Press Kit on Small
Islands: Issues and Actions
New York, 27-28 September 1999
Small Islands Press Release
Trade, Environment
Issues to dominate
UN Special Session on Small Islands
(New York, August 1999) -- Some forty small island nations will use
their two days in the global spotlight to seek international support on
trade and environment problems, when the United Nations focuses on
island issues at a special session of its General Assembly on 27-28
September in New York.
While island nations often conjure up images of
a paradise, their coasts, coral reefs and
forests are under increasing stress from
pollution, development, climate change and
natural disasters -- problems often beyond their
means or control to solve.
The UN special session -- to be attended by a number of island
Presidents and Prime Ministers -- will assess progress on the action
plan adopted by over 100 countries five years ago at the 1994 Global
Conference on the Sustainable Development of Small Island Developing
States, held in Barbados. There small island and donor nations agreed to
tackle the islands' challenges in partnership.
The difficulties small islands face in an increasingly competitive
global economy was a top issue at preparatory talks held this past April
at the UN Commission for Sustainable Development. Caribbean nations
protested recent rulings by the World Trade Organization against the
long-standing trade preferences for their bananas and other products in
European markets. Pacific island economies have suffered from the
financial crisis that has afflicted their Asian trading partners.
In light of their limited resources and options, island nations are
seeking some kind of compensatory mechanism or assistance while they try
to restructure their economies.
"Most small island developing states have taken positive steps since
Barbados", said UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, "but
international assistance to them has declined". He added, "If we can
find solutions to the special vulnerabilities of islands, it will help
us address more global problems.
The small islands action plan aims to strike a
balance for "sustainable development , which
promotes needed economic growth and improves
social well-being while preserving the
environment". This approach was popularized at
the 1992 Rio Earth Summit, which called for the
Barbados Conference.
Back to top
Financing the Action Plan
Island nations contend that, while they have taken the Barbados
action plan to heart, donor countries have lagged behind on their end of
the partnership. In line with global aid declines, official development
assistance to small island developing States has continued to fall since
1994, when the UN Conference generated a surge of interest. Net
disbursements for bilateral and multilateral aid combined have dropped
from $2.36 billion in 1994 to $1.96 billion in 1997.
Although the small islands action plan did not come with a price tag
attached, governments agreed in Barbados that to carry out the plan,
Aadequate, predictable, new and additional financial resources would be
needed. At the April preparatory talks, donors signalled they would
reaffirm this statement, but given global aid declines, there is a
pragmatic recognition that these may be promises on paper only. Gordon
Bispham of the Network for Barbados NGOs, a spokesman for small island
groups, considered it a key issue that Adonor nations have failed to
fulfil their commitments regarding this agreement. For their part,
donors suggest partnerships with the private sector and non-governmental
groups, better coordination and use of aid, and improved domestic
policies.
Ambassador Tuiloma Neroni Slade of Samoa, Chair of the Alliance of
Small Island States (AOSIS), said that while islands "hold high the
ethic of self-reliance, their acknowledged vulnerabilities and small
size mean that development challenges are often seriously magnified. The
support of the international community thus becomes a vital element in
sustainable development efforts".
Progress on Environment
Despite funding shortages, most small island nations have moved
forward on environmental protection as a result of the Barbados
Conference. Many have devised national green plans and set up
sustainable development councils or agencies. Dozens of projects have
been carried out nationally and regionally, but much more is needed.
Of the 14 problem areas identified in the small islands action plan,
six have been prioritized as needing urgent attention over the next five
years:
* adapting to climate change and rising sea levels, which could
submerge some low-lying island nations;
* improving preparedness for and recovery from natural and
environmental disasters;
* preventing worsening shortages of freshwater as demands grow;
* protecting coastal ecosystems and coral reefs from pollution and
overfishing;
* developing solar and renewable energy to lessen dependence on
expensive imported oil;
* managing tourism growth to protect the environment and cultural
integrity.
One contentious environmental issue in early talks has been the right
of small island nations to restrict or ban the transport of hazardous
and radioactive waste through their seas -- which was recognized in the
Barbados action plan. Small islands want to reaffirm this right, but
other proposals still under negotiation emphasize rights of free passage
and navigation.
Press Contact:
Ms. Pragati Pascale
Tel: (212) 963-6870
Fax: (212) 963-1186
Development and Human Rights Section
UN Department of Public Information
Published by the United Nations Department of Public Information
DPI/2063 -- August 1999 -- 5M
Back to top
Small Islands feature
Trouble in Paradise:
Small Islands Struggle to Preserve Environments
For the sun, sand and surf, tourists see small island nations as a
little corner of paradise. But the very development which brings
tourists and business to small islands is exacting a high toll on their
environments, spoiling the natural wealth which makes them so
attractive.
Small island nations, like all countries, are seeking the right
balance between economic development and environmental protection,
called Asustainable development. But because of the islands' smallness
and isolation, which seriously limit their options, and their
vulnerability to storms and economic shocks, the problems they confront
are particularly challenging and often call for solutions that are well
beyond their means to provide.
Recognizing this, in 1994 the United Nations held a Global Conference
on the Sustainable Development of Small Island Developing States, hosted
by Barbados. Over 100 countries adopted an action plan to guide island
nations and their donor partners in putting the small islands on a
better track. Now, five years later, the United Nations is holding a
special session of its General Assembly in New York on 27-28 September
to assess progress and boost support for the islands.
Some difficulties the islands face are global problems requiring
global solutions, such as climate change and shipment of hazardous and
radioactive waste through their waters. Small island nations are doing
what they can: signing onto the appropriate treaties and lobbying the
world's governments through the 40-nation Alliance of Small Island
States (AOSIS).
Local environmental problems, such as
pollution, population pressure, and natural
resource management and conservation require
local action, and the small islands have,
individually and as a group, embarked on a
number of programmes to promote sustainable
development. But despite good intentions,
because resources are limited, the ability of
the small islands to implement these programmes
often falls short.
