************************************************************** The material posted here was provided to the Division for the Advancement of Women by the Government in response to a note verbale. It is being made available in electronic format in the form received. In cases where it was not possible at this time to reproduce charts and tables supplied, these can be obtained by contacting the Division for the Advancement of Women directly. ************************************************************** CONTINUED PROGRESS NATIONAL REPORT ON THE STATUS OF WOMEN IN ISRAEL Submitted to the 41st Session of the commission on the Status of Women of ECOSOC March, 1997 (follow up to the fourth world conference on Women) TABLE OF CONTENTS Forward by the Prime Minister's Advisor on the Status of Women The Beijing Platform for Action Women and Poverty Education and the Training of Women Women and Health Violence Against Women Women and Armed Conflict Women and the Economy Women in Power and Decision-Making Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women Human Rights of Women Women and the Media Women and the Environment The Girl Child Forward by the Prime Minister's Advisor on the Status of Women - Emuna Elon This report summarizes actions taken by Israeli governmental agencies to promote progress towards implementation of the Beijing Platform for Action. As such, it is a follow-up to our previous report, "A Decade of Progress-The Israeli National Report to the Fourth World Conference on Women (1995)". The Platform for Action is intended to lead to full participation of women in political life and to an overall improvement in the economic, social, political, legal, and cultural status of women. In these pages, we present both the continued progress and the persistent impediments to achievement of this goal in Israel. Despite the prevalent image of lsrael as a gender-egalitarian society, reality is considerably more complex. The current status of Israeli women has been shaped by a number of historical and cultural trends. A young population with a high reproduction rate, a high proportion of women in the work force; a varied ethnic population including large numbers of immigrants, some indigent; a strong emphasis on traditional family values, and a complicated relationship between religion and state are among the socio-political forces which characterize Israeli society and which impact upon the status of women. Justifiably, Israeli women can he proud of the comprehensive body of progressive and empowering legislation which guarantees their equality in many areas of life; understandably, they are concerned about social norms and cultural dictates, which lag behind that legislation. Israeli politics are highly factitious, deeply polarized, and very uncertain. Yet, more than once, the women members of the Knesset have broken party ranks and voted together for the benefit of women. Israeli women have been remarkably able to create women's cross-party coalitions, even in the face of objections by the "father" parties. We are proud of this sisterhood. Despite the other issues which divide us, as women we are able to act concertedly to uphold our inalienable human rights. l he general elections in May, 199t, brought about a change of administration. The number of women parliamentarians in the 120-seat Knesset was reduced from 13 to nine. In contrast to the two women Cabinet Ministers in the last administration, only one woman currently serves in the Cabinet. However, for the first time, three women have been appointed as Director-Generals of government offices. Even more significantly, the newly-elected Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has pledged his commitment to the advancement of the status of women. In allied reports to the United Nations, many of Israel's more than 90 NGO's will detail their important activities. In the past, the myriad and varied activities sponsored by Israeli women's political and grass roots organizations have been uncoordinated, diffused, or even redundant. In response, the Knesset Permanent Committee on the Status of Women, together with almost all of the women's and feminist organizations in Israel, have proposed the establishment of a Statutory Authority for the Advancement of the Status of Women. This Authority will be responsible for the implementation of programs, nurturance of initiatives, and follow-up of recommendations. Prime Minister Netanyahu and the Minister of Justice have expressed their support for this initiative. Legislation, currently pending in the Knesset, is expected to pass in the near future. The overviews and summaries of achievements in this report relate only to women who are citizens of the State of Israel, and not to women who reside within the territories administered by the Palestinian Authority. I am hopeful that we will soon be able to cooperate in peace, to the benefit of ail of the women of the region. As the Prime Minister's Advisor in the Status of Women, it is my duty to place issues related to the status of women on the national agenda and to ensure that all government ministries are actively committed to the goal of greater equality for women. It is also my privilege to work closely with the women's NGO's and with the Knesset Committee on the Advancement of the Status of Women. I pledge to continue these efforts. I am confident that together with the many women from all walks of Israeli life who seek to improve their lives through commitment and empowerment, we will contribute to the creation of the just society to which we aspire. THE BEIJING PLATFORM FOR ACTION A. WOMEN AND POVERTY Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action: + Review, adopt, and maintain macroeconomic policies and development strategies that address the needs and efforts of women in poverty. + Revise laws and administrative practices to ensure women's equal rights and access to economic resources. + Provide women with access to savings and credit mechanisms and institutions. + Develop gender-based methodologies and conduct research to address the feminization of poverty. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today Israeli macroeconomic policies are intended to prevent poverty. The National Insurance Institute provides unemployment compensation or welfare allocations to unemployed persons and income supplements to families, in accordance with the number of children. Single parents are entitled to minimum income guarantees, and there is no work disincentive for mothers who are supporting children. Moreover, the National Insurance Institute has acted to reduce the economic dependency of women and children. As is well known, "dead-beat dads" who refuse to pay child support payments to their families are a major cause of the increasing feminization of poverty. Since the early 1970's, the National Insurance Institute has taken upon itself to make these payments, and it is then the Institute which prosecutes the recalcitrant fathers. Yet, according to all criteria, poverty exists in Israel and it is growing in both scope and depth. The percentage of Israeli women who subsist below the poverty line is much higher than that of men. Women are a majority amongst the unemployed and amongst the population on welfare. We cite here several reasons for this: A guaranteed minimal wage, set at one-half national average wage, is considered the first protection against poverty. However, women comprise more than 70% of those who earn less than the average minimal wage and whose salaries must be therefore supplemented by the National Insurance Institute. Furthermore, minimum wage legislation is poorly enforced, and lacks effective and accessible remedy mechanisms because government has not allocated adequate resources or personnel. Over 60% of Israeli women are concentrated in a small number of large, female-dominated, labor intensive, and low-paying occupations, which encompass less than 25% of the range of occupations in Israel Women, particularly in unskilled or semi-skilled positions with low seniority, are acutely vulnerable. Most women are hesitant to complain or press charges. Frequently, they are not even aware of their rights nor of the legal injustice done to them. Since the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948, less than fifty women have sought redress of discrimination in the labor courts. Several distinct groups of women are particularly vulnerable: Mizrachi women (that is, women born in North Africa or Western Asia or their descendants); Arab women (Moslem, Druze, Christian, and Bedouin) female-headed single-parent families; recent immigrant women (especially Russian and Ethiopian); and the elderly. Mizrachi women are over-represented development towns, where labor-intensive, low- and semi-skilled factory work (such as food-production and textiles) are the only jobs available. Wages are very low, and unemployment is a constant threat. Arab women are doubly marginalized and have fewer educational opportunities than Jewish women. The surfeit of unskilled Arab women laborers (especially in the Galilee) makes it easy for employers to exploit them and ignore their rights. A full 55% of Arab women live below the poverty line (compared to 12% of Arab men). All factors affecting the poverty of women in general have an even harsher effect upon single-parent families headed by women. Approximately 9% of all families in Israel are single-parent families. Twenty-three percent of single-parent families live below the poverty line, but 85% of these are headed by a woman. Since its establishment in 1948, the State of Israel has made tremendous efforts to absorb immigrants from throughout the world; in many cases, these efforts have included dramatic airlifts and extensive covert operations. Frequently, these