A/54/135-E/1999/88
Distr.:General
18 June 1999
Original: English
General Assembly
Fifty-fourth
session
Item
101 of the preliminary list*
Environment
and sustainable development
Economic and Social Council
Substantive
session of 1999
Geneva,
530 July 1999
Item
13 (e) of the provisional agenda**
Economic
and environmental questions: environment
*A/54/50. |
** E/1999/100 and Add.1.
Report of the
Secretary-General
The present report is submitted in pursuance of General
Assembly resolutions 52/200 and 53/185. It thus builds on the previous report of the
Secretary-General on this topic (A/53/487). The Council is invited to consider the report
in conjunction with the report of the Secretary-General entitled Recommendations on
how the United Nations will deal with the reduction of natural disasters after the
conclusion of the International Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction
(A/54/136E/1999/89). The present report covers context (sect. I); actions continued
or initiated since the Guayaquil seminar (sect. II); and conclusions and recommendations
(sect. III). Two annexes prepared by the World Meteorological Organization concern a
scientific and technical retrospective (annex I) and a feasibility study for an
international research centre (annex II). It is proposed to continue the existing
inter-agency cooperation for concerted action on El Niņo, to be coordinated within the
successor arrangements for the Decade to be decided upon by the General Assembly at its
fifty-fourth session, and to ensure the continuation of its full functional
complementarity with the work of the Inter-Agency Committee on the Climate Agenda.
|
|
Paragraphs |
|
Page |
|
|
|
|
|
I. Context...................................................................................................................
|
|
16 |
|
3 |
|
|
|
|
|
II. Actions continued
or initiated since the Guayaquil seminar........................................
|
|
715 |
|
4 |
|
|
|
|
|
III. Conclusions and
recommendations..........................................................................
|
|
1620 |
|
5 |
|
|
|
|
|
Annexes |
|
|
|
|
|
I. The 19971998
El Niņo: a scientific and technical retrospective....................................................
|
|
7 |
|
|
|
II. International
centre for the research of El Niņo at Guayaquil, Ecuador: a feasibility study................ |
|
8 |
|
|
|
I. Context
1. In response to the
occurrence of the El Niņo phenomenon in 1997/98, in December 1997 the Inter-Agency Task
Force on El Niņo was created within the framework of the International Decade for Natural
Disaster Reduction (IDNDR). In paragraph 6 of its resolution 52/200, the General Assembly
welcomed its establishment for cooperative work on the prevention and mitigation of and
preparedness for natural disasters related to the El Niņo phenomenon. The Task Force has
provided member agencies and their partner agencies outside the United Nations system with
a platform for combining their efforts to improve understanding of the El Niņo
phenomenon, disseminating early warnings on the 1997/98 event and channelling technical
assistance and capacity-building resources to Member States threatened or affected by El
Niņo-related disaster impacts. These actions have once again demonstrated the immense
value of interdisciplinary approaches and complementarity in the global disaster reduction
effort, as developed within the framework of IDNDR.
2. While the
unprecedented strength of the 1997/98 El Niņo event presented a great challenge to the
disaster reduction community, it also provided new opportunities for international
cooperation, spurred by an increasing scientific understanding of the climate system and
new developments in climate observations technology and telecommunications. As recently
stated in a report by one of the leading governmental institutions on climatic research in
the Western hemisphere, the United States National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
(NOAA), for the first time, affected countries around the world were aware of and could
prepare for the climatic impacts associated with El Niņo.1 This clearly
reflects well the growing notion of the culture of prevention that IDNDR was mandated to
promote. Indeed, as part of their contribution to the Task Force on El Niņo and within
the framework of IDNDR, member agencies have intensified their ongoing programmes on the
El Niņo phenomenon or embarked on new ones.
3. In pursuance of
General Assembly resolution 52/200 and with the generous support of the Government of
Ecuador, the first intergovernmental seminar on the 1997/98 El Niņo event was held at
Guayaquil, Ecuador, from 9 to 13 November 1998. The seminar provided a substantive
interface between the scientific and technological constituencies and their operational
partners in disaster prevention, humanitarian disaster management and operational
development, including support to local capacity-building. In assessing the efficacy of
disaster prevention on the basis of early warning information in various stages of the El
Niņo event, the seminar reached consensus on the need for more complete atmospheric and
oceanographic monitoring in order to improve the modelling of El Niņo and the precision
of the forecasts. There was also agreement on the need to socialize the
information disseminated, i.e., to provide data tailored to the acute needs of the
communities to be affected.