Back to top
Rising Temperatures, Rising Seas
Climate change and sea-level rise, which may well pose the greatest
potential threats to the small islands, are problems far beyond the
small islands' control. In 1995, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change (IPCC) - a group of 2,500 leading scientists coordinated by the
United Nations - concluded that there had been between a 0.3 and 0.6
ー
-- rise in the mean surface temperature of the Earth since the
late nineteenth century. It also found considerable evidence that human
activities, such as burning petroleum, might be contributing to these
changes.
A generalized warming trend could lead to higher sea levels - since
water expands when heated and polar regions would melt - with possibly
disastrous consequences for small islands. While scientists are still
uncertain how much sea level might rise - IPCC projections range between
15 and 95 cm (6 and 37 inches) as soon as the year 2100, with a best
estimate of 50 cm (20 inches) - the problem is of acute concern to small
islands, which are particularly vulnerable since most of their
population lives in the coastal zones.
There have already been reports of extensive
coastal erosion on many islands. The South
Pacific Regional Environment Programme, a
regional group, contends that rising sea levels
have already swamped several Amotu or small
islets in Kiribati and Tuvalu, destroyed coastal
roads and bridges, and caused traditional burial
places to crumble into the ocean. In the Indian
Ocean, countries such as the Maldives have
expressed fears that almost 80 per cent of its
atolls, which barely rise above sea level, could
be completely inundated; and on the Seychelles,
it is estimated that a 100 cm (39 inch) rise
would erase 70 per cent of its land mass.
Back to top
The IPCC estimated that global warming could force developing
countries to spend about 0.43 per cent of their gross domestic product
to adapt to climate changes. It also found that Caribbean island states
could be forced to spend almost $1.1 billion on new construction to
protect against sea-level rise.
Climate change may affect small islands in other ways as well.
Temperature changes along with altered wind and rainfall patterns have
already created uncommon drought conditions in some Indian Ocean and
Pacific islands, although this may be partly related to the recent El
Ni phenemenon.
Small island developing States have concentrated their efforts on
lobbying the major industrial countries to curb emissions of the
greenhouse gases that are blamed for speeding up the warming process.
The small islands were among the first to ratify the United Nations
Framework Convention on Climate Change, and are strongly in favour of
its 1997 Kyoto Protocol, which sets legally binding emission limits for
the industrialized countries.
One way the Kyoto agreement may benefit small islands is through its
Aclean development mechanism, by which industrialized countries could
earn credits toward their emissions targets if their government agencies
or private corporations carry out emissions-reduction projects in
developing countries. Details of the mechanism are still being worked
out, but the island nations hope it could promote investment in solar
and renewable energy, which could in turn lessen their dependence on
expensive imported oil.
Oil, which tends to cost more in the small
islands than in other developing countries,
accounts for a large percentage of small island
imports - for example, almost a third of all of
Cuba's imports in 1995, and a quarter of the
imports for the Bahamas. Fuelwood, which is also
extensively used for energy, primarily for
cooking in rural areas, puts additional pressure
on forests and is not a long-term alternative,
though bagasse, made from sugar cane waste,
could be developed in some islands. Several
non-governmental organizations have stressed the
need to develop alternative, renewable energy
generation sources, such as solar systems that
can provide sufficient energy to run small
appliances.
Back to top
Protecting the Shoreline
Rising sea levels are not the only threat to the coastlines of small
island nations. Many islands are already experiencing a loss of
shoreline and beaches as a result of extensive mining of sand and coral
to meet construction needs. On some islands, such as Barbados, the
destruction of coral reefs has led to the complete erosion of beaches.
And in the past, unchecked construction of tourism facilities -- such as
marinas, jetties and artificial beaches -- along the coastlines of
Malta, Mauritius, Seychelles, Cyprus and other islands has led to the
degradation of fisheries, coral reefs, mangrove forests, sea beds and
dune systems. Other threats to the coastal region come from poor land
use, the destruction of mangroves and the discharge of agricultural,
industrial and sewage effluents.
Several small islands have adopted plans and programmes for
protecting and preserving their coastal regions. Cape Verde, Fiji and
Kiribati are among those that have developed plans, while Barbados,
which has suffered significant beach erosion in the past, has
established a special government unit to manage the coastal zone.
Virtually all of the small islands have signed on to the International
Coral Reef Initiative to monitor and study ways to improve the health of
the reefs.
The Global Environment Facility (GEF) has provided funds to 14 South
Pacific States to develop strategic action programmes to conserve and
manage coastal and ocean resources in a sustainable manner. These
islands have received close to US$20 million to implement their
programmes, with the GEF contributing US$12 million of the total.
Fishing, one of the most important means of
livelihood and sources of food on the islands,
has been threatened in some areas by depletion
of fish stocks and marine pollution. Island
governments have generally lacked the resources
and training to monitor and regulate fishing
practices -- both in inland waters, where local
artisanal fishermen work, and in offshore areas,
where foreign, industrial-size fleets often buy
fishing rights. Worldwide, it is estimated that
60 per cent of all commercial fisheries have
been depleted. Since the 200-mile offshore
exclusive economic zones (EEZs) of the small
island nations add up to about one sixth of the
Earth's surface area, better fisheries
management in the islands would be a significant
step toward improving global fish supplies.
Small islands have relied heavily on regional
cooperation, which has resulted in agreements
such as the South Pacific Tuna Treaty with the
United States.
Back to top
Preserving Unique Species
Surrounded only by the seas, small islands are home to some of the
most unique and diverse plant and animal species, a fact popularized by
the evolution theorist Charles Darwin after his studies in the Galapagos
Islands. Studies today indicate that the Western Pacific has the highest
marine diversity found anywhere, with some reefs harbouring up to 3,000
species. The region is also home to more critically threatened
species--110--than anywhere else. Large-scale logging, commercial
agriculture, mining and other land-clearing activities have diminished
many natural habitats. The most extreme example is Nauru, where
phosphate mining has carved out the interior of the island and destroyed
entire ecosystems.
Although subsistence farming still accounts for over half of all
agriculture on small islands, economic and population pressures are
forcing the introduction of more productive farming methods. Many fear
that this will open the door to crops with foreign genetic make-ups that
could overrun indigenous but low-yielding species.
