officer of the Rogatica Brigade,
and ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR. At around 1830
hours on 24 July 1995, an agreement was reached
regarding Zepa.
- The transportation of the women and children
of Zepa began on 25 July 1995. On or about
the same day, hundreds of mostly able-bodied
Muslim men began to flee across the Drina
River to Serbia where many of them were registered
by the International Committee for the Red
Cross (ICRC) and eventually released. The
Muslim men fled to Serbia because they feared
they would be harmed or killed if they surrendered
to the VRS.
ROLE AND ACTIONS OF THE ACCUSED IN FURTHERANCE
OF THE JOINT CRIMINAL ENTERPRISE AND OPERATION
TO FORCIBLY TRANSFER AND DEPORT THE SREBRENICA
AND ZEPA MUSLIM POPULATION
- In order to achieve the goal of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation, as expressed
in Directive 7, to force the Muslim populations
of Srebrenica and Zepa to leave the area,
several actions were carried out, including
but not limited to the following:
- Making life unbearable for the inhabitants of
the enclave;
- Defeating the Muslim forces militarily;
- Disabling the local UN forces militarily;
- Preventing and controlling outside international
protection of the enclaves, including air strikes
and international monitoring; and
- Controlling the movement of people out of the
enclaves.
- Members of the Joint Criminal Enterprise
and Operation made life unbearable for the
inhabitants of the enclave by:
- Shelling civilian targets in Srebrenica and Zepa;
and,
- Controlling the movement of people out of
the enclaves:
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
1, 10, 27, 31, 34 to 38, 54, 66 to 70, 83,
88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment)
- Making life unbearable for the inhabitants
of the Zepa enclave:
- in July 1995 he proposed to General RADIVOJE
MILETIC that the refugee columns of Muslim
population from Zepa be attacked.
- Defeating the Muslim forces militarily:
- he communicated with the Drina Corps
Forward Command Post and RS President Radovan
Karadzic about combat operations around
Srebrenica and the decision to take over
Srebrenica; and,
- in July 1995 he proposed to General RADIVOJE
MILETIC to destroy the remaining
Muslim army from Zepa by using chemical
weapons.
- Disabling the local UN forces militarily:
- he assisted in disabling the UNPROFOR in
the attack on Srebrenica through his communications
with UNPROFOR, specifically by lying to UNPROFOR,
and coordinating lies with subordinate units.
- Preventing and controlling outside international
protection of the enclaves, including air strikes
and international monitoring:
- he organised and led the psychological and
propaganda activities related to the operations
in Zepa and Srebrenica.
- Controlling the movement of people out of the
enclaves:
- he gave orders related to and coordinated
the forcible transfer of men, including civilians,
from the Srebrenica and Zepa enclaves;
- he helped to coordinate the detention of
prisoners from Srebrenica.
- he took part in negotiations with Muslim
representatives at Zepa and gave them the choice
between "evacuation" or VRS "military action";
and,
- he helped to organise and oversee the transportation
of the population of Zepa, including by assembling
the buses and loading people onto the buses.
- RADIVOJE MILETIC, acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
2, 11, 31, 50 to 51, 74(a)(i), 74(b)(ii),
83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
- Making life unbearable for the inhabitants
of the enclave:
- he drafted Directive 7, which was signed
by President Karadzic on March 21, 1995 and
called for the VRS to inter alia "create
an unbearable situation of total insecurity
with no hope of further survival or life for
the inhabitants of Srebrenica and Zepa" and
ordered that; "The relevant State and military
organs responsible for work with UNPROFOR and
humanitarian organisations shall, through the
planned and unobtrusively restrictive issuing
of permits, reduce and limit the logistics
support of UNPROFOR to the enclaves and the
supply of material resources to the Muslim
population, making them dependent on our good
will while at the same time avoiding condemnation
by the international community and international
public opinion; and,
- he took part in and helped implement the
policy set out in Directive 7 to restrict humanitarian
aid to the Muslim populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa.