4. The Declaration of
Guayaquil, adopted at the closing session of the seminar on the basis of its deliberations
on the effectiveness of the international response to the 1997/98 El Niņo event,
contained a number of recommendations on the way forward. Following a proposal submitted
by the Government of Ecuador, the Declaration called upon the United Nations to assess the
feasibility of establishing an international centre for the research of the El Niņo
phenomenon at Guayaquil within the context of the Inter-Agency Task Force on El Niņo, and
to report on its findings to the General Assembly at its fifty-fourth session, through the
substantive session of 1999 of the Economic and Social Council.
5. Experience with the
1997/98 El Niņo event, presented at sessions on the socio-economic dimension and other
programme components of the Guayaquil seminar, demonstrated once again the potentially
devastating effects of El Niņo-related climate extremes on the sustainable development
efforts of developing countries, where most of the impacts occur. As indicated by an
analysis performed by Munich Reinsurance, the economic losses incurred by the four most
severely hit countries varied from 1.7 per cent of gross national product (GNP) in El
Salvador to 11.4 per cent of GNP in Ecuador. International organizations, including the
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), assisted affected Governments in their work
of reconstruction and rehabilitation. The Guayaquil Declaration recognized the urgency for
actions to strengthen the capacity of existing governmental and intergovernmental
programmes to help achieve the objectives of resolution A/RES/52/200. The following main
fields were highlighted in particular: climate monitoring; improved prediction; early
warning; sector-specific information flows; and capacity-building. The full report on the
Guayaquil seminar is available through the United Nations Secretariat.
6. At the fifty-third
session of the General Assembly, the Secretary-General submitted a report on progress made
with international cooperation to reduce the impact of the El Niņo phenomenon (A/53/487),
as requested in General Assembly resolution 52/200. While expressing its concern about the
widespread and devastating effects of the El Niņo/Southern Oscillation (ENSO)in most
regions of the world, the General Assembly at its fifty-third session noted the progress
made in the improved scientific understanding of the phenomenon and endorsed the
recommendations made in the Secretary-Generals report. Subsequently, the Assembly
adopted resolution 53/185 on international cooperation to reduce the impact of the El
Niņo phenomenon, in which it called for, inter alia, the continued and full
implementation of its resolution 52/200. It also decided, inter alia, to consider
the La Niņa phenomenon in the context of such implementation.2 In
part-fulfilment of Assembly resolution 53/185, operative paragraph 5, the summary report
of the intergovernmental Guayaquil seminar, which includes the full text of the
Declaration, was submitted to the Commission on Sustainable Development at its seventh
session (New York, 1930 April 1999) as background paper No. 10 (see also sect. II
below).
II. Actions continued or initiated since the Guayaquil
seminar
7. International activity
towards the improved reduction of El Niņo-related natural disasters has greatly
intensified since the General Assembly, in its resolution 52/200, decided to intensify
inter-agency collaboration and encourage more attention for this subject at the national
and regional levels. In the short time since the intergovernmental Guayaquil seminar and
the discussions on El Niņo at the fifty-third General Assembly, several new initiatives
have been launched and some that already existed within the framework of IDNDR have been
intensified. Although these projects will eventually contribute to the full implementation
of Assembly resolutions 52/200 and 53/185, their final assessment will only be possible
after more time is given to secure the institutional arrangements and resources needed for
the tasks to be undertaken.
8. For example, in an
early follow-up of Assembly resolution 52/200, the World Meteorological Organization (WMO)
agreed to take the lead in respect of the science and technology roles of the Inter-Agency
Task Force on El Niņo, in particular in relation to the understanding, observing and
predicting of the El Niņo phenomenon and its related meteorological and hydrological
impacts. Accordingly, WMO presented a proposal for a scientific and technical
retrospective of the 1997/98 ENSO event to the second meeting of the Inter-Agency
Committee on the Climate Agenda (IACCA), held at Geneva on 16 and 17 April 1998, as an
input to the Inter-Agency Task Force on El Niņo. With the endorsement of IACCA, WMO
embarked on the retrospective, mainly based on information solicited from its members on
national impacts, the national capacity to meet needs and the views of other national
institutions. A progress report on this component of the Inter-Agency Task Forces
work has been presented to the Thirteenth WMO Congress, held at Geneva from 4 to 26 May
1999 (for a summary, see annex I below). The full report is expected to be before the
General Assembly at its fifty-fourth session.