Natural disasters also threaten biodiversity. Severe storms often
have a greater proportional impact on the biodiversity on small islands
than elsewhere due to the smaller land mass and smaller habitats. On
Montserrat, a frog known as the mountain chicken is believed to have
become extinct due to the acidification of standing water caused by the
volcanic eruptions that showered the island.
Most small islands, often with assistance from the United Nations
system, have taken steps to catalogue and preserve their biodiversity.
For example, the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) is helping
small islands to review, manage and conserve their forests, while UNESCO
is attempting to preserve the traditional knowledge of local
biodiversity. Many countries are using strategies to preserve
biodiversity that involve local community participation. Community
involvement was an important feature of a coastal management plan in the
Comoros, and in a project to protect marine turtles in the South
Pacific.
In the Bahamas, made up of 35 major islands covering an area of
100,000 square miles, a project to manage biodiversity data has resulted
in a governmental commission that is responsible for coordinating and
monitoring environmental and biodiversity activities.
Too often, however, the efforts of
international agencies and local governments in
the field of small island biodiversity are
hamstrung by a lack of resources, a lack of
coordination between different organizations,
and a lack of integration with other national
programmes.
Back to top
No Room for Expansion
Islands by their very nature are limited in size, and the amount of
land available for farming on the small islands is relatively small.
Growing populations are forcing more people to compete for this limited
land, and the result has been severe land degradation on many small
islands. Almost three quarters of the Pacific islands have cited land
degradation as a serious problem.
There is very little unused good arable land available in Fiji and
Samoa, and subsistence farmers have been forced to use marginal lands,
where the soil is poorer, or hillside slopes. The problem tends to get
worse in areas closer to the coast. Even in Papua New Guinea, where most
land is not under cultivation, large plantations tend to farm the land
intensively, also degrading the quality of the soil. Degraded land is
less productive and causes sedimentation problems in rivers and streams,
particularly near the coastal zones.
The continuing loss of forest cover on the small islands is also a
cause for concern. Population pressures, the elimination of traditional
land controls, pasture development and logging are among the factors
that have hastened forest destruction. In the Pacific, extensive logging
operations have deforested large tracts of land in Papua New Guinea and
the Solomon Islands, and forests are also under siege in the Cook
Islands, the Federated States of Micronesia, Samoa and Tonga. In
Micronesia, aerial photographs indicate that only 15 per cent of the
island of Pohnpei still has undisturbed forests, down from 42 per cent
in 1976. In the Caribbean, where many forests were originally cleared
for sugar and banana plantations, those existing now tend to be
secondary forests, which lack the rich biodiversity of old-growth
forests.
Waste management is also a major problem on small islands, since
there is limited space for landfill, and contamination of the
groundwater and surface and ocean waters results from sewage, industrial
effluents and agriculture. Tourism also taxes the small islands'
disposal and treatment facilities.
While many small islands have taken steps to manage their waste
problem, most do not have adequate waste management plans. Some efforts
have led to tangible results, such as the construction of sanitary
landfills in Seychelles and Mauritius, as well as on several Caribbean
islands. Barbados, Belize, Jamaica, Maldives, and Trinidad and Tobago
have, with donor assistance, embarked on programmes to upgrade their
waste management infrastructure.
The movement of hazardous and radioactive
wastes remains a serious concern to small
islands, who believe that the Basel Convention
on the Control of Transboundary Movements of
Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal is highly
inadequate. In talks leading up to the 1999
special session, small island nations have
sought to reaffirm their right, as agreed in the
Barbados action plan, to regulate, restrict or
ban imports of hazardous waste and to prohibit
shipment of hazardous and radioactive substances
through their waters, consistent with
international law. However, some industrialized
countries have sought to soften the wording of
the Barbados agreement.
Back to top
Meeting the Challenges
Since 1994, small islands have adopted many measures and have created
new government bodies to promote sustainable development and to
implement the Barbados Programme of Action. The Federated States of
Micronesia has established a President's Council on Environment and
Sustainable Development and in Fiji, a National Environment Strategy has
been developed and legislation has been adopted to carry it out.
Barbados has set up a national commission on sustainable development
that has representation from government ministries, the private sector
and other civil society groups. Barbados has also established a working
group on the management of hazardous wastes to develop legislation and
safety guidelines for the transport, storage and disposal of toxic
chemicals.
Mauritius has formed a national environmental commission, chaired by
the Prime Minister, to coordinate efforts by government authorities and
other organizations engaged in environmental protection programmes. In
Cyprus there has been an effort to use economic instruments as a tool to
upgrade tourism, as well as to encourage sound land-use practices and
proper coastal zone management.
In addition, regional island groups have been active in setting
strategies and carrying out region-wide projects to promote sustainable
development, and international organizations, such as the UN Development
Programme, have been giving support to national ministries and agencies
that actually implement programmes.
Yet for the small islands, the prognosis is always uncertain.
Although they have taken the Barbados action plan to heart, a major
hurricane or cyclone can erase years of work in hours. At present, there
are not sufficient resources to carry out all the programmes needed to
ensure that the environment is adequately protected.
Published by the United Nations Department of Public Information
DPI/2060 - July 1999 - 5M
Back to top
Small Islands Feature
On Trade and Aid:
Small Islands Face Economic Crunch
Long vulnerable to the forces of the seas, small islands are now
bracing themselves against the gathering forces of globalization which
threaten to alter dramatically the economies of many islands and hamper
efforts to promote sustainable development.
New developments in the push for greater trade liberalization have
served notice to small islands that the special trade preferences that
allow them to sell their traditional agricultural exports in developed
countries at protected prices will soon end. Without these trade
preferences, islanders have little hope that their products -- such as
coconuts, bananas, sugar and spices -- can compete in global
agricultural markets against larger-scale operations in other countries.
Five years after both developing and developed
countries agreed on a special plan to assist
small islands in pursuing sustainable
development at the Conference on Small Island
Developing States held in Barbados in 1994,
issues of trade and the effects of
globalization--while always important-- have
taken on a sense of urgency, as countries
prepare to review implementation of the Barbados
plan at a special session of the United Nations
General Assembly this September.