- Defeating the Muslim forces militarily:
- he monitored the state of the Muslim forces
before, during and after the attacks on Srebrenica
and Zepa and communicated this information
to his superiors, including President Karadzic,
and subordinate units;
- he monitored the surrender of Muslim forces
after the fall of Srebrenica and Zepa and communicated
this information to his superiors, including
President Karadzic, and subordinate units;
and,
- he monitored the activities of VRS units
in the Srebrenica and Zepa areas and communicated
this information to his superiors, including
President Karadzic, and subordinate units.
- Controlling the movement of people out of the
enclaves:
- he monitored the progress of the transfer
of the civilians of Srebrenica and Zepa and
communicated this information to his superiors,
including President Karadzic, and subordinate
units;
- he monitored VRS efforts to search and clear
Zepa of any remaining Muslims and communicated
this information to his superiors, including
President Karadzic, and subordinate units;
and,
- he was kept informed of the flight of the
Muslim men from Zepa to Serbia.
- MILAN GVERO, acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
3, 12, 31, 54, 83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this
Indictment):
- Defeating the Muslim forces militarily:
- he released to the public media a false statement
concerning the attacks on the enclaves in order
to assist in the take-down of the Srebrenica
enclave; and,
- he assisted in the attack on the Srebrenica
enclave from the Drina Corps Forward Command
Post on 9 July 1995 and advised General Krstic
on the ongoing operation.
- Disabling the local UN forces militarily:
- he assisted in the attack on Srebrenica knowing
that one of the main objectives was to force
the Muslim population to leave Srebrenica by
lying to UNPROFOR about Muslim attacks, in
particular on UN observation points, and VRS
intentions and actions with respect to the
enclave; and,
- he kept RS President Radovan Karadzic informed
of his communication with the international
forces.
- Preventing and controlling outside international
protection of the enclaves, including air strikes
and international monitoring:
- he threatened and pressured an UNPROFOR commander
in an attempt to stop air strikes; and,
- after the fall of the Srebrenica enclave,
he lied to international representatives in
order to block the UN’s and other international
organisations’ access to Srebrenica.
- Controlling the movement of people out of the
enclaves:
- he helped to organise and coordinate the
capture and detention of Muslim men from Srebrenica;
and,
- he facilitated and oversaw the movement of
wounded Muslims from Srebrenica.
- VINKO PANDUREVIC, acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
4, 13, 27, 30.6, 30.8 to 30.15, 31, 32, 34
to 37, 39, 54 to 55, 67, 80(a)(iii), 83,
88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
a. Defeating the Muslim forces militarily:
i. he commanded and ordered forces
involved in the attack on the Srebrenica
and Zepa enclaves from 6 July 1995through
14 July 1995, knowing one of the main objectives
of the attack was to force the Muslim
population to leave the Srebrenica and
Zepa enclaves.
b. Controlling the movement of people
out of the enclaves:
i. he had knowledge of and assisted
in the forced movement of able bodied Muslim
men from Srebrenica to detention centres
in the Zvornik Municipality from 13 July
1995through 15 July 1995; and,
ii. he assisted the forcible movement
of Srebrenica men by authorizing Zvornik
Brigade forces to receive, detain and
guard several thousand Bosnian Muslim men
in the zone of responsibility of the Zvornik
Brigade, knowing those men had been forcibly
removed by RS authorities from the Srebrenica
enclave.
- LJUBISA BEARA acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
5, 14, 27, 31, 34 to 37, 40, 63, 83, 88 and
90 to 91 of this Indictment):
a. Controlling the movement of Muslims out of
the enclaves:
- he planned, organised and assisted
in the gathering together, detention and transportation
of Muslim men from Srebrenica along the Konjevic
Polje - Milici road Srebrenica on 13 July1995;
- he assisted in the transportation
and organisation of Muslim men from Bratunac
to detention centers in the Zvornik area, specifically
the schools at Orhaovac, Petkovci, Rocevic
and Kula and the Pilica Cultural Centre, from
13 through about 16 July 1995;
- he participated in the effort by General
Krstic to capture Muslim men fleeing from the
Zepa enclave over the Drina River to Serbia
on about 1 and 2 August 1995; and,
- as Chief of Security for the Main Staff Corps,
and by virtue of the authority vested in him
by his commander, Ratko Mladic, he had
responsibility for the handling of all of these
Bosnian Muslim prisoners and to ensure their
safety and welfare. He failed to do so.