measures have been-literally-life-saving. Many new immigrants come to Israel with few resources. Approximately thirteen percent of the new immigrants from Russia and the CIS are single-parent families, the overwhelming majority of whom are headed by women. Despite efforts by the Ministry of Absorption, they are unfamiliar with Israeli laws and norms. Unable to find employment, poorer immigrants must subsist on National Insurance Institute supplements; however, these supplements are not sufficient to enable them to live in central locations. The immigrants must therefore move to peripheral areas, where jobs are scarce and educational standards are lower. Thus, a pattern of unemployment and dependence is instituted and perpetuated. Some impoverished immigrants may soon form a new Israeli underclass. Ethiopians are even further disadvantaged, as their previous cultural and economic milieu have left them ill-prepared for the industrial and post-industrial reality of the Israeli economy. Older women are often forced into poverty because their pensions are lower, due to fewer years of full-time work and less over-all pay. Until recently, women were required to retire at age 60 (compared to age 65 for men), thus further limiting the number of years they could earn wages and the benefits they could later receive. Most women who work in their homes were not covered by the National Insurance Institute, without pension plans; this situation was redressed in late 1995. As a result of these difficulties, recent legislation and regulations have been aimed at reducing poverty in Israel. In 1992, the Single Parents Law was enacted, strengthening the protection for single-parent families with low income by increasing the level of means-tested benefits and awarding day care and child-education grants and priority in vocational training. In 1994, the Law for the Reduction of Poverty and Income Disparities was passed, providing for means-tested benefits to the elderly and other economically-vulnerable groups. Since the number of elderly women living in poverty is greater than the number of men (due both to women's greater poverty and greater longevity), the Law for the Reduction of Poverty and Income Disparities is expected to help women even more than men. Recently, the analysis of the contribution of women's unremunerated work to the national economy has received public attention, but no concrete action has been taken. Thus, in sum, Israel's macroeconomic policies and structure fail to take a gender and family perspective into account, despite Israel's overtly "pro-family" social policies. There are numerous initiatives and mezza-level programs, but women are not yet considered as a distinct constituent group in the economy. Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + Israel has recently passed its 1997 budget. The initial budget proposal included several measures which would have been very detrimental to women's economic conditions, including payments for medical visits, a decrease in universal monthly child allotments and a cancellation of an income tax benefit accorded to working married women. Due to the efforts of the Knesset Social Welfare Lobby, composed of members of both the coalition and the opposition. together with representatives of women's and social rights NGO's, these proposals were defeated. The coalition is expected to continue its efforts and to monitor the implementation of the budget, in order to guarantee that poverty in Israel does not expand in either scope or depth. + In late 1995, the National Insurance Law was amended to stipulate that all residents of Israel, including housewives, will be eligible for old-age insurance in their own right. + In 1995 and 1996, the Ministry of Construction and Housing, through its Neighborhood Rehabilitation Program, began a series of 40-hour workshops for women who have never worked outside of their homes. The workshops provide personal empowerment and interpersonal skills, together with basic employment proficiencies; upon completion of the workshop, the women are referred for vocational assessment and counselling. Sixty-five percent of the graduates have found permanent employment. + The Ministry of Construction and Housing also conducts series of 40-hour upgrading workshops, including personal and professional skills, information and rights, and consciousness raising and empowerment. These workshops target women who are already employed outside of their homes and who seek more permanent or higher-level employment. + Last year, the Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare sponsored a series of subsidized, minimal-cost courses for unemployed adults, during which they continued to receive their unemployment insurance. Forty-five percent of the participants were women; 11% of them Arab (Christians, Moslems, and Druze). + The Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare sponsored a series of courses for displaced clerical and secretarial workers, providing them with up-to-date computer skills and other necessary proficiencies. Almost all participants were women; 70% of them have been able to find suitable employment subsequent to completion of the course. + The Ministry of Labor also conducted series of courses in areas with high unemployment, providing information regarding employment opportunities in each area. Seventy-five percent of the participants were women.+ An amendment to the alimony and child-support law is currently pending in the Knesset; this law will determine levels of payment according to a pre-defined formula, thus reducing judicial deliberation and expediting the legal procedure. B. EDUCATION AND TRAINING OF WOMENStrategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Ensure equal access to education + Eradicate illiteracy among women + Improve women's access to vocational training, science and technology, and continuing education + Develop non-discriminatory education and training + Allocate sufficient resources for and monitor the implementation of educational reforms + Promote life-long education and training for girls and women An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today Two sets of legislation have contributed to ensuring that women in Israel will receive adequate education: the determination of age seventeen as the minimum age for marriage of girls; and legislation mandating compulsory education for all until age 16. Thus, over-all levels of illiteracy and semi-literacy in Israel today are very low, even among minority populations, and they are drastically lower than levels in the neighboring countries. Community centers, sponsored by the Ministry of Education, provide literacy and adult education programs to both Jewish and Arab adults. The Ministries of Education and Labor and Welfare provide education, training, and retraining programs for older women. In the past, these programs were criticized by women's organizations, who contended that they trained women for traditionally female, unstable, low-paying, non-lucrative positions (such as cosmetics and low-skilled clerical) and that they therefore perpetuated occupational and educational segregation. More recently, these programs have included additional, less-traditional retraining (such as computer technology, drafting, and graphics). An extensive system of nurseries and day care centers, with means-tested discounts, is provided by women's NGO's, the cost of which is subsidized by the Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs. Nearly 85% of Jewish children and 55% of Arab children attend pre-school by age 4. Compulsory education begins at age five. Participation in the primary and secondary educational system is very nearly universal. However, among non-Jewish girls, there is a high drop-out rate from secondary education. In some of the ultra-Orthodox Jewish secondary schools, girls are not provided with a full curriculum. They are thus prevented from completing their matriculation exams and are denied eligibility for entrance to the university. (University education in general, and for women in particular, is considered unacceptable by the ultra-Orthodox community.) By and large, Jewish and Arab children attend different primary and secondary schools. Despite attempts in recent years to further equality, tremendous differences between Arab and Jewish schools persist with regard to public expenditures, infrastructure, teacher-qualifications, etc. There are also extensive discrepancies between the levels of education in the larger cities and in the development and peripheral areas. Both the previous and the current administrations have declared their commitment to achieving equality between the sectors. Despite the separate school systems, Arab children in Israeli schools do learn about Jewish culture and tradition. Jewish children may learn Arabic if they choose, but it is not compulsory. The Ministry of Education sponsors coexistence programs in which Arab and Jewish children meet. An examination of pedagogic practice and materials reveals extensive gender bias. For example, in many schools, girls are discouraged from pursuing the traditionally male-dominated fields of science and math. This and other manifestations of gender bias are the target of a new, innovative, and comprehensive program for Gender Equity in Education, co-sponsored by a woman's NGO and the Ministry of Education. There is some indication of implicit ethnic tracking. especially of Mizrachi girls and Ethiopian immigrants; this perpetuates the underclass-status of many Mizrachi families and creates a new immigrant underclass. This problem has been the specific target of a number of women's NGO's. In recent years, the proportion of expenditures by the Ministry of Education has decreased significantly. This has led to increased demands that parents pay for extracurricular activities and, in some schools, even for materials and programs which are nominally part of the compulsory educational curricula. For large or poor families, these payments are a tremendous financial burden, and often the children suffer when the parents cannot meet the schools' financial demands. While the overwhelming majority of teachers are women, women are almost totally absent from the higher levels of educational administration and management. The numbers of women attending university has continued to increase; at this time, nearly 50% of the students entering institutions of higher learning are women. However, few women hold senior faculty positions in the universities or other institutions of higher education. Gender studies departments exist in all the universities, but they are poorly funded and offer few tenure positions. It is axiomatic that the school systems both reflect and shape the surrounding society. The previous administration had avidly supported the inculcation of gender and ethnic equity throughout the educational system, and the current administration has reaffirmed this commitment. Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + In 1994, the Ministry of Education adopted a pilot program designed by a woman's NGO to eliminate gender-bias in formal education. This program, the first of its kind in the country, emphasizes gender equality throughout the entire educational system, in all subjects, through the use of appropriate techniques and training and the elimination of sexist and stereotypic teaching materials. The program also includes a course in gender equality for all teachers, as well as on-going-in-service teacher training + In September, 1996, the program was implemented in five primary schools around the country. + The position of Supervisor of Gender Equality in the Ministry of Education has been reconfirmed. It is the Supervisor's responsibility to monitor textbooks and other teaching materials and to serve as an ombudsman. + The Ministry of Education had submitted a plan calling for mandatory pre-school education and a longer school day to the government. (Currently, compulsory education begins at age five and the elementary school day ends in the early afternoon.) However, due to the extensive budget cuts, this plan will not be implemented in the next three years, with the exception of several depressed, development locations.+ During 1996, the Ministry of Education sponsored approximately 15 InService Training programs for teachers, principals, and other education professionals. + The Supervisor of Gender Equality in the Ministry of Education has prepared a text and guide for teachers regarding gender equality in education. It was distributed to all schools in the country. The Supervisor has also produced a video on the needs of working parents, in order: to heighten teachers' and principals' sensitivity and awareness.+ In 1997, a self-guiding kit on gender equality will be distributed to kindergarten teachers throughout the country. C. WOMEN AND HEALTH Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Increase women's access throughout the life cycle to appropriate, affordable, and quality health care, information. and related services. + Strengthen preventive programs that promote women's health. + Undertake gender-sensitive initiatives that address sexually transmitted diseases, HIV/AIDS, and sexual and reproductive health issues. + Promote research and disseminate information on women's health + Increase resources and monitor follow-up for women's health. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today The National Health Law ensures health insurance, based on progressive payments, to all Israeli citizens. Israel has an extensive system of primary and secondary health care and adequate medical facilities are available in peripheral as well as central areas. Coverage is comprehensive and inclusive, including, for example, pregnancy and childbirth; termination of pregnancy (under stipulated conditions-see below); chronic mental and physical disabilities; and acute and chronic hospitalization and treatment. Inoculations against 40 diseases are covered by insurance and administered almost universally. All drugs distributed by pharmacies and physicians in Israel have passed standard testing procedures. However, very little attention is paid to prevention, education, encouragement of healthy behaviors, and other actions to minimize health risks and disease, especially in the area of reproductive health and contraception. This is especially true among the indigenous minority populations. While some schools do offer programs in family planning and contraceptive education, this is not universal. The Israel Defence Forces do provide such programs to both male and female conscripts. By law, a woman is entitled to make the decision to terminate a pregnancy, and she need not consult with-nor does she need the consent of any other individual. Minors do not need the consent of a guardian. Abortion is available at the approval of a committee, which is convened only at the woman's request. The committee is empowered to grant this request in four specified circumstances, including: the woman's age (women under 17 or over 40 are automatically granted the right to terminate the pregnancy); jeopardy to the life or welfare of the woman; pregnancy which results from rape, incest, or extra-marital relations; and when congenital defects in the fetus have been detected. With regard to jeopardy to life or welfare of the mother, empirical evidence shows that the authorities are cognizant of the psychological damage which can ensue as a result of forcing a woman to carry an unwanted pregnancy to term. It should be noted that successful illegal abortions, which are widely performed, are rarely prosecuted. In a recent precedent-setting decision by the High Court of Justice, a woman was granted the right to use fertilized eggs. despite objections on the part of her estranged husband. Israeli women's life expectancy has increased over the last twenty years from 73.4 to 77.4 years. However Israel is still seventeenth overall among industrialized nation's for women's life expectancy. while it is second overall for men's. Furthermore, women's longer life-expectancy is frequently accompanied by chronic disease, such as diabetes, hypertension. stroke, and osteoporosis. Public policy has yet to consider alternatives to residential care for the elderly. Obstetric and gynecological services are available and covered, but contraceptive materials must be paid for out-of-pocket. Public pre-natal and post-partum services are widely available, as is an extensive and universal system of well-baby clinics. .Medical practice still exhibits discriminatory attitudes towards women's health. As a result, for example, heart attack is the primary cause of death of women in Israel, largely because physicians tend not to relate seriously to women's complaints of chest pains or heart problems. Advertising of tobacco is restricted and there are numerous private programs for cessation of smoking. The Israel Cancer Association sponsors a yearly media campaign against tobacco and other substance use. Substance abuse programs are in place throughout the country, and there are some publicly-sponsored campaigns against smoking and alcohol abuse. However, with the influx of immigrants from the CIS, among whom there is a high rate of alcoholism, the current level of services may no longer be adequate. Statistics reveal that Israeli women use health services, visit doctors, and are hospitalized more frequently than men. Yet the voice of Israeli women as consumers of health services is rarely heard. Medical research, training, and practice have traditionally been guided by a male model, with little attention given to gender differences associated with illness and health, life-styles, and a host of factors that appear to make women more vulnerable than men to illness. The number of women entering medical schools continues to rise; at this time, approximately 50% of the medical students are women. However, most women continue to concentrate their studies in the "less prestigious" medical specialties, such as family practice and psychiatry. Some medical schools have instituted gender sensitivity training, but this is not routine and not mandated by the Council which determines the curricula of medical students. As a country of immigrants, Israel constitutes an excellent laboratory for epidemiological research; however, current research has failed to address the underlying causes of gender differences in morbidity and mortality patterns, and their relationship to other variables. Israel has ratified CEDAW as well as other international treaties on the rights of women and girls to health care. Yet decisions regarding health care policy and resource-allocation are often the result of cultural norms and political pressure, rather than rational professional criteria. For example, the cultural emphasis on childbearing has lead to disproportionate allocation of resources to highly-technological fertility services at the expense of health maintenance throughout the reproductive cycle, which should include, inter alia, family planning and education, availability of services for pregnancy-termination, and services for the post-reproductive period. Several women's NGO's have begun to address these issues. However, until recently, there has not been any government attempt to coordinate these many efforts. Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + The Ministry of Health has established a Steering Committee, composed of professionals and representatives of women's organizations, regarding women's health needs. This committee will also endeavor to coordinate the many efforts to advance the status of women's health in Israel.