Back to top
The Trade Squeeze
Recent rulings by the World Trade Organization that some of the
islands' trade preferences violate free trade agreements have fueled
concern that small island economies will not have sufficient time or
resources to reinvent their economies before suffering a sharp economic
downturn. Tighter national budgets, it is feared, will inevitably lead
to fewer available resources for programmes to protect the environment.
Specks of land in the ocean, small islands are easily swamped in
today's world economy. Yet they rely on international trade more than
most countries, as their limited land mass and resources require that
they import virtually everything, from energy to health supplies to
machinery. Total freight costs as a percentage of import value for the
small islands were 55 per cent higher than for developed market-economy
countries in 1993, and by 1996, the disparity grew to as much as 66 per
cent.
This reliance on the outside world drives up the cost of living and
doing business for islanders, and makes it extremely difficult for them
to compete against lower-cost agricultural producers in other countries.
Furthermore, because of climate, soil and sometimes severe weather
conditions -- such as hurricanes in the Caribbean, cyclones in the
Indian Ocean, and typhoons in the Pacific -- small islands are often
limited in the types of crops they can grow.
Small islands have been able to sell their agricultural products in
many developed countries for more than the market price as a result of
several international agreements, often based on former colonial
relationships. These have included the Generalized System of
Preferences, which was negotiated under the General Agreement on Tariffs
and Trade (GATT), and a number of regional agreements. In particular,
under the Lom・Convention, a trade and aid pact often cited as a model of
north-south cooperation, the European Union agreed to import commodities
such as sugar from small islands and other African, Caribbean and
Pacific nations at a negotiated price--usually higher than prevailing
market rates.
The subsidies from these arrangements have helped sustain many small
island economies. In addition to bringing in valuable foreign exchange,
these agreements have also provided the islands with guaranteed access
to northern markets, which has been important for attracting foreign
investment for other ventures. In Mauritius, this guaranteed access to
markets has been credited as the determining factor in the establishment
of an Export Processing Zone that today provides jobs to more than
80,000 people.
Yet some have argued that the preferences have
lulled the islands into a false sense of
security that prevented them from either
diversifying or from adopting measures to remain
competitive in the global marketplace.
Back to top
Banana Wars
Although the small islands account for a very small portion of the
total banana market, the United States and several Latin American
countries filed complaints that the EU banana quota system harmed their
economic interests by preventing the sale of their bananas in European
markets. The WTO ruled that the US had a right to retaliate against the
EU in the amount of $190 million for the business that its companies
lost as a result of the banana quotas. Lost in the clash between the two
economic goliaths, however, is whatever sense of security the small
islands might have had. Islanders fear that the rush to trade
liberalization will mean that preferences for other agricultural
commodities and textile products may soon be threatened as well.
Small islands have strenuously opposed the WTO ruling because, they
say, it shows an unwillingness on the part of the world's major
multilateral organizations to respect, represent or consider the needs
of vulnerable developing states. They contend that the continuation of
trade preferences is vital in order to increase national income, job
creation, international competitiveness and sustainable development.
For banana-producing islands, particularly in the Caribbean, big
changes are imminent. Since bananas can be grown in many countries, the
elimination of a protected market will mean that the market will be
flooded with more bananas, which will drive prices down. Small island
growers will be hurt, since their production and labour costs are higher
than elsewhere.
If preserving the trade preferences is not possible, the small
islands are asking that some differential treatment or preferences be
maintained for a certain period of time, or that a mechanism be created
to compensate them in some way for their lost exports until their
economies are sufficiently restructured.
Negotiations are currently underway for a
successor to the Lom・Convention, and new terms
of trade between the small island developing
States and the developed nations are being
discussed. The EU has said that it will make an
effort to ensure that the Lom・talks, as well as
at the Millennium Round of multilateral trade
negotiations under the WTO, will reduce
remaining trade barriers and provide the small
islands with more secure access to export
markets for their products.
Back to top
Feeling the Pinch
The continued push for trade liberalization, combined with the steady
decline in the amount of official development assistance from donor
countries, is expected to have a major impact on sustainable development
in small island developing States. As national incomes decrease, island
governments will find themselves increasingly unable to carry out
programmes that protect the environment, and may be pressured to favour
short-term growth over long-term resource conservation. Declining
incomes may force already struggling islanders to overexploit land,
forests and fisheries, with resulting stress on the environment. In
Haiti, the poorest country in the western hemisphere, less than one per
cent of the country's forests remain.
Antigua and Barbuda has already begun to feel the pinch. As a country
where almost 70 per cent of the gross domestic product (GDP) is derived
from tourism, it enjoyed a high level of economic growth during the
1980s and early 1990s. But a series of four hurricanes, combined with an
influx of 3,000 refugees fleeing a major volcanic eruption in the
neighbouring island of Montserrat, contributed to a decline in the
island's fortunes. The government was forced to borrow heavily to repair
infrastructure damaged by the storms, and social and environmental
programmes were put on hold.
A downward economic spiral could reduce an island's attractiveness as
a vacation destination. Greater social tensions and a blighted
environment are also likely to keep tourists away. In the short term, as
a result of the banana dilemma, there are reports of farmers on some
Caribbean islands who are turning from banana production to the
cultivation of illicit drugs such as marijuana, which are much more
profitable. While virtually all small island governments have pledged to
crack down on the drug trade, most do not have the resources to
sufficiently curb the business.
A lack of opportunities will also spur further
migration from the small islands to developed
countries. This Abrain drain has long been cited
as a major obstacle for the islands in promoting
their economic development.
Back to top
Limited Options
While most small islands accept that they must restructure their
economies, this is a long-term process involving building new industries
and retraining major segments of the labour force. The choices are
difficult, expensive and limited.
The larger and more populous of the small island States have more
options, but for the smaller islands, such as Tuvalu and Antigua and
Barbuda, there are fewer possibilities. Donor countries have recognized
that these islands will continue to require ongoing development
cooperation.