- VUJADIN POPOVIC acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
6, 15, 27, 30.5, 31, 32, 34 to 37, 41, 55,
59, 61, 83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
- Controlling the movement of Muslims out of
the enclaves:
- he was a participant at the meeting at the
Hotel Fontana at 10:00 hours on 12 July 1995
with General Mladic and his staff, DutchBat
officers, Muslim representatives from Srebrenica-the
purpose of which was arrange for the departure
and transportation of the Muslims to leave
Srebrenica and to intimidate the Muslims so
they would leave the Srebrenica area;
- he was present on duty in Potocari on 12
July supervising and overseeing the transportation
of Muslims from Potocari to areas outside of
the RS;
- he assisted in the transportation and organisation
of Muslim men from Bratunac to detention centres
in the Zvornik area, specifically the schools
at Orahovac, Petkovci, Rocevic and Kula and
the Pilica Cultural Centre, from 13 July to
16 July 1995;
- as Assistant Commander of Security for the
Drina Corps, and by virtue of the authority
vested in him by his commander, VUJADIN
POPOVIC had responsibility for the handling
of all of these Bosnian Muslim prisoners and
to ensure their safety and welfare. He failed
to do so.
- DRAGO NIKOLIC acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
7, 16, 27, 30.6, 30.14 to 30.15, 31, 32,
34 to 37, 42, 83, 88 and 90 to 91 of this
Indictment):
- Controlling the movement of the Muslims out
of the enclaves:
- he assisted in the planning, organising and
supervising of the transportation of Muslim
men from Bratunac from 13 through about 16
July;
- he assisted in the transportation and organisation
of Muslim men from Bratunac at detention areas
in the Zvornik area including the schools at
Orahovac, Petkovci, Rocevic, Kula and the Pilica
Cultural Centre, from 13 July through 16 July
1995;
- as Chief of Security of the Zvornik Brigade,
and by virtue of the authority vested in him by his
commander, VINKO PANDUREVIC he had
responsibility for the handling of all of these Bosnian
Muslim prisoners and to ensure their safety and welfare.
He failed to do so.
- LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
9, 18, 27, 30.4, 31, 34 to 37, 43, 61 to
63, 83, 88 and 90 to 92 of this Indictment):
- Disabling the UN forces militarily:
- he commanded MUP forces on 12 July 1995 who
forcibly entered the UN enclave at Potocari
and along with VRS forces, took military control
of Potocari and the DutchBat based there; and,
- he was present in Potocari on 12 or 13 July
commanding troops who assisted the VRS in disarming
DutchBat troops in and around Potocari.
- Controlling the movement of the Muslims out
of the enclaves:
- on 12 and 13 July he commanded troops who
assisted the VRS in organizing the transportation
on busses and trucks of Muslim women and children
to areas outside the VRS. He was present in
Potocari on 12 and 13 July and commanded MUP
troops there who assisted the VRS in securing
and controlling the Muslim population. As a
commander he had responsibility
for the handling of all of these Bosnian Muslim
prisoners and to ensure their safety and welfare;
- on 12 and 13 July he was present in Potocari
and commanded troops there who assisted the
VRS in detaining and transporting Muslim men
from Potocari to detention centres outside
the enclave to the town of Bratunac; and,
- on 13 July he was present along the Bratunac
- Konjevic Polje Road and commanded troops
there who assisted the VRS in capturing, detaining
and transporting to detention sites outside
the enclave, thousands of able bodied Muslim
men and boys from Srebrenica.
- MILORAD TRBIC acting individually
or in concert with other members of the Joint
Criminal Enterprise and Operation to forcibly
transfer and deport the populations of Srebrenica
and Zepa and knowing that forcing the Muslims
out of the enclaves was unlawful, committed
acts in furtherance of the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation including but not
limited to the following (see also paragraphs
8, 17, 27, 30.6, 31, 32, 34 to 37, 44, 83,
88 and 90 to 91 of this Indictment):
- Enclaves:
i. on 13 and 14 July 1995 he assisted in
organizing the transportation, detention and
security of Muslim men from Srebrenica transported
in busses and trucks from Bratunac to detention
sights in schools in the Zvornik area, including
Orahovac, Petkovci, Rocevic, Kula and the Pilica
Cultural Centre.