9. In accordance with its
lead role on science and technology in the Inter-Agency Task Force on El Niņo, WMO
embarked on a feasibility study for an international centre for the research of the El
Niņo phenomenon at Guayaquil, as requested in the Declaration of Guayaquil. The study
started off with a WMO mission to Ecuador from 27 January to 7 February 1999.
Consultations were held with senior government officials representing various sector
agencies at Quito and Guayaquil, and with relevant international organizations3
and institutes.4
10. The outcome of the study was
positive in the sense that the proposed centre not only has the full support of the
Government of Ecuador and the national and regional institutions with which it would
cooperate, but that such support may also be expected from the wider international climate
science constituency. The centre would have two main functions: to promote and undertake
research on the ENSO phenomenon and mathematical modelling to permit
downscaling of global climate predictions to regional and national scales; and
to provide outreach services to the community of users of ENSO data and predictions. A
brief progress report on the feasibility study is contained in annex II below.
11. In parallel with its support for
the feasibility study, WMO is acting as the executing agency for an Inter-American
Development Bank-funded study on the prediction and amelioration of socio-economic impacts
of ENSO in Latin America and the Caribbean. The specific objective of this 21-month
project are: (a) to evaluate the existing institutional and technical forecasting
capabilities in all countries of the region to anticipate and cope with El Niņos
consequences; (b) to identify on a geographical basis, by groups of countries, the more
vulnerable economic sectors and population groups; (c) to analyse the economic value of
improved early warning systems as compared with the existing situation; and (d) to prepare
proposals for improved early warning systems in selected countries or groups of countries
within the subregions of Meso-America, the Caribbean and South America, to ameliorate the
socio-economic impacts of El Niņo. WMO has continued to produce and distribute regular
updates on the demise of the El Niņo phase and the onset of the La Niņa phase, in
collaboration with the national meteorological services of its Member countries and
climate research institutions.
12. Other agencies have taken
initiatives in accordance with their mandates. Building on some of the main conclusions
from the Guayaquil seminar, the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) has formulated
a project proposal for the assessment of how early warning and other El Niņo-related
information was used at the country and community levels for the mitigation of El Niņo
impacts during the 1997/98 event. Supported by the United Nations Fund For International
Partnerships, this inter-agency project will be undertaken by core teams in 12 countries,5
with the participation of UNEP, WMO, the United Nations University, IDNDR, and the United
States National Center for Atmospheric Research. The results are expected to be available
in December 2000.
13. As a spin-off of the participation
of the World Health Organization (WHO) in the Inter-Agency Task Force on El Niņo and
with inputs from several of its collaborating centres, WHO has prepared a bibliography on
the public health hazards associated with the ENSO phenomenon. It will soon be made
available on the WHO Web site as a contribution to the work of the Task Force.
14. The specific El Niņo concerns
with regard to natural disaster reduction have been the subject of discussion at various
IDNDR conferences, including an international IDNDR early warning conference, held at
Potsdam, Germany from 7 to 11 September 1998, an IDNDR- Economic and Social Commission for
Asia and the Pacific regional conference for Asia, held at Bangkok from 13 to
17 February 1999, and an IDNDR-UNEP regional conference for Africa held at Nairobi
from 18 to 21 May 1999. As announced in the Guayaquil Declaration, a further international
conference on the 1997/98 ENSO event, hosted by the Government of Peru, will be held at
Lima from 20 to 24 September 1999. The conference will focus on institutional
arrangements, the role of decision makers and the application of scientific knowledge and
technological expertise in El Niņo-related prevention. Another conference, tentatively
planned to be held at La Serena, Chile, from 12 to 15 October 1999, will investigate
linkages between the El Niņo phenomenon and the process of desertification, with support
from the Government of Chile and with the participation of the Economic Commission for
Latin America and the Caribbean and the United Nations Convention to Combat
Desertification in Those Countries Experiencing Serious Drought and/or Desertification,
particularly in Africa.
15. As a further follow-up to the
Guayaquil seminar, in the segment on oceans and seas of the report on its seventh session,
the Commission on Sustainable Development welcomed the intergovernmental expert meeting
held at Guayaquil, and the two expert meetings to be held at Lima in September 1999 and at
La Serena, Chile, in October 1999. The Commission also, inter alia:
(a) Requested the
Secretary-General to gather information on all aspects of the impact of ENSO, through
national reports on the implementation of Agenda 21, and to provide this information to
the Inter-Agency Task Force in order to contribute to the development of the
internationally concerted and comprehensive strategy towards the assessment, prevention,
mitigation and rehabilitation of the damage caused by ENSO;
(b) Decided to consider the
impacts of ENSO as part of its examination of the integrated planning and management of
land resources at its eighth session;
(c) Invited all
intergovernmental agencies concerned with aspects of the oceans to consider, within their
respective mandates, whether their programmes of work make sufficient allowance for
considerations of the potential impact of increased climate variability, and to review
through the various coordination arrangements what more needs to be done to ensure
adequate understanding of the prediction of coastal and marine impacts of such phenomena
as El Niņo.