Some islands might continue to compete in the global agricultural
market if they can distinguish their products--by growing bananas that
are tastier or environmentally or organically certified, for
example--and attempt to carve out a market niche. There are also
proposals to develop exports of Anatural products from the small
islands, such as the natural cosmetics made from coconuts which Dominica
sells abroad. Some islands, such as the Cayman Islands and Bermuda, have
become well known off-shore financial centres, and Jamaica has attempted
to market itself as a data servicing centre. But for the most part, the
small islands must look to something else.
They are handicapped in this search by a number of factors. Most
islands are not endowed with rich natural resources, and the need to
import materials and energy makes costs higher than elsewhere. It also
raises the general cost of living, which translates into higher wages
and labour costs. In addition, although islanders tend to have higher
levels of education than are found in other developing countries, their
small populations often lack the critical mass of skills necessary to
sustain an industry.
While private capital is playing a major role
in the current push towards globalization,
foreign direct investment in the islands has,
for the most part, targeted the tourism sector
-- which is no panacea.
Back to top
The prospects for tourism are good: the World Tourism Organization
predicts that globally, there will be a 300 per cent increase in the
number of tourists over the next 21 years, to 2021, and that
international spending by tourists will increase by 500 per cent over
the same period. Regional projections indicate that small islands will
substantially benefit from this global growth. Already tourism is one of
the largest industries on the small islands, and on many islands, it has
surpassed agriculture as the major foreign currency earner. Even though
many of the profits Aleak back to overseas investors, local benefits
have been considerable.
Yet tourism is a fair-weather industry, and its success is dependent
on many fluctuating factors, such as a good world economy, good weather
and stable social conditions. Small islands--and foreign investors
themselves--are wary of becoming too dependent on tourism, as it is
extremely sensitive to environmental degradation and economic shocks.
The Asian financial crisis, for example, has caused a significant drop
in the number of tourists visiting the Pacific islands. Major hurricanes
have had a deadly impact on tourism prospects for some Caribbean
islands, and have also prompted insurance rates to skyrocket.
One possible option for small islands might be
the exploitation of their exclusive economic
zones, or the 200 miles of waters surrounding
each island. Most small islands have been
unable, so far, to use these zones for economic
gain, as the costs of underwater mineral mining
are still prohibitive, and the islands have been
generally unable to police the fishing
activities in their waters. Alternatively, small
islands may turn to small and medium-size
enterprises in new areas, such as advanced
technology, book publishing and some textile
trades.
Back to top
Declining Assistance
Following global trends, official development assistance to small
island developing States has continued to fall since 1994, when the
Barbados Conference generated a surge of interest. Net disbursements for
bilateral and multilateral aid combined have dropped from $2.36 billion
in 1994 to $1.96 billion in 1997, the last year for which data is
available.
The levels of assistance that have been received by the small islands
have been far lower than anticipated, or needed, to implement the 1994
Barbados Programme of Action, which detailed the actions that were
necessary to achieve sustainable development in the small islands.
Although partnership efforts have lagged in some respects,
representatives of donor countries and small islands met in February
1999 to discuss possible avenues for future assistance. Responding to
donor demands that the islands prioritize their needs, representatives
from small island governments and regional organizations presented over
300 project proposals for assistance to implement the Barbados
Programme. Although small islands and donors both saw the meeting as
constructive, few commitments have resulted thus far.
Of the small islands, Papua New Guinea received the most bilateral
assistance in 1996CUS $350 million, followed by Haiti, the Netherlands
Antilles, and the Federated States of Micronesia. On the donor side,
Australia provided the most-- US $311 million, which mainly went to
Pacific islands-- and was followed by the United States, Japan, the
Netherlands, France, Italy and New Zealand.
Given worldwide declines in aid, the small islands are concerned that
their needs might be overlooked in the global picture, since the islands
generally have a higher GDP per capita than other developing countries.
For example, when the Maldives was removed from a UN list of the world's
poorest countries last year, it protested that its prospects for aid
would be reduced and that it would be deprived of certain benefits that
accrue to the poorest countries, such as interest-free loans, debt
write-offs and preferential market access. Samoa, Vanuatu and Cape Verde
have also been tapped as countries that should graduate from the list.
International financial institutions often rank
developing countries' needs by their GDP per
capita, which the small islands contend is not
an accurate gauge. Instead, they maintain that
they should be classified separately according
to a Avulnerability index that takes into
account their susceptibility to external factors
that could cripple an island's economy, such as
natural disasters and trade shocks. The index
would also take into account that small islands
have higher costs than other developing
countries, which impairs their international
competitiveness.
Back to top
The Search for Solutions
Limited development options, a lack of resources, and ever-present
threats from storms and the sea provide some serious challenges for
small island developing States. Increasingly, however, these countries
have found that there is strength in numbers, and they have banded
together to form regional and global groups, such as the 40-nation
Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS). Small islands in the Pacific
and the Caribbean are attempting to create larger regional markets, and
the Indian Ocean countries have joined together in an effort to solve
environmental problems.
Through cooperation among themselves, the islands have gained a
measure of political clout that has been most pronounced in the
negotiations on climate change, and they are now attempting to use this
cooperation to further their economic strategies. The small island
developing States hope that the UN General Assembly five-year review of
the Barbados action plan will once again focus global attention on their
needs and give new impetus to international efforts to foster their
sustainable development.
Published by the United Nations Department of Public Information
DPI/2061 - July 1999 - 5M
Back to top
Issues in Brief
Small Islands Five Years
Later: Where Do We Stand?
In 1994 in Barbados, over 100 countries adopted a Programme of Action
to assist small island developing States in pursuing sustainable
development. Now, five years later, at a special session of the UN
General Assembly on 27-28 September 1999, delegates from around the
world will examine progress since Barbados and discuss how the
international community can boost action in support of island nations.
The following summary gives the situation for each priority area
according to the chapters of the Programme of Action, as well as
progress since Barbados and some of the recommendations proposed --
either at preparatory talks or in reports by the UN Secretary-General --
for consideration at the special session.