Joint Criminal Enterprise III (Extended Format)
and Co-Perpetration
- It was foreseeable to ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR,
RADIVOJE MILETIC, MILAN GVERO, VINKO PANDUREVIC,
LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC,
MILORAD TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN, that
individual criminal acts, such as individual
opportunistic killings and persecutory
acts as described in paragraphs 31 and
48 of this Indictment, would be carried
out by Serb forces during the Joint Criminal
Enterprise and Operation to forcibly transfer
and deport the populations of the Srebrenica
and Zepa enclaves. The term "opportunistic" is
used in this Indictment to describe killings
and other criminal acts carried out by
individual soldiers, acting on their own,
likely without orders from superior officers.
COUNT 7: Inhumane Acts (Forcible
Transfer), a CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY,
punishable under Articles 5(i) and 7(1) and VINKO
PANDUREVIC and LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN under
Article 7 (3), of the Statute of the Tribunal.
COUNT 8
(Deportation)
By their acts and omissions described in
the preceding paragraphs, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR,
RADIVOJE MILETIC, MILAN GVERO, VINKO PANDUREVIC,
LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC,
MILORAD TRBIC and LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN committed:
- The crime of Deportation was perpetrated,
executed, and carried out by and through
the following means:
- the forced movement of Bosnian Muslim men from
Zepa, across the Drina River to Serbia, by means
of making life unbearable in the enclave by restricting
aid to the enclave and instilling fear and terror
in the population by shelling civilian areas and
attacking the enclave, killing the Muslim men,
as described in paragraph 71 of this Indictment.
COUNT 8: Deportation, a CRIME AGAINST
HUMANITY, punishable under Articles, 5(d) and
7(1) and VINKO PANDUREVIC and LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN under Article 7(3), of the Statute
of the Tribunal.
GENERAL ALLEGATIONS
- At all times relevant to this Amended Indictment,
a state of armed conflict existed in the
Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
- At all relevant times, the accused was
required to abide by the laws and customs
governing the conduct of war.
- All acts and omissions charged as crimes
against humanity were part of a widespread
or systematic attack directed against the
Bosnian Muslim civilian population of Srebrenica
and its surroundings.
INDIVIDUAL CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY
Article 7 (1) Criminal Responsibility
- Pursuant to Article 7(1) of the Statute
of the Tribunal, ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, RADIVOJE
MILETIC, MILAN GVERO, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA
BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGAN NIKOLIC, MILORAD
TRBIC and LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN are
individually responsible for the crimes charged
against them in this Indictment. Each of
them committed, planned, instigated, ordered,
and otherwise aided and abetted in the planning,
preparation, and execution of these charged
crimes, as set out in detail in this Indictment.
The term "committed" as it is used herein,
includes two forms of Co-perpetration, namely:
88.1 Joint Criminal Enterprise - as described
in this Indictment, includes membership of at
least two persons in a criminal enterprise with
an agreement to achieve the criminal objective,
and
88.2 Direct and/or Indirect Co-Perpetration -
does not require membership in a criminal enterprise
or plan, nor an agreement, In Direct/Indirect
Co-Perpetration each accused is responsible as
a co perpetrator for his participation in the
crimes charged, based on his own acts, whether
individually or jointly with others, in participating
knowingly, with criminal intent, directly and/
or indirectly, with or without an agreement,
through or by way of his subordinates or other
persons, in the commission of the crimes charged
including inter alia, communicating, organizing,
co-ordinating, facilitating, or providing supervision
or failing to act in furtherance of the crimes
charged.
- Both Joint Criminal Enterprise and Direct/Indirect
Co-Perpetration, while representing separate
forms of criminal liability, identify the
same set of facts, that is the criminal endeavor
to force the Muslim population from the Srebrenica
and Zepa enclaves and murder all the able
bodied men captured from the Srebrenica enclave,
as described in the Indictment. As used in
this Indictment the term "Operation" is used
in conjunction with Direct and/or Indirect
Co-Perpetration to identify the facts upon
which liability under Direct/Indirect Co-Perpetration
is based. Joint Criminal Enterprise and Operation
are identified separately in this Indictment
because the Joint Criminal Enterprise necessarily
includes membership in a criminal enterprise
and agreement, whereas the facts of the Operation
can be viewed without a criminal enterprise
and agreement.