III. Conclusions and recommendations
16. The experience with the 1997/98 El
Niņo event has reaffirmed the great predictive value of El Niņo signals obtained from
the equatorial Pacific. At the same time, however, additional influences exerted by
oceanic and atmospheric processes taking place in the Indian and Atlantic Oceans have
clearly made predictions much less reliable for certain areas outside the Pacific Ocean
basin. It is clear that the precision of future ENSO predictions for such areas will
critically depend on the integration of climate oscillations occurring in the Indian and
Atlantic Oceans with those from the Pacific Ocean, based on a sound scientific
understanding of the interactions between all three. In view of the very serious potential
for damage, both in terms of human suffering and economic losses, efforts should be made
to intensify and/or extend observations of climate oscillation systems in the three large
ocean basins, and to further develop existing ENSO prediction skills, based on improved
modelling.
17. Another pertinent conclusion from
the effort to reduce the 1997/98 El Niņo event concerns the availability of data and
their usefulness for decision makers in the field. As compared with ENSO events in the
past, there has probably never been as much information available at low cost, mainly as a
result of the ever-increasing use of the Internet and the World Wide Web. Despite the
existence of this rich source of information, it has not always been easily interpreted by
user communities due to lack of processing and adaptation to their specific needs. The
potential role of regional ENSO centres (such as the proposed Guayaquil centre) on this
issue could be to facilitate the distribution of relevant information to users in
countries within relatively homogeneous climatic regions, and to promote the best possible
utilization of such information for the reduction of disaster impacts.
18. The early recognition of the
unusual strength of the 1997/98 El Niņo and the timely action undertaken on the General
Assembly initiative, as expressed in its resolution 52/200, has provided an unprecedented
opportunity to maximize the potential available within the IDNDR framework for early
disaster prevention through advocacy and the wide distribution of information, including
early warning, and to assess the effectiveness of these approaches as well as the
weaknesses which still require further development. This has underscored the value of
close inter-agency collaboration among disaster reduction constituencies at the regional
and national levels, both within as well as outside the United Nations system. Efforts
must therefore be made to ensure that the possibilities for well coordinated action will
also exist after the conclusion of IDNDR at the end of 1999. These issues are to be
discussed under agenda item 13 (h) (for details, see A/54/136E/1999/89).
19. The Inter-Agency Task Force on El
Niņo has clearly shown the immense value of concerted action among United Nations system
partners and their non-United Nations counterparts within the framework of IDNDR in
advocacy, coordination of action and the wide dissemination of information. The
Secretary-General invites the Council and the General Assembly not only to safeguard
appropriate successor arrangements for disaster prevention but also to ensure continuation
of the work of the Inter-Agency Task Force on El Niņo (in keeping with Assembly
resolution 53/185 and the report of the Commission on Sustainable Development on its
seventh session, the Task Force should probably be renamed the Inter-Agency Task Force on
ENSO) as a part of such arrangements.
20. From the start of IDNDR, the
member agencies of what now constitutes IACCA (established in 1997) have formed a solid
technical and scientific platform for action towards the goals and objectives of IDNDR in
the prevention of climate-related natural disasters. In view of the important and probably
growing global hazards posed by climate variability and extremes, including ENSO events,
it is crucial that within the framework of the successor arrangements for IDNDR proposed
by the Secretary-General (see A/54/136E/1999/89), the strong institutional
connections between IACCA and the United Nations system-wide disaster prevention
constituency are retained.
Notes
1 See An experiment in the application of
climate forecasts: NOAA-OGP activities related to the 1997/98 El Niņo event (NOAA,
Office of Global Programs, 1999).
2 In the present report, the joint consideration of
both El Niņo and La Niņa will be reflected by the use of the term El Niņo/Southern
Oscillation, or ENSO.
3 UNDP; the United Nations Educational, Scientific and
Cultural Organization/Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission; and the International
Council of Scientific Unions.
4 The International Research Institute for Climate
Prediction of New York; and the Permanent Commission for the South Pacific and its
subsidiary at Quito.
5 Cuba, Costa Rica, Panama, Ecuador, Ethiopia, Kenya,
Mozambique, China, Viet Nam, the Philippines, Papua New Guinea and Fiji.