1. Climate Change
The situation: Small islands are especially vulnerable to threats of
rising sea levels, as their populations are concentrated in coastal
areas. By the year 2100 sea levels could rise by 15-95 cm, with a Abest
estimate of 50 cm, if current trends continue, according to the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). The South Pacific
Regional Environment Programme (SPREP) cites anecdotal evidence of
islets submerging, burial grounds crumbling into the sea, salt water
intruding onto farmlands and beaches eroding in low-lying nations such
as Kiribati, Tuvalu and the Marshall Islands. The IPCC has estimated
that the costs of new construction for protection against sea level rise
in the Caribbean States alone would amount to US$1.1 billion. Moreover,
building sea walls would seriously interfere with lagoons and coastal
ecosystems.
Progress made: Gauges for monitoring sea level rise have been set up
in 11 South Pacific countries, funded by Australia. In the Caribbean,
the tide gauge monitoring network for the Global Oceanic Observation
System has been strengthened. Studies to assess where sea level rise is
likely to have the greatest impact have been carried out on 12 Pacific
and some Caribbean island nations. In 1997, the Global Environment
Facility (GEF) gave a $12.42 million grant to small islands for
adaptation to climate change. Most small island nations have ratified
the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. Talks are underway on how
small island nations can best utilize the mechanisms of the Kyoto
Protocol, which most have signed.
Action called for: Draft recommendations urge
the international community and small islands to
continue to improve island capacity to respond
to climate change. International support is
particularly required to identify adaptation
options.
Back to top
2. Natural and environmental disasters
The situation: Small island States are extremely vulnerable to
storms, the impact of El Ni and other natural disasters. Hurricanes
George and Mitch caused extensive damage in the Caribbean, $450 million
worth in Saint Kitts and Nevis alone. Fiji and Papua New Guinea were
among Pacific nations which suffered from severe droughts related to El
Ni. Tsunamis in Papua New Guinea following an earthquake killed over
2,000 people and destroyed homes and crops. Storm insurance costs in
many island nations are prohibitively high; on some islands, insurance
is simply not available.
Progress made: The South Pacific Disaster Reduction Programme, which
ran from 1994 to 1998, improved disaster management training. A special
group on natural disasters set up in 1997 under the Association of
Caribbean States is preparing a regional agreement for disaster
management.
Action called for: Draft recommendations call for further work on
reducing the impact of El Ni and natural disasters and on early warning
systems. They also urge partnerships between small islands and the
private sector to implement schemes to spread risks, expand insurance
coverage and reduce premiums.
3. Waste Management
The situation: Small islands typically lack waste disposal sites
because of a shortage of land and lack of capacity. High rates of
population growth and increases in tourism are generating more and more
waste. Because sewage treatment facilities are inadequate, poorly
treated effluent is often discharged into the sea, seriously affecting
the two main industries of small islands: tourism and fisheries. New
regulations have proven ineffective because island governments have
inadequate staff and resources to enforce them. Islands have little
capacity to deal with the growing volume of toxic and hazardous wastes.
Progress made: The private sector has become actively involved in
recycling plastics, metals, paper and used oil in some small islands.
Sanitary landfills have been built in Seychelles and Mauritius and are
under construction or being upgraded in several Caribbean and Pacific
nations. A number of countries, including Barbados, Jamaica, Maldives
and Trinidad and Tobago, have secured donor support to improve sewage
systems. SPREP is assessing the abilities of eight Pacific island
nations to manage chemicals. The Comoros, Mauritius, Seychelles and
Madagascar are improving their preparedness for oil spills with help
from the GEF, World Bank and International Maritime Organization, among
others.
Action called for: National priorities
identified in the Secretary-General's report
include improving waste management systems,
landfills and sewage systems; reducing the
volume of waste; setting up port reception
facilities for disposal of ship wastes; enacting
and enforcing government regulations on waste
disposal; and building long-term storage
facilities for hazardous waste.
Back to top
4. Coastal and Marine Resources
The situation: Two important coastal industries, tourism and fishing,
both require management to avoid deteriorating or depleting the
resources on which they depend. Common problems for islands include:
beach erosion, often due to mining of sand and coral; and loss of
shoreline, habitat degradation and marine pollution as a result of
development. Small islands often do not have the capacity to manage
fisheries in their exclusive economic zones (EEZs) C sometimes hundreds
of times the size of their land area. Since the EEZs of small island
nations equal about one sixth of the earth's surface area, improving
fisheries management would help significantly to stem the global decline
in commercial fish stocks, over 60 per cent of which are depleted
worldwide.
Progress made: Thirteen Pacific islands, with funding from the GEF,
have prepared a Strategic Action Programme for coastal, watershed and
fisheries management and have secured $20 million more to carry out the
plan. Barbados has set up a Coastal Conservation Unit which has produced
a draft coastal zone management act. The Forum Fisheries Agency of the
South Pacific provided technical support to small island States for
negotiation of the South Pacific Tuna Treaty with the United States. All
small islands have adopted a strategy under the International Coral Reef
Initiative, and most have networks to monitor the health of the reefs.
Action called for: Draft recommendations call for:
* establishment or strengthening of programmes to assess the impact
of development on coastal areas and reduce land-based pollution;
* policies to address fisheries problems, including illegal,
unregulated and unreported fishing in small island waters, and
strengthening of national capacity for negotiating fishing agreements
and promoting commercial investment in sustainable fisheries;
* regional coordination in monitoring fishing, including use of
computerized vessel tracking systems;
* community-based reef conservation and management, and initiatives
related to alternative livelihoods such as aquaculture and eco-tourism,
to build on the International Coral Reef Initiative.
In preliminary talks, small islands have sought
to reaffirm their right -- included in the
Barbados action plan -- to restrict or ban the
import of hazardous and radioactive waste and
prohibit its shipment through island waters,
consistent with international law. Some
recommendations have sought instead to call on
States to improve the safety of shipment of
hazardous and radioactive waste and emphasize
that the sovereign rights of small islands over
their EEZs should be in full conformity with
rights of transit passage and freedom of
navigation under the Convention on the Law of
the Sea.