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA
BEARA, VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC,
MILORAD TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN had
knowledge of the plan to murder the able
bodied Muslim men of Srebrenica and were
involved in the execution of that plan.,
Each accused possessed the criminal intent
and state of mind required to commit the
individual crimes charged (See Attachment
C to this Indictment for the requirement mens
rea for each crime) in the Indictment
related to this plan, and their acts significantly
assisted and facilitated the commission
of the crimes. The participation of the
accused in the Joint Criminal Enterprise
to murder the able-bodied Muslim men of
Srebrenica and the specific acts and responsibilities
described in this Indictment satisfy the
elements required for a finding that, pursuant
to Article 7(1) of the Statute of the Tribunal, ZDRAVKO
TOLIMIR, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA,
VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD
TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN "committed," "planned," "instigated," "ordered," and
otherwise "aided and abetted" genocide,
crimes against humanity (including murder,
persecutions, forcible transfer, and inhumane
acts), and murder as a violation of the
laws or customs of war.
- ZDRAVKO TOLIMIR, RADIVOJE MILETIC, MILAN
GVERO, VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA,
VUJADIN POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD
TRBIC AND LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN had knowledge
of and were involved in the implementation
of the plan to make life unbearable for
the Muslim population of Srebrenica and
Zepa and forcibly remove them from the
enclaves to areas outside the RS. Each
accused possessed the criminal intent and
state of mind required to commit the individual
crimes charged in the Indictment related
to this plan, and their acts significantly
assisted and facilitated the commission
of the crimes. The participation of the
accused in the Joint Criminal Enterprise
and Operation to remove the Muslim population
and the specific acts and responsibilities
described in this Indictment satisfy the
elements required for a finding that, pursuant
to Article 7(1) of the Statute of the Tribunal, ZDRAVKO
TOLIMIR, RADIVOJE MILETIC, MILAN GVERO,
VINKO PANDUREVIC, LJUBISA BEARA, VUJADIN
POPOVIC, DRAGO NIKOLIC, MILORAD TRBIC AND
LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN "committed," "planned," "instigated," "ordered," and
otherwise "aided and abetted", crimes against
humanity (including murder, persecutions,
forcible transfer, and inhumane acts),
and murder as a violation of the laws or
customs of war.
- As a separate and independent basis of
liability under Article 7(1), LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN’S presence at or near mass
execution sites described in paragraphs 30.4
and 43(a)(iii) of this Indictment, together
with his failure to intercede in order to
protect prisoners who remained alive at the
execution site, instigated, assisted and
aided and abetted the perpetrators of the
killings, in that his presence served as
encouragement and incitement to the physical
perpetrators of the Kravica executions who
continued to kill prisoners during and after LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN presence at the site of the
executions.
Article 7 (3) Criminal Responsibility
- VINKO PANDUREVIC and LJUBOMIR BOROVCANIN are
also, or alternatively, criminally responsible
as Commanders for the acts of their subordinates
pursuant to Article 7(3) of the Tribunal
Statute. Such criminal responsibility is
the responsibility of a superior for the
acts of his subordinate if he knew or had
reason to know that his subordinate was about
to commit such acts or had done so and the
superior failed to take the necessary and
reasonable measures to prevent such acts
or to punish the perpetrators thereof.
- The criminal acts of the subordinates of VINKO
PANDUREVIC for which he is responsible
include but are not limited to the actions
described in paragraphs 39 and 77 of this
Indictment.
- The criminal acts of the subordinates of LJUBOMIR
BOROVCANIN for which he is responsible,
include but are not limited to the actions
described in paragraphs 43 and 81 of this
Indictment.
All in violation of Articles 3, 4(3), 4(3)(b),5
(a), 5(b), 5(d), 5(h), 5(i), 7(1) and 7(3), of the
Statute of the Tribunal.
Dated this 28th day of June 2005
The Hague, The Netherlands
______________
Carla Del Ponte
Prosecutor