+ The Ministry of Health has hired a woman researcher at the National Center for Disease Control, who will coordinate and de-aggregate data on women s health.+ The Ministry has agreed to a demand by women's NGO's to produce and distribute information and data on women's health in Israel (within the framework of the International Center for Disease Control.) D. VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Take integrated measures to prevent and eliminate violence against women. + Study the causes and consequences of violence against women and the effectiveness of preventive measures.+ Eliminate trafficking in women and assist victims of violence due to prostitution and trafficking. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today Tremendous progress has been made in legislation regarding violence against women over the last five years. Today Israeli women benefit from comprehensive, progressive, feminist legislation, according to which a woman may, for example, obtain a protective order removing the violent man from the home, ex parte and without representation by an attorney. Should the man violate this order, he will be in contempt of court, which carries criminal implications. Marital rape is recognized as a criminal offense. Additional regulations address issues such as police protocol in handling domestic violence, and the provision of shelters, legal assistance, and other services to victims. However, the influence of traditional Jewish and Muslim religious structures cannot be underestimated in an understanding of the development of social attitudes and norms regarding gender equality and family relations. While the official rabbinical attitude toward domestic violence is one of absolute condemnation, women's advocates contend that the current rabbinic interpretation of traditional Judaism has created an environment in which domestic violence may be tolerated. Since 1992, women's NGO's have been actively working with the rabbinical authorities to change this, and they attest that progress has been made towards a reduction of this bias. Among Muslims, the practice of "family honor killings" continues. The law views these killings as murder and prosecutes accordingly. However, members of the community, men and women alike, frequently collude to protect the murderer, and "family honor killings" may be reported as suicides, accidents, or disappearances. Jewish and Arab women's NGO's have organized and publicly demonstrated against this phenomenon. Protection from violence is provided at 10 shelters for battered women, located throughout the country. The Ministry of Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare covers 75% of the cost of these shelters, and the additional 25% is provided by women's volunteer organizations. Last year, a shelter was established in the Arab sector, in recognition of the particular needs of Arab women; the Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare covers 100% of the operating costs of this shelter. The shelters provide professional counselling, legal advice and assistance, and child care and rehabilitation, as well as half-way houses. Several shelters do have multi-lingual staff and volunteers, although there are no shelters designed specifically for immigrant women, There are ten emergency phone lines for battered women throughout the country; one of these is designated for Arab women, while Russian and Amharric speakers are available on most of the others. Callers receive advice and information from trained volunteers. Police currently receive special training for working with family violence. While the former (unofficial) policy of the police was the establishment of "domestic peace", through the mediation of familial disputes, police policy now dictates that domestic violence be treated as a violent cime and that the victim be protected. Furthermore, the police may continue to investigate a complaint of violence even if the woman withdraws the complaint; the police also have the prerogative of filing a report even if the abused woman declines to do so. Women's organizations report that in most cases, cooperation with the police is effective. However, as in many countries, the majority of abused women do not file complaints with the police. There are 19 Centers for the Prevention of Violence in the family, located throughout the country These Centers are jointly funded and administered by the Ministry of Labor and .Social Affairs, the women's organizations, and the local authorities. The Centers provide direct treatment; visiting centers where parents and children who have been separated can meet; legal advice; and research and information. Women s organizations, together with the Ministry of Education, have begun to implement programs in secondary schools t~.) encourage egalitarian, non-violent relationships among Israeli youth . The Israel Defense Forces also conduct similar programs for their male and female conscripts, with a particular emphasis on sexual harassment. There are eight rape crisis centers in Israel; these centers also maintain hotlines and provide educational services. Public support for the rape crisis centers is less than ten percent of the total operating costs, and the remainder is provided by donations and contributions. The Centers report that police directives are meant to provide sensitive and effective care for the victim; however, the implementation of these directives is not uniform throughout the country. With the influx of immigrants from the former Soviet Union, there has been a rise in the number of young Russian women who are brought to Israel for prostitution. The media have brought this problem to the attention of the public and the criminal justice system. Penal codes prohibit direct or indirect procurement of income from prostitution. The Equal Opportunity in Employment Law prohibits an employer from discriminating against a female employee in hiring, promotion, training, dismissal, and severance pay due to her objection to sexual harassment on the part of her employer or supervisor. As noted below, the definition, procedures, and punishments for sexual harassment have been made clearer and more severe in the Civil Service Corps. Violence against women has received increased attention from the media and the public. Recently, an organization entitled Men Against Violence has been established and works in close cooperation with women's organization. It would appear that social norms and expectations are beginning to change. However, the judiciary continues to act prejudicially against women victims, and sentences against offenders are often light or even suspended. Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + In September, 1996, the Prime Minister allocated NIS 3 million, in order to create a media campaign against violence against women (this was one of the recommendations of the above-described commission). + In March, 1995, the Knesset appointed a Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry to investigate the subject of women murdered by their spouses or life partners. The committee further broadened its mandate to investigate the subject of domestic violence against women, and presented its conclusions and recommendations in June, 1996. This comprehensive report analyzed the causes of domestic violence, the adequacy and efficacy of existing services, and the gaps in service-provision, and presented comprehensive, integrated and binding recommendations to each of the relevant Ministries. + Due to the public outcry at the light sentences imposed on abusive men, legislation mandating minimum sentencing has been proposed in the Knesset. Both the Prime Minister and the Minister of Justice have expressed support for this law, and it is guaranteed a majority in the legislature. + In September, 1996 the Ministry of Justice, together with the women's NGO's, and with the cooperation of the Israel Police, began a pilot program of Victim-Witness Assistance to survivors of rape, the program will be implemented in two counties; if successful, it will be adopted and implemented by the Ministry of Justice. + The Family Courts Law (1995) will simplify access to legal recourse for wt)men on family matters, including violence against women, by combining all of these issues (e.g. property and paternity issues, child custody, child support and adoption issues) in one court + In 1995, the Knesset passed a more stringent definition of sexual harassment in the Public Services Law Book, including the establishment of a special commission within the Civil Service dealing with those who transgress the law and authorization to punishment. (However, this does not provide protection for the private sector.) + The National Health Law now covers any and all medical expenses incurred as a result of sexual or physical abuse to women. + A recent amendment to the penal code has recognized the Battered Women's Syndrome, acknowledging the right of a battered woman to defend herself against her attacker and effectively broadening the definition of "self defense" to include a woman's perspective. + The Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare has established ten half-way houses for battered women, and an additional ten are planned for 1997. + During 1997, the Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare, together with the Joint Distribution Committee will undertake a comprehensive research project to determine the extent, characteristics, existing solutions and alternatives with regard to wife abuse + Cognizant of the particular needs of Arab women, the Israel police have begun to implement a program to hire Arab policewomen. + In 1996, the Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare raised its level of funding of shelters for battered women from 50% to the current 75%. + Plans for the establishment of a shelter for violent men are expected to be implemented in the near future by the Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare and NGO's. (Discussions with the judiciary have indicated that judges will be more inclined to impose restraining orders and restrictions if they know that men have an alternative to returning to their homes.) E. WOMEN AND ARMED CONFLICT Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action: + Increase the participation of women in conflict resolution at decision-making levels and protect women living in situations of armed and other conflicts or under foreign occupation. + Reduce excessive military expenditures and control the availability of armaments. + Promote non-violent forms of conflict resolution and reduce the incidence of human rights abuse in conflict situations + Promote women's contribution to fostering a culture of peace + Provide protection, assistance, and training to refugee women, other displaced women in need of international protection, and internally displaced women. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today The issue of armed conflict, military policy and spending is an extremely important one for Israel. At this point in the nation's history, given the geo-political realities in the Mid-East, it is unlikely that military spending will decrease significantly in the near future. Until the Israeli public and policy-makers feel that true peace and public safety have been established, military resources will in all likelihood not be converted to social programs and economic development, nor will the priority De on alternate uses for the resources. Indiscriminate terrorism continues plague Israeli society, a source of fear for all. The Israeli government and NGO's have repeatedly expressed outrage and condemnation of acts of terrorism perpetrated within Israel's borders and abroad and have called upon other nations to do the same. Because these attacks take place in cities and towns, on busses and in shopping centers, women and children are the primary targets and victims. The military thus remains a central institution in Israeli society. Since Israel maintains near-universal conscription, military service is a right of passage and a source of legitimacy and status in adult life. Israel is the only Western democracy with compulsory conscription for women, but women are restricted from combat. However, fewer women than men are conscripted and, by law, women are conscripted for shorter periods of time. At this time, 69% of women in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) serve in professional positions, which require formal training, while a full 31% serve in secretarial jobs, which neither require nor impart professional skills of any kind. Roles in armed conflicts and peace negotiations are predicated on service and experience in the Israel Defense Forces. Thus, the limitations of women's military service severely restrict women's overall power and influence in the military and in foreign policy-making. In an institution predicated on hierarchy and power, in which women play an inferior role, it is not surprising to find incidents of sexual harassment and abuse. Recent anecdotal reports have indicated that this may be a more frequent occurrence than was previously assumed. Not one lsraeli representative to the negotiations with the Palestinians has been a women, despite the fact that women were very active in the informal, "Track II" contacts which predated the Oslo accords. Only four women serve as Israeli ambassadors or consuls general worldwide. Thus, enhancing the status of women within the army also means promoting greater equality for women in civilian society. Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + In a suit brought before the Supreme Court of Justice by two NGO's, the Israell Air Force was instructed to permit a woman to complete the entrance exams for combat pilot instruction. Subsequent to this decision, the air force reviewed its admission procedures and has since enabled all women who meet the initial requirements to complete the entrance exams. + Cognizant of the important socialization and social-legitimization functions of the Army, the Commander in Chief of the Women's Corp has delineated four goals to increase women's equality within the armed forces: full use of the potential of female recruits; activities to eliminate sexual harassment (including more stringent regulations); reorganization of the Women's Corps; and elimination of irrelevant differences between male and female soldiers which, until now, have been part of the regulations defining service in the Israel Defense Forces. + The Israel Defense Forces have instituted a program of empowerment and awareness among male and female conscripts, with regard to sexual harassment and egalitarian relationships. Senior training and education officers in the military have developed a positive relationship with the Knesset Committee on the Status of Women and with women's voluntary organizations. + In this regard, the Israel Defense Forces have agreed to conduct a formal survey of sexual harassment and violence among soldiers. As noted, punishments for sexual aggression against women soldiers have recently been made more severe, and conviction of such an offense leads to immediate, dishonorable discharge in addition to other sentencing. As part of this effort, the Israel Defense Forces have also established a hotline against sexual harassment. + The Israel Defense Forces are currently considering structural changes which would lead to a more positive, less segregated, integration on women into the army. + The Foreign Ministry has instituted a program to actively recruit women into the Foreign Service. F. WOMEN AND THE ECONOMY Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Promote women's economic rights and independence, including access to employment, appropriate working conditions, and control over economic resources. + Facilitate women's equal access to resources, employment, markets, and trade. + Provide business services, training and access to markets, information and technology, particularly to low-income women. + Strengthen women's economic capacity and commercial networks. + Eliminate occupational segregation and all forms of employment discrimination. + Promote harmonization of work and family responsibilities for women and men. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today The status of working women in Israel is a complex blend of progressive labor legislation, conflicting social norms, and overt and covert discrimination. Initial labor law provisions relating to women were founded on a conflicting combination of a belief that everyone should be engaged in productive, remunerated labor, and a social commitment to the development of the traditional family (in which women carry primary responsibility for the household and for childcare). A strong legal and social infrastructure was created to ensure that women would be able to integrate work and homemaking. Many of these protective measures continue to be of great practical value in facilitating the integration of motherhood with participation in the recognized labor market. However, this policy has not involved a concomitant commitment to providing women with equal opportunity for better-paying jobs and for advancement; furthermore, the protective legislation has, in many instances, ensconced women even further in the role of homemaker The Knesset introduced The Women's Work Law, guaranteeing women's right to equal opportunity in employment, in 1953; an equal-pay law was passed in 1964. In the 1970's labor courts expressly recognized the principle of a legal right to equal employment opportunity between the sexes. Since the late 198() s, the Knesset has actively intervened to establish, or reestablish, rights to equal employment opportunity. In 1987, the Knesset passed the Equal Retirement Age for Male and Female Employees. In 1988 it passed the Equal Employment Opportunities Act, with wide-ranging prohibitions on discrimination in employment; this law also recognized sexual harassment as a form of punishable discrimination by awarding civil damages to the victim. In 1988, maternal rights were converted to parental rights. In 1990, the High Court of Justice confirmed that there is a basic right to equal employment, and in 1994, it recognized the principle of affirmative action. Thus, the Knesset and the labor courts have begun to lay the legal foundation for women's equality in employment; however, the mechanisms for enforcement are inadequately funded and ineffective. No less importantly, legislation has preceded social and normative change. Women constitute 42% of the civilian working force; 89% of them are employees. Despite the above-cited legislation mandating equal pay for equal work, the wage gap between men and women for full-time, year round employment is, on the average, over 30%. Furthermore, this gap actually has grown since 1980. Women comprise nearly 70% of those who earn less than the average wage and whose salaries must therefore be supplemented by the National Insurance Institute. The unemployment rate for women is approximately one third higher than for men. Although there are six times as many female managers today than there were in 1975, the increase in managerial employment is insignificant: Women constitute 41% of the workforce, but only 17.5 percent of managers. Of these, 74% are concentrated in commerce and public services. Thus, even at the managerial level, women are segregated into the lower-paying sectors. In 1994, a committee to encourage women to establish small business was