Back to top
5. Freshwater
The situation: Many small islands face serious shortages of
freshwater, and have few options to remedy the situation. Surface water
and groundwater resources are very limited, particularly on volcanic or
atoll islands, while urbanization is both increasing demand and
polluting supplies. Small islands are especially vulnerable to drought,
low rainfall and saline intrusion. Developing water supply and
sanitation utilities is both technically difficult on island terrains
and financially unfeasible, given the small scale of island economies
and the expense of importing all equipment. Demand on water supplies is
also increasing for tourism and irrigated agriculture to grow market
crops.
Progress made: Pre-dating the Barbados Programme of Action, a major
regional water supply and sanitation project began in 1979 in the
Caribbean and in 1986 in the Pacific; both programmes continue under
regional environmental and scientific bodies. Since 1994, the UN
Environment Programme (UNEP), the World Meteorological Organization,
GEF, the UN Development Programme (UNDP) and the World Bank have
supported a number of projects on various aspects of improving water
supplies and sanitation. UNDP has helped Cape Verde prepare a national
water master plan and assisted Comoros in the delicate construction of
wells tapping coastal aquifers. The Asian Development Bank is financing
the set-up of water utilities in Micronesia. Bahrain has set up an
action plan to protect freshwater resources and modernize the
distribution network.
Action called for: Draft recommendations call
for improving assessment, planning and
integrated management of freshwater resources.
Back to top
6. Land Resources
The situation: Competing demands for very limited land need to be
resolved in a sustainable way. High population pressure, deforestation
due to logging or conversion to agriculture and resulting soil erosion
are among key factors. Traditional land tenure practices make management
difficult. Increased demands for cash income have led to greater
production of export cash crops and inappropriate tourism development,
with heavy impacts on the land.
Progress made: Among national efforts, Grenada introduced a
management scheme using a computerized land information system. Similar
work was done in Trinidad and Tobago and Saint Lucia. The Organization
of Eastern Caribbean States has asked the UN Food and Agriculture
Organization (FAO) for help in developing a land-use planning and
agricultural zoning mechanism. Software for classifying land by use has
been set up in Fiji, Tonga and Vanuatu. Samoa is awaiting approval of a
new land-use policy. Soil conservation and erosion control programmes
have been formulated in Jamaica and Barbados. National forestry policies
are being established in a number of Caribbean countries with FAO and
UNDP support, following a 1997 regional meeting. A three-year programme
is assisting 22 Pacific island nations in forest management.
Action called for: The report of the Secretary-General recommends
continued movement toward integrated land-use planning, using regional
sharing of expertise and international technical assistance.
7. Energy
The situation: The almost total dependence of small island States on
imported petroleum for their commercial energy needs continues to cause
severe imbalances in trade. Increased use of fuelwood, particularly in
rural areas, has led to much deforestation.
Progress made: There has been little or no progress in improving the
availability of energy services. Use of renewable energy, especially
solar PV systems, has increased in some small islands, especially in
rural areas, but this has been heavily subsidized by government or donor
agencies rather than developed on a commercial basis. The GEF provided
$7.1 million to small island States for environmentally sound energy
development; this has subsequently leveraged an additional $60 million
from other sources.
Action called for: Draft recommendations urge mobilization of
resources, including from the private sector, to encourage energy
efficiency and develop renewable energy, especially at the regional
level.
Back to top
8. Tourism
The situation: Tourism is an economic pillar of many small islands,
in many cases contributing more than one third of GNP, but unless
properly managed, it can damage the natural environment and unique
cultures which are the main attractions to tourists. In the wider
Caribbean, travel and tourism output is projected to grow at an annual
average rate of 3.6 per cent in real terms up to 2005 and to create 2.7
million jobs. An annual average growth rate of 8 per cent up to 2005 is
expected in Asia and the Pacific. Adverse impacts include marine
pollution from hotel and ship sewage, degradation of coastal zones,
stress on water supplies and local cultures, and substantial Aleakage of
profits to foreign investors rather than local entrepreneurs.
Progress made: Master tourism plans, regulations and environmental
impact assessments have been adopted in a number of small islands,
including Mauritius, Maldives and the Netherlands Antilles. Caribbean
countries have set a joint strategy for sustainable tourism. In Cyprus,
new economic instruments such as tax incentives are being used to
improve the quality of tourism.
Action called for: Draft recommendations call for regional and
national environmental assessment programmes to address the carrying
capacity for tourism, community-based initiatives, and mobilization of
adequate resources from all sources to assist in sustainable tourism
development.
9. Biodiversity
The situation: Biodiversity in small islands -- including many unique
species -- is under threat from pressures of population growth and
development, natural disasters and the introduction of alien species.
Progress made: A number of small islands have prepared national
biodiversity strategies and country studies under the Convention on
Biological Diversity. A review of biodiversity in small islands was
carried out by the World Conservation Monitoring Centre. The Bahamas has
developed a model Biodiversity Data Management Report and Plan.
Action called for: The report of the
Secretary-General calls for further
international support to enable small islands to
protect native species and their habitats,
control alien invasive species and implement the
relevant international legal conventions.
Back to top
10. National Institutions
The situation: Small islands often lack effective national
institutions to set and carry out plans for sustainable development.
Progress made: Since 1994, many small island nations have established
new national agencies or high-level policy-making bodies to set
priorities for sustainable practices, although they often lack resources
to enforce new legislation. In Micronesia, a President's Council on
Environment and Sustainable Development has been set up. In Fiji, a
National Environment Strategy has been formulated and legislation
drafted. National commissions on sustainable development or the
environment have been set up in Barbados and Mauritius. SPREP has
coordinated the preparation of national environmental management
stratagies in the Pacific region, with assistance from the Asian
Development Bank, UNDP and Australia.
Action called for: Draft recommendations call for renewed commitment
by small islands to complete national sustainable development strategies
before 2002, as agreed at the Earth Summit +5 session in 1997.
11. Regional Institutions and Cooperation
The situation: The limited resources of small island States and their
geographic isolation make regional cooperation especially important.