Annex I
*
Prepared by WMO. |
The
1997/98 El Niņo: a scientific and technical retrospective *
1. The very strong
1997/98 El Niņo event brought to international attention the global scale of risks posed
by extremes of climate, particularly for the developing world. Loss of life, destruction
of infrastructure, depletion of food and water reserves, displacement of communities and
outbreaks of disease all occurred as manifestations of climate-related natural disasters.
The international community recognized the intensity and global distribution of natural
disasters associated with the El Niņo event, which led to the conviction, as reflected in
General Assembly resolutions 52/200 and 53/185, that steps should be taken to mitigate the
negative impacts of climate extremes.
2. WMO took a lead role
in coordinating scientific and technical information about the 1997/98 El Niņo event. In
particular, during the course of the event WMO prepared a series of publications, called El
Niņo Updates, providing information on the current status; these were issued to
national meteorological and hydrological services and made available to the media and
international agencies.
3. WMO, with UNEP,
UNESCO/IOC and ICSU subsequently organized the scientific programme for the first global
assessment of the 1997/98 El Niņo event, carried out at Guayaquil, Ecuador, from 9 to 13
November 1998. The first global assessment (international seminar on the 1997/98 El Niņo
event: evaluation and projections) was co-sponsored by the Government of Ecuador, the
Inter-Agency Task Force on El Niņo and the Permanent Commission for the South Pacific.
4. WMO is nearing
completion of a scientific review, to be published as The 1997/98 El Niņo Event: A
Scientific and Technical Retrospective with the support of UNEP and UNESCO/IOC as a
contribution to the Inter-Agency Task Force on El Niņo to establish a sound scientific
and technical basis for new strategies to mitigate the negative impacts of climate
extremes.
5. The material for the Retrospective
is drawn from the presentations made at the first global assessment meeting at Guayaquil,
national studies and scientific research. The Retrospective has three parts:
(a) Part I. Variability of the
climate system: reviews relevant knowledge and processes of the climate system, including
the Asian monsoon and El Niņo, and describes the El Niņo Southern Oscillation as an
outcome of the coupled ocean-atmosphere system;
(b) Part II. The 1997/98 El
Niņo event: reviews the development and evolution of the 1997/98 El Niņo event and the
global pattern of climate extremes, examines many of the regional climate anomalies and
provides information on the extent of human impacts and losses;
(c) Part III. The way ahead:
examines how science and technology, supporting climate information and prediction
services, can be used in the service of community preparedness, early warning and
management of climate risk in society, particularly through the integration of science and
technology with natural disaster reduction and sustainable development planning and
policies.
Annex II
*
Prepared by WMO. |
International
centre for the research of El Niņo at Guayaquil, Ecuador: a feasibility study*
1. In response to General
Assembly resolution 52/200 on international cooperation to reduce the effects of the El
Niņo phenomenon, the first global assessment of the 1997/98 El Niņo event was
carried out at Guayaquil, Ecuador, from 9 to 13 November 1998. The first global
assessment (international seminar on the 1997/98 El Niņo event: evaluation and
projections) was co-sponsored by the Government of Ecuador, the United Nations Task Force
on El Niņo and the Permanent Commission for the South Pacific.
2. An outcome of the
international seminar was the Declaration of Guayaquil, submitted to the General Assembly
by the Government of Ecuador on 17 November 1998. The Declaration of Guayaquil called for,
inter alia, immediate action to assess the feasibility of establishing an
international centre for the research of the El Niņo phenomenon at Guayaquil, as proposed
by the Government of Ecuador, and suggested that such action be undertaken within the
context of the Inter-Agency Task Force on El Niņo.
3. WMO, through its
Secretary-General, recognized the urgent need to undertake the feasibility study and
organized a mission for the purpose from 28 January to 7 February 1999. The mission
included consultations with the International Research Institute for Climate Prediction of
New York, with institutes and senior officials at Quito and Guayaquil, and with other
relevant international institutions.
4. The report of the
feasibility study describes the scientific and organizational contexts, the scope and
functions that such a centre should undertake, a suitable location, staff and equipment
needs, and a proposed organizational arrangement. The report also outlines the probable
contributions that would be required from the host countries, and the magnitude and nature
of external resources required. These are estimated as US$ 1.1 million per annum and US$
300,000 per annum, respectively, and a total of US$ 2.62 million for equipment capital
costs (computing and observational infrastructure, not accommodation).
5. The report of the
feasibility study has been made available to the Government of Ecuador and is currently
under consideration.