established as part of the Small Business Authority (which is part of the Ministry of Commerce and Industry). The activities of this committee are predicated on the belief that small business can serve as a viable means for women to improve their personal, financial, and social status, and to contribute to the economy. A recent survey has indicated that only 5.3% of all women in the labor force are independently employed, in contrast to 17.6% of the men. Furthermore, only 1.2% of the women employ others, while 7.2% of the men do so. The committee has especially targeted the Arab population. as well as the Jewish population residing in the peripheries. The activities of this committee are predicated on the belief that small business can serve as a viable means for women to improve their personal. financial, and social status, and to contribute to the economy. The rights of women with regard to pregnancy, child birth, and child care are regulated by law, which prohibits dismissal of a pregnant employee and also grants the women the right to twelve weeks of maternity leave, with full pay from the National Insurance Institute. Maternity leave can be extended up to one year, unpaid, and taken by either parent. Employees may not be dismissed during maternity or extended maternity leave. All rights related to birth parents apply to adoptive parents. Parents may use their personal sick leave time to care for ill children. Child care is the legal obligation of both parents, and desertion is a criminal offense. However, behavioral norms place the responsibility of childcare almost exclusively upon the shoulders of women. Regardless of the fact that more and more women have joined the workforce and that two incomes are a financial necessity for most Israeli families, women have not been relieved of any significant part of the role of care for home and children. Institutional frameworks have only partially taken this reality into account. Several women's NGO's provide day care and nurseries for working women; these facilities are partially subsidized by the Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs. However, a short school day and numerous long vacations militate against paid working among mothers. The Ministry is currently involved in efforts to lengthen the school day and to begin compulsory education for children at an earlier age, (Currently, mandatory education begins at age five, while NGO's and the Ministry advocate age three). These measures would make it easier for parents with child care responsibilities to combine family and remunerated work. However, as noted, this plan has been postponed for at least three years, due to the extensive budget cuts. Women and men have freedom to organize and join labor unions, as well as freedom to protest and strike. However, proactive protection of employees on the part of government has yet to be implemented. In 1993, a team was set up by the Ministry of Economics and Planning to recommend means for implementing a previous committee's recommendations for the advancement of women in the Civil Service. Most of the team's proposals were in fact adopted. The Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs has a section for the employment of women, which has statutory supervisory powers on the issue of equal opportunities for women in work, including criminal prosecutions in cases of violation of laws relating to equal opportunity employment and/or maternity and paternity rights. Three ministries have advisors on the status of women, while in all ministries, someone is responsible for status of women. Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + The Ministry of Construction and Housing and the Joint Distribution Committee, Israel, prepared and co-sponsored a 6-stage model for encouraging women to open small business. The model was implemented in 12 low-income neighborhoods and development towns. 284 women participated in the four-month course which provided practical information, business knowledge and empowerment skills. Upon completion of the course, the participants formed a women's business network. This year, the plan will be conducted in an additional 12 neighborhoods. + Legislation mandating the integration of supplementary benefits (e.g., travel and clothing allowances ) into salary was passed during 1996. This legislation is intended to eliminate gender discrimination and to correct wage gaps which have persisted despite equal-pay legislation. + In 1995, the level of maternity leave benefits was raised from 75% to 100% of the woman's salary. (These benefits are paid by the National Insurance Institute). + In 1996, an amendment to the Civil Service Law was passed, mandating equal and fair representation to both sexes and expressly citing affirmative action as a remedy for inequality. An operative plan was approved in March, 1996. + The Civil Service sponsored a course for advisors on the status of women in government ministries. The course, which entailed 300 study hours, included a wide variety of topics relating to the status of women. The course is a required qualification for appointment to the position of Advisor on the Status of Women in a government ministry. + The Small Business Authority, the Jewish Agency, and the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, in cooperation with Israeli women's NGO's, have established Businesswomen's Clubs in nearly 20 communities in all sectors of Israeli society, including the Arab and the ultra-Orthodox sectors. These institutions have also sponsored courses for small businesswomen and entrepreneurs. + The Small Business Authority has committed itself to prepare a plan for the establishment of a loan fund for the establishment of small businesses l-)y women. + In 1996, the Ministry of Labor and Welfare, the Department of Women's Employment, established a unit for the advancement of women, specifically dedicated to the development of models for several types of empowerment workshops, including courses for Arab and Bedouin women. + In 1996, the Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare sponsored six day-long, pre-discharge meetings for women soldiers with appropriate educational levels to encourage them to purse subsidized, post-secondary studies in computer technology or electronics. G. WOMEN IN POWER AND DECISION-MAKING Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Take measures to ensure women's equal access to and full participation in power structures and decision-making. + Increase women's capacity to participate in decision-making and leadership. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today There are no legislative or official proscriptions on women's participation in politics. There are, however, numerous practical and normative obstacles. Israel's widespread reputation as a gender-egalitarian country derives primarily from historic factors. The reality, then as now, is considerably different from the ideal image that many still hold. Women's status in the legal, social, economic, and political spheres is unequal and inferior in many aspects. The Declaration of Independence established the principle of equality for all citizens of Israel; however, the Declaration does not have binding legal status. The Law of Equal Rights for Women, passed in 1951, guarantees equality between the sexes, except on issues of personal status (marriage and divorce), which are the sole province of the religious courts. Thus, the Israeli legal system reflects a basic conflict between commitment to equality and to commitment to the religious and Jewish character of the state. Jewish tradition accords respect to both sexes, but it also clearly defines and delegates the public sphere to men and the private sphere to women. The influence of this tradition spreads well beyond the religiously-observant community to the ,general society. These views also predominate in Arab society, both Christian and Islamic. Although women's human capital, as reflected in seniority and education, is not inferior to men's, women receive relatively less reward for this capital. The gap in wages, despite legislation mandating equal pay for equal work, reaches 32% in the public sector, due to unequal allocation of benefits. Despite the nearly-universal necessity of two incomes, a women's salary is frequently considered to be a "second income". As in most industrialized countries, women are concentrated in a small number of female-dominated occupations. which are less prestigious and less-well remunerated. Only a handful of women attain top posts in management, whether in industry, government or academe. For example, only 5% of Israeli professors are women, although women constitute 40% of the non-tenured faculty members. Only 2% of women serve in positions of senior management and/or on directorates of large companies. Women are grossly under-represented in political positions, both national and municipal. The classic pyramid-like structure of women's socio-political involvement predominates in Israel. As noted above, the general elections in May, 1996, brought about a change of administration. The number of women parliamentarians in the 120-seat Knesset was reduced from 13 to nine. In contrast to the two women Cabinet Ministers in the last administration, only one woman currently serves in the Cabinet. However, for the first time, three women have been appointed as Director-Generals of government offices. In the past, most women Members of Knesset dealt primarily with "women's issues" (such as social welfare and education), and refrained from participating in issues of security and foreign affairs. This pattern has begun to change. Of the nearly 17,000 candidates for the most-recent municipal elections, only 493 were women. Women totalled approximately 7.3% of those