Progress made: In the Pacific, eight regional intergovernmental
organizations have been set up to focus on particular aspects of
sustainable development, under the umbrella of the newly established
South Pacific Organizations Coordinating Committee (SPOCC). The
Caribbean office of the UN Economic Commission for Latin America and the
Caribbean (ECLAC), in collaboration with CARICOM, has served as the
regional coordination mechanism to carry out the Barbados Programme of
Action. In the African region, the Indian Ocean Commission has been
actively engaged in implementation.
Action called for: Further strengthening of regional cooperation,
scientific programmes and training.
Back to top
12. Transport and Communication
The situation: Transport and communications are the lifelines linking
small island States with the outside world, but distance and isolation
have resulted in high transport costs and limited options for many
islands. Public and private monopolies, often by foreign companies,
result in high telecommunications costs. The quality and frequency of
international shipping and air services is largely beyond national
control.
Progress made: Since 1994, 32 out of 38 small island States improved
their Ateledensity, or the number of phone lines per 100 inhabitants,
with about 20 islands showing growth rates of 15 per cent or more. All
small island States except Niue and Tuvalu have established connectivity
with the Internet, although for most, access is limited to government
institutions and larger private organizations. A number of Caribbean
nations are using new communications technologies to develop
information-processing centres for North American businesses, with
potential for generating significant foreign exchange and jobs. Airport
improvements have been made or are underway in over ten small island
nations. In 1996 Caribbean nations, through CARICOM, adopted a regional
market access agreement to improve airline services and encourage
airline investment.
Action called for: The Secretary-General's reports recommend that
island nations give priority to improving rural telecommunications and
take steps to move telecommunications monopolies toward a competitive
environment. They suggest that international development partners should
help raise funds for telecommunications investment and that the World
Bank and regional development banks should increase lending in this
sector. More investment is also needed in infrastructure for shipping
and air transport.
13. Science and Technology
The situation: Most small island States lack a national scientific
infrastructure and trained personnel to meet their needs, and often lose
scientists through a Abrain drain. At the same time, traditional
knowledge about sustainable development is dying out for lack of
interest.
Progress made: Several UN agencies and programmes, including UNESCO,
UNIDO and UNDP, have projects to improve scientific training and
technology development in island regions.
Action called for: The Secretary-General's report recommends
subregional cooperation among islands in science education and
infrastructure development as the most realistic short-to-medium term
strategy for building scientific and technological capacity. Island
nations are encouraged to seek private domestic and foreign investment
in clean technologies.
Back to top
14. Human Resource development
The situation: With their small populations, island nations often
lack the trained personnel to pursue sustainable development. The
Seychelles identified lack of trained staff as the key factor preventing
effective management of national parks. In Haiti, no scientists or
engineers work full time in the environmental field.
Progress made: In recent years, all but one of the small island
States have made progress in developing human resources at the basic
level needed for building specialized technical skills for environmental
management. Cuba, Barbados and Mauritius have created centres or
programmes to promote environmental training and public awareness. In
the Bahamas and Jamaica, school curricula now include more instruction
about environment and sustainable development. UNDP, through its
Capacity 21 fund, has supported training in Pacific and Caribbean
islands, including on environmental law. Japan allocated $57.8 million
for 1994-1998 for upgrading education facilities in Pacific island
nations.
Action called for: Draft recommendations stress the need for
increased emphasis on capacity-building and education. The
Secretary-General's report suggests regional mechanisms for training,
and use of distance education and the Internet.
15. Implementation, Monitoring and Review
The situation: The Barbados Programme of Action, as well as Agenda
21, stipulated that successful implementation would require provision of
effective means including adequate, predictable, new and additional
financial resources. In all sectors, national and regional efforts
toward sustainable development have been constrained by limited
resources.
Progress made: Official development assistance
(ODA) to small islands peaked in 1994 at $2.36
billion but then declined to $1.96 billion in
1997, reflecting drops in aid levels worldwide.
Whereas in some developing countries, loss of
ODA has been partially offset by increases in
foreign direct investment, small island nations
often do not have economies of sufficient scale
to attract private capital. Many small island
nations find it increasingly difficult to obtain
concessional development finance because
criteria often focus on their relatively higher
per capita GNP without taking full account of
their actual levels of development, their
vulnerability or their capacity to generate
adequate national savings to meet needs for
large amounts of investment resources.
Back to top
Action called for:
1. Finance. Draft recommendations include a reaffirmation that
implementation of the Barbados Programme of Action will require
additional financing. They urge that projects be identified for GEF
financing and that the effectiveness of bilateral and multilateral
assistance be improved through better coordination. Draft
recommendations also suggest that donors give special consideration to
the over 300 project proposals presented by island nations at a February
1999 meeting between small islands and donors.
2. Globalization and trade liberalization. At preparatory talks,
small island nations have sought recommendations for some kind of
assistance, compensation or preferential treatment to strengthen their
position in the multilateral trading system, but no consensus has been
reached.
3. Technology transfer. Draft recommendations, noting that small
islands need access to low-cost environmentally sound technologies,
encourage information-sharing, participation in clean technology
initiatives, and public-private partnerships.
4. Vulnerability index. In view of the
usefulness of an index that would reflect
islands' small size, environmental fragility,
and susceptibility to natural disasters and
economic shocks, draft recommendations suggest
that the quantitative and analytic work on a
vulnerability index for small islands be
completed as soon as possible.
5. SIDSNET. Small islands have been closely
involved in setting up the Small Island
Developing States Network (SIDSNET), the
Internet site and listserve created by UNDP in
response to the Barbados Programme of Action.
Draft recommendations suggest that small islands
should enhance their Aownership of the Network
and that, with the assistance of the
international community, they should address
constraints to broadbased Internet access and
encourage private sector involvement.
6. International cooperation and partnership. Draft recommendations
suggest that existing institutional arrangements within the United
Nations system need to be strengthened and coordination improved to
support implementation of the Barbados Programme of Action. More
regional monitoring is needed, as well as benchmarks and indicators to
assess implementation.
Published by the United Nations Department of Public Information
DPI/2062 -- August 1999 -- 5M
Back to top
|