UNITED
NATIONS GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
SUMMARY BY THE
PRESIDENT OF THE
FIFTY EIGHT SESSION
OF THE UNITED NATIONS
GENERAL ASSEMBLY
OF THE OPEN-ENDED PANEL ON COMMODITIES OF 27 OCTOBER 2003
TO THE SECOND COMMITTEE
3 NOVEMBER 2003
Thank you Mr. Chairman.
Delegates:
General Assembly decided,
in resolution 58/2, that a report should be presented to the Second Committee
on the outcome of the Open-Ended Panel on Commodities, convened on 27
October 2003. Having opened and presided over the Open-ended Panel on
this issue of critical importance, particularly for developing countries,
I am now pleased to present that Report.
The Report of the
Meeting of Eminent Persons on Commodity Issues (A/58/401) convened in
Geneva on 22-23 September 2003 under the auspices of UNCTAD, and the summary
of the discussion at the Recent Trade and Development Board on the Report
of the Eminent Persons (A/58/15 [Part V], provided invaluable input into
the deliberations of the Open-ended Panel.
In remarks made at
the opening of the Panel, your Chairman, Ambassador Iftekhar Ahmed Chowdhury,
underscored the link between the deliberations of the Panel and the consideration
of Item 91(g) on commodities by the Second Committee. His remarks placed
the commodities issue into perspective, in the context of the development
of commodity-dependent countries in the global economy. Mr Rubens Ricupero,
Secretary-General of UNCTAD, gave a summary of the findings of the Meeting
of Eminent Persons.
Four of the fifteen
Eminent Persons who participated in the important UNCTAD commodities exercise
- Ambassador Jorio Dauster, Mr. Roman Grynberg, Mr. Irfan ul Haq and Mr.
Martin Kohr - were the Panellists. The Panellists provided details of
the results of their deliberations set out in the Report, as their initial
input into to the interactive discussion that followed. Mr Mark Ritchie,
President of the Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy, was invited
to open the Panel's interactive discussion.
As the Report of the
Meeting of Eminent Persons was important to focussing the deliberations
of the Panel, it would, I believe, be useful to recall some of its pertinent
elements. The Report contains fifteen recommendations for action. These
are arranged in three groups - those to be addressed in the short-term,
those to be addressed in the medium term, and those to be addressed in
the long-term. The Report also makes five specific recommendations to
which the Eminent Persons attach the highest priority, particularly in
the context of follow-up by the General Assembly. These are:
a) Enhanced, equitable
and predictable market access for commodities of key importance to developing
countries;
b) Addressing the
problems of oversupply for many commodities;
c) Making compensatory
financing schemes user-friendly and operational;
d) Strengthening capacity
and institutions; and
e) Pursuing the possibilities
for the creation of a new International Diversification Fund.
The presentations
of the Panellists and the interactive discussion that followed covered
a broad range of issues relating to the commodities issue. Among the interesting
and notable perspectives emerging from the presentations of the Panel,
and taken up in the course of the interactive discussions, was that the
commodities issue is, at the same time, an "old" issue and a
"new" issue. In this context, the Panellists emphasised the
longstanding dependence of numerous developing countries on a few commodities
for a major part of their income and export earnings. For these countries,
the performance of commodities markets has a major impact on their macroeconomic
stability, capacity to meet foreign debt obligations, balance of payments
performance, success in poverty reduction, and overall sustainable development
efforts.
Increased and sustained
efforts to solve problems associated with commodity markets, including
price declines and volatility, over dependence on a handful of commodities
for export revenues and oversupply was regarded as critical action that
had to be taken. In this context, improving competitiveness and ensuring
better participation in global supply chains was considered to be key.
Panellists and participants
identified a number of macro-economic patterns of central importance,
that make the commodities issue a 'new' one, requiring renewed attention
by the international community. Pertinent "new" matters, together
with comments/issues raised in the context of the Panel discussion, and
which are particularly important to the deliberations of the Second Committee
were:
a) Commodities
and Sustainable Development: A new regime for commodity dependent
countries was considered to be essential to long-term sustainable development.
b) Commodities
and Millennium Development Goals (MDGs): Attaining the objectives
of the MDGs would continue to be a serious challenge in those countries
contending with widely varying or declining income due to over dependence
on the export of a single commodity, and had to be addressed.
c) Commodities
and reduction of market participants: The Panellist, in particular,
noted that that the structure of the commodity markets of most developing
countries is now marked by a significant reduction in market participants,
and because of that change, there has been a strengthening of the relative
position of multinational firms in each commodity sub-market.
d) Commodities
and HIPC: For many HIPC countries, the completion point and other
markers of the HIPC debt initiative are crucially dependent on accurate
forecasts for national revenues from the export of commodities. When the
forecast is not met, the entire HIPC programme is undermined.
e) Commodities
and the WTO: The Doha Programme of Work contains but a single paragraph
on commodities. There was only one explicit commodity item - on cotton
- on the Agenda of the recent WTO Ministerial held in Cancun, Mexico.