elected; only one of the ten women candidates for mayoralty was elected. On the municipal and local council level, over 50 councils on the status of women exist in the Jewish sector and some 25 in the Arab sector. A statutory committee for the advancement of the status of women exists within the Center for Local Government, and an Advisor on the Status of Women is now employed by the center. The pattern of under-representation is also evident within the political parties. Despite the fact the women are active members of all the various parties, they are almost entirely absent from the decision-making bodies of those parties. Not one of the major parties has agreed to reasonable quotas or affirmative action for women; often, in pre-coalition and coalition negotiations, the few places promised to women are "traded away". Inequities stemming from military service are another major obstacle for women in local politics: Men who have completed successful careers in the defense forces are required to retire in their mid-forties. The "old boys' network established and nurtured in the military frequently provides them with access to positions in socio-political or economic institutions, including municipal government. Three women currently sit on the Supreme Court. However, half of the nation s magistrate judges are women, so it is hopeful that more women will be appointed to the Supreme Court in the future. Women's under-representation at all senior levels of involvement and decision making is self-perpetuating. Where women do not constitute a critical mass, they do not .and cannot promote other women. Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + The local women's councils for the advancement of women have sponsored numerous activities for women, including a Passover "Sedar" for single-parent families; the establishment of a hotline for information on breast cancer; a Breast Cancer Awareness Day, which included free examinations; and recorded telephone messages which provided information regarding municipal services for women. + A joint forum between the Union of Local Authorities and a majority of women's organizations has been established to encourage women's candidacies for mayor and deputy mayor and to demand that women constitute one-third of all party lists. + This forum has also called for passage of legislation which would mandate that each and every local council have a Women's Council and/or an Advisor to the Mayor on the Status of Women, and that these positions be jointly funded by the Local Councils and the Ministry of Interior. H. INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISMS FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF WOMEN Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Create or strengthen national machineries and other government bodies + Integrate gender perspectives in legislation, public policies, programs, and projects + Generate and disseminate gender-disaggregated data and information for planning and evaluation. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today Formal mechanisms for the advancement of women have been established at the highest levels of government. Both the Prime Minister's Office and the Knesset have developed apparati to systematically improve the status of women. However, the position of Advisor to the Prime Minister on the Status of Women is not mandated by law, and its appointment is at the Prime Minister's discretion. The primary responsibilities of the office include: preparation of proposals on government legislation, administration, and policy, participation in government deliberations and issues affecting women, handling of complaints of discrimination and deprivation, collection of information from other government entities regarding women's status. The Knesset also has a Statutory Committee for the Advancement of the Status of Women. Specific Actions and Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + Proposed legislation would mandate and authorize the creation of an Authority for the Advancement of the Status of Women. This Authority's responsibilities would include the legislative and programmatic protection of women's rights, monitoring of enforcement of laws through government and in the private sector, coordinating efforts to promote women's rights among all levels of government, providing recourse institutions where human rights abuses have occurred, and generally addressing the human rights of women in all spheres, including education, employment, personal safety, and political representation. This would be a more comprehensive body than the already established Prime Minister's Advisor on the Status of Women. As noted, both the Prime Minister and the Minister of Justice have expressed their support for this legislation. + The Civil Service has established a commission for the Advancement and Integration of Women. + The Civil Service Commission has mandated that gender-neutral language be used in all governmental tenders and publications. I. THE HUMAN RIGHTS OF WOMEN Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Promote and protect the human rights of women, through the full implementation of all human rights instruments, especially the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) + Ensure equality and non-discrimination under the law and in practice + Achieve legal literacy An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today Human rights are addressed in the Declaration of Independence and other government documents. Israel has ratified the CEDAW and International Treaty for Civil and Political Rights and the International Treaty for Social and Cultural Rights. However, the ratification of CEDAW included reservations to Section 7, stemming from the fact that women cannot he appointed as religious judges, because they cannot be ordained as rabbis. Israel also expressed reservations to Section 16, as all issues regarding marriage and divorce are the province of the religious courts, w here there is no equality for women (in any religion in Israel). An analysis of the human rights and status of women in Israel must therefore address the influence of the religious community on public-policy making, politics, and social structure on all levels. As noted above, this is most evident in the standing of women before religious courts. While distribution of marital property, custody of children, and issues of spousal and child maintenance can be discussed in either civil courts, where women's status is equal, or rabbinical courts, where women's status is inferior, marriage and divorce are the sole province of the religious courts. (This does not, however, preclude women attorneys from appearing before religious courts.) This situation leads to numerous restrictions on women's power over their own marital status, and has wide implications for their human rights. However, surveys repeatedly reveal that a majority of the Israeli public does not want to repeal the religious statutes. Therefore, the challenge facing Israeli society is to create culturally-syntonic solutions which will neither offend the traditional-orientation of the Israeli public nor deprive women of their human rights. We do note that in the past few years, the Director General of the Rabbinical Courts has met regularly with a coalition of women's NGO's, in an attempt to reach more equitable solutions for women. Under Israeli law, there are few, if any, constraints or discrimination directed against women. Legally, women can own, inherit and bequeath real property equally; similarly, women may receive bank credit equally with men. (In fact, in many sectors of the Israeli population, it is common practice to register domestic housing units and even businesses in the name of both husband and wife.) Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + The Rabbinic Courts have agreed, in principle, to recommend that couples sign pre-nuptial agreements. These agreements will have binding religious implications, as well as civil validity. (However, no such arrangements have been prepared for Moslem or Druze women.) + The Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare has prepared booklets in Arabic and Russian, explaining the rights of women, particularly (but not solely), with regard to violence and victimization. J. WOMEN AND THE MEDIA Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Increase the participation and access of women to expression and decision-making in and through the media and new technologies of communication. + Promote a balanced and non-stereotyped portrayal of women in the media. