|
Defining environmental governance as "how we organize
ourselves to be more responsive to environmental challenges",
the Swiss Permanent Representative to the United Nations,
Peter Maurer, spoke on this topic at an event organized by
the United Nations NGO Committee on Sustainable Development
on 5 December 2006. As co-chair of Informal Consultative Process
on the Institutional Framework for the United Nations' Environmental
Activities, which delivered a report to the 60th General Assembly
in June 2006, Mr. Maurer has extensive experience working
with this issue.
Global attention to environmental issues, particularly global
warming, is high at this moment, said Mr. Maurer. He added
that the film by former United States Vice President Al Gore,
"An Inconvenient Truth", which was released in May,
and an October 2006 report by economist Sir Nicholas Stern
for the Government of the United Kingdom, which predicts serious
economic consequences if countries do not take action against
global warming, have given visibility to the issue. He also
said that the environment had been high on the global agenda
after 1992 "Earth Summit" in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil,
but attention to the topic had faded through the 1990s.
Debates around environmental governance had been reinvigorated
by the 2005 World Summit Outcome Document, said Mr. Maurer.
Representing a compromise between all Member States, the Outcome
Document recognized the need for a "more coherent institutional
framework" for environmental activities at the United
Nations and its agencies. Bodies that deal with the environment
include the United Nations Environment Programme, headquartered
in Nairobi, Kenya; the United Nations Development Program,
and the Commission on Sustainable Development, both in New
York; the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change,
headquartered in Bonn, Germany; and the World Bank and the
Global Environmental Fund, headquartered in Washington, D.C.
The main challenge is to make sure these institutions are
organized rationally and effectively, and are pursuing environmental
goals in an efficient manner, said Mr. Maurer.
He explained that, to a large degree, the language of the
Outcome Document represented a compromise between the position
of the United States, which did not want to address the topic
of environmental governance, and France, which sought to create
a single organization that would handle environmental issues-a
"UNEO" (United Nations Environmental Organization).
Mr. Maurer said environmental issues tend to break through
traditional groupings of States at the United Nations, such
as the "Group of 77" developing countries. Instead,
common positions arise among countries that have problems
with such issues as desertification, flooding or rising sea
levels. While large countries, such as the United States,
India, Brazil, South Africa and Nigeria often "have their
own views" regarding the environment, he said countries
that stand to suffer negative consequences, such as Small
Island States, are more open to tackling environmental issues,
because they perceive more direct benefits from resolving
them. Environmental consciousness is also growing in the Russian
Federation and China, he added, and these countries represent
a "moving target" with regards to the environment.
Responding to a question, Mr. Maurer said one way to move
forward was to integrate UN bodies working on the environment
on the Internet. This would be a relatively easy step that
could ensure participation with civil society and help integrate
systems "without major political cracks". He also
said that virtual integration would easier than convincing
a country currently hosting an environmental secretariat that
it should relinquish hosting an organization.
Roma Stibravy, Chairperson of the UN NGO Committee on Sustainable
Development, offered an alternative view, saying that "UNEP
and the Commission on Sustainable Development secretariat
should be one [organization] headquartered in New York".
She added that environmental issues should be at the center
of global affairs. "Terrorism, civil and cross-border
wars are considered global threats. The environment should
be brought to the same level of concern and consideration",
she said.
|