Regrettably, that the WTO process was not even able to address the urgent
demands of these West African countries on this single commodity.
f) Commodities
and vulnerabilities: ECOSOC is now grappling with the definition of
vulnerabilities in the context of LDCs; Every indication is that one key
component of that definition might well be the vulnerabilities of countries
to the external structural realities in the commodity markets;
g) Commodities
and SIDS: This session, the Second Committee is preparing for the
review of the Barbados Programme of Action for SIDS, and for the event
for conducting that review, now scheduled for August 2004. A crucial matter
for the economic viability of the SIDS is in many cases their dependency
on a single commodity for export, a matter that should be addressed in
the preparatory process and in the Conference.
h) 'Newer commodities':
In earlier consideration of the commodities issue, it was taken by
Governments that commodities referred to trade and processing of natural
products, minerals and agricultural goods. Today, 'commodities' could
now include industrial products and services that are marketed as if there
were 'old' commodities. Such is the case in with commodities, such as
computer chips and commodity service providers.
Panellists and participants
went beyond noting newer aspects of the commodities issue to flag new
ways that intergovernmental cooperation could contribute to a resolution
of challenges in this area. They emphasised, in that context, that developing
countries alone could not solve the problems in commodities markets arising
from global market imperfections. A viable and long-term solution requires
action by individual countries, as well as joint actions by consumers
and producers of commodities, from developing and developed countries
alike.
Suggestions for future
action in the commodities area and for enhancing the visibility of the
issue included the involvement of a range of international organizations
and possible action these organizations could take. Concerned organisations
and proposed courses of action, as well as action that might be taken
in the context of the MDGs and UN Global Compact include:
(a) The WTO:
calls were made for the resumption of the Doha negotiations, and for giving
special attention in the negotiations for cotton and other commodities;
(b) The IMF:
the connection between structural adjustment programmes and commodities
and the importance of a well functioning compensatory finance systems
was noted, and it was urged that these matters be considered;
(c) UNCTAD: the
need to enhance capacity building initiatives, establish new multi-stakeholder
partnerships on commodities, and examine in detail the inter-relationship
between national development and the global market, was stressed by panellists
and participants alike. These are important themes for UNCTAD XI, to be
held in Brazil in 2004;
(d) The MDGs:
it was proposed that commodity-dependency matters should be considered
in the implementation of the MDGs
(e) The UN Global
Compact and individual commodity firms and their trade associations: Panellists
and participants alike identified as a matter for urgent action incorporating
a commodity focus into on-going corporate social responsibility efforts.
A member of the Panel,
additionally, stressed that a long-term solution might be to take a new
look at the establishment of an international export diversification fund.
Regarding keeping the commodities issue under long term consideration,
it was proposed that the Open-Ended Panel on Commodities might be maintained
as a standing advisory group on commodity matters.
The Commodity issue
is of importance to millions of people around the world. There is an urgent
need, now more than ever, to address it. Importantly, one Head of State
commented in his address to the General Debate that there is a "conspiracy
of silence" on the commodities issue. It is instructive, in that
regard that the sub-item on commodities, discussed under the topic of
macro-economic issues, is a biennial topic in the Second Committee.
Also, in the Doha
programme of work for the WTO, the commodities issue is mentioned in one
paragraph only. Cotton received attention at the Cancun Ministerial Meeting
because of the insistence of four African producers. Over the years, the
work of UNCTAD, which established in the 1960s in part to deal with the
commodities issue, has been severely curtailed. Now, public understanding
of the commodities issue needs to be strengthened, resources allocated
to the work on commodities need to be increased, and the visibility of
the commodities issue needs to be enhanced through international dialogue.
These were courses of action which Panellists and participants alike highlighted.
A comprehensive programme
of action by all relevant parties, including the private sector and NGOs,
is critical. The objectives of such a programme could include action for
enhanced, equitable and predictable market access; solutions to the oversupply
of commodities; user-friendly compensatory finance schemes; and technical
assistance to strengthen national capacity and institutions - including
assistance in dealing with the problems arising from commodity market
imperfections
The expert opinions
and recommendations of the Eminent Persons were very much appreciated,
as was the Secretariat support provided by the UNCTAD and the Financing
for Development Office in DESA. I take this opportunity to once again
thank them for their contribution.
Let me now conclude
by emphasising the importance that I personally attach to cooperation
in the commodities area, and particularly to practical solutions to address,
as a matter of urgency, the plight of commodity-dependent countries. Our
deliberations at this Fifty-eighth Session of the General Assembly have,
I believe, raised the profile of our work in this area. It remains for
us to sustain these efforts.
You will now move
to the next stage of your deliberations of sub-item 91(g) on commodities,
and particularly translating the deliberations of the Open-ended Panel
and other relevant reports and discussions into what I hope will be an
action-oriented, implementable resolution. Your Chairman has assured me
that he will give this matter his personal attention. Let me assure you
that I stand ready to work with your Chairman and to assist in any way
I can to forge consensus on the resolution, and on any other issues in
the area of commodities.
I thank you.
|