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today Freedom of the press is legislatively guaranteed and protected, although issues relating to security must be submitted to censorship. The media is thus also free to reflect widespread prejudices, preconceptions and inequalities with regard to women. Examinations of Israeli media, both print and electronic, reveal negative, stereotypic portrayals of women, the absence of women as expert consultants and authority figures, and the use of violence and quasi, soft-porn in commercials. Furthermore, women are conspicuously absent from decision-making and policy formulating agencies. Surveys of the electronic media reveal that women are simply absent from the scene; for example, only 14.4% of adults appearing on TV are women. Furthermore, women are most frequently portrayed in unequal and degrading positions; in interviews and discussions, for example, they are referred to by their first names and described in a familial or dependent context, while men are referred to in their professional capacities and addressed by their professional titles. In the print media, women's issues are often portrayed as marginal, tangential, or frivolous. They are considered, at best, "soft news", while feminism and innovative reformative ideas are often ignored. On camera or on-the-air female reporters are largely limited to non-prime time or to "soft" news stories. Coverage of international affairs and politics is still primarily the domain of male reporters, although there are a few notable recent exceptions. Many media managers believe that the public prefers to hear or see a man report a story of national urgency. Advertising in the print and electronic media is replete with stereotypical and sexist images of women, and despite self-imposed and legal restrictions. advertisements often include "soft porn", and implied violence. However, public awareness of this injustice seems to be growing: In several instances, public outcry at particularly heinous advertisements led to their removal. Women's associations have used every effort in trying to place women on the committees which oversee cable television. However, the political character of such appointments did not favor the appointment of women. The majority of women who work in the news media occupy administrative or lower and middle management positions. Not one of the major television, radio, or newspaper organizations in the country is headed by a woman, although women comprise almost all of the lower-paid research and support staff in these organizations. The Commission on the Status of Women in Radio and Television within the Israel Broadcasting Authority actively promotes the participation of women at all levels of media. It is also working to increase the number of women in the Israel Broadcasting Association and the visibility of women as experts and professionals for news stories. No such organization exists for the print media. The mass media does not only reflect reality; they also create reality. The relative absence of women from the communications spotlight may serve as evidence of the social marginality of women in Israel and their relative absence from the public sphere. Specific Actions and Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + In 1995, a committee of newspaper editors agreed upon self-imposed restrictions in the advertising accepted for publication, including prohibition of advertisements for certain erotic services, "adult" telephone lines, and those featuring children in sexual contexts. + The Commission of the Status of Women in Radio and Television successfully lobbied for monitoring of the presentation of public service announcements in the Israel Broadcasting Association. + The Commission of the Status of Women in Radio and Television sponsored a course for women within the Broadcasting Authority. The Course provided information on women's rights, awareness training with regard to the role of the media in the advancement of the status of women, skills for working in male-dominated workplaces, and personal and professional empowerment. + This Commission also sponsored a one-day conference under the tile, Do Women Communicate Differently. Heads of the Israel Broadcast Authority and of the other electronic and print media attended the well-publicized conference, which discussed issues of gender and journalism. K. WOMEN AND THE ENVIRONMENT Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Involve women actively in environmental decision making at all levels. + Integrate gender concerns and perspectives in policies and programs for sustainable development. + Strengthen or establish mechanisms at the national, regional? and international levels to assess the impact of development and environmental policies on women. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today The Israeli environmental movement is still in its nascent stages. There are already a number of environmental organizations, each of which has a slightly different orientation. The recently-established Ministry of the Environment also files lawsuits against corporate polluters and works actively to protect the environment; the establishment of this ministry reflects a relatively recent shift in attention towards environmental issues. There is no distinct ecofeminist movement, although several women are active in environmental affairs. Laws on recycling of paper and batteries already exist, and there are restrictions on the use of chloroflourocarbons and freon. The use of leaded gasoline has been significantly reduced. By law, women of childbearing age (16-45) are prohibited from working in environments in which there is significant likelihood of exposure to electromagnetic or radioactive materials or lead at levels which would jeopardize the health of a fetus. We note, however, that this protection of the fetus may have been at the expense of the elimination of environmental threat. Over all, gender perspectives have not been integrated into Israeli environmental planning, and planners do not address gender-based differences. The planners tend to relate to the needs of the "population at large", together with specific needs of particular groups (e.g., education services for children, welfare services for families in distress). Local research shows that many women in Israeli society have a more complex and difficult daily routine than men. However, the urban male (and, most frequently, the Jewish, middle class, healthy urban male) has remained the prototype for most planning efforts. The National Planning and Building Law (1965) stipulates that this 30-plus member body must have at least one representative of women's organizations. (Today, de facto, more women are voting members because several participate as professionals). However, no equivalent stipulation exists on other levels of statutory planning. Overall, women's roles in environmental policy-making are relatively limited, largely due to the overall lack of women pursuing careers in environmental sciences, engineering, urban planning, and so forth. The planning process must be empowering and participatory at all stages, for all citizens. We assert that gender-sensitive environmental planing is commensurate with "good planning". There is much to be done by way of changing public attitudes toward environmental protection and consumption. L. THE GIRL CHILD Strategic Objectives Mandated by the Beijing Platform for Action + Eliminate all forms of discrimination against the girl child. + Eliminate negative cultural attitudes and practices against girls. + Eliminate discrimination against girls in education, skills development, and training. + Eliminate the economic exploitation of child labor and protect young girls at work. + Eradicate violence against the girl child + Promote the girl child's awareness of and participation in social, economic, and political life. + Strengthen the role of the family in improving the status of the girl child. An Overview of the Situation in Israel Today In Israel, the basic rights of all girl children are recognized and observed: All children (boys and girls alike) are considered legitimate; any female or male child born in Israel is automatically granted citizenship; all male and female children are equally entitled to inherit from their fathers, whether or not their mothers were married to the father. The legal minimum age for marriage is seventeen for women; there is no minimum for men. With the passege of the Family Courts Law (1995), child support allocation and enforcement will be handled by one centralized court system within the magistrate court. The Juvenile Labor Law (1953) generally prohibits work for children under age fifteen (except under specific circumstances such as holidays, vacations, etc.) There are restrictions on the type of work children can do and the number of hours they are permitted to work. The influence of traditional religious structures cannot be underestimated in understanding the development of social attitudes and norms regarding gender equality and family relations; boys and girls are differently socialized. In the ultra-Orthodox community, many girls are denied some of the freedoms of study and community involvement accorded to boys. The Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare maintains a unit for those adolescent girls, ages 13-23, who are at risk of alienation and juvenile delinquency. In 77 locations throughout the country, in all sectors, this unit has set up hostels, social clubs, external high schools, half-way houses and other means to help these girls. The service is staffed by professional social workers. Achievements Since the Beijing Conference + The program to eliminate gender bias in the schools, developed by a Women's NGO and adopted by the Ministry of Education, has, as one of its objectives, the education of adult teachers and parents about sexist practices and attitudes that harm the growth and self-esteem of girl children. + As noted above. conscription into the Israeli Defense Forces is a crucial socializing and legitimizing factor, for men and women alike. The Ministry of Labor and Welfare has therefore implemented a project to promote and guide girls for enlistment into the Israel Defense Forces, particularly targeting girls from weaker sectors of the population, whose psycho-social profile would not entitle them to conscription. Ninety-five percent of the girls who participate in these groups do subsequently enlist in the IDF. + The Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare has begun an extensive program to train social workers in shelters and Centers .for the Prevention of Violence to work with adult violence against children. + The Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare has established eight Parent-Child Centers, for parents who for various reasons can meet with their children only in a safe place under professional supervision. However, this project is underfunded and at risk of cancellation.