|
Roma and Sinti, who make up the largest minority in Europe
today with some 10 to 12 million members, share with the Jews
the terrible experience of disfranchisement, persecution and
systematic extermination in Nazi-occupied Europe. Half a million
members fell victim to the Holocaust, an experience that is
burned deep in the collective memory of the Roma and Sinti
minorities, but which is still barely acknowledged by the
majority in their countries of nationality. As a consequence
of the Holocaust, the international political system is extremely
sensitive to the various forms of anti-Semitism, whose rise
we have observed with great concern in recent years. In contrast
to this, there is neither an awareness of the historical dimension
of the crimes of genocide committed against our minority nor
of the present-day racism that Roma and Sinti are subjected
to in many countries.
 |
| The deportation
of the Remscheid Roma and Sinti to Auschwitz, March 1943
PHOTO/STADTARCHIV REMSCHEID |
In the minds of many people, Roma and Sinti are still associated
with homeless "nomads". This contrasts with the historical
fact that members of this minority group have been integrated
in and are citizens of their respective countries of nationality
for many centuries, particularly in Europe. Therefore, most
of the European Governments have recognized Roma and Sinti as
national minorities who, in addition to the national culture
of the majority, also cultivate their own cultural identity,
including their traditional language, Romany. The terms "Roma"
and "Sinti" are authentic proper names meaning "person".
Those of eastern European descent are called "Roma"
and those of central European origin are referred to as "Sinti".
On the other hand, the foreign term "gypsy" is regarded
by most minority members as discriminatory.
Since the end of the cold war and the opening up of central
and eastern European countries in 1990, the living conditions
of the Roma and Sinti minority have drastically deteriorated
as a result of nascent racism. However, racist-motivated violence
and discrimination against Roma and Sinti have significantly
increased in a large number of countries in western Europe.
As The New York Times correctly observed in a commentary in
March 1996, members of the minority are today subjected to marginalization
and racism to an extent that corresponds to the situation of
African-Americans in the United States up until the mid-1950s.
A notable cause for the continued marginalization and discrimination
of Roma and Sinti is the structures of prejudice and racist
clichés, which have been substantially influenced by
the misanthropic racial ideology of the National Socialists
and the associated fascist regime. In view of these ideological
lines of continuity, it is hardly surprising that Roma and Sinti
minorities are not only socially disadvantaged to a considerable
extent but are also repeatedly the victims of open violence.
The authorities in eastern and western Europe have recorded
a drastic increase in racist violence against minorities by
neo-Nazis; however, such attacks increasingly emanate from the
security forces themselves. Only rarely can the perpetrators
expect consistent prosecution and conviction by the police and
legal authorities. As an example, the police officers responsible
for the obviously racist-motivated murders of two Bulgarian
Roma in 1996 were not punished by competent authorities; only
after a judgement of the European Court of Human Rights in 2005
was the Bulgarian State obliged to investigate the racist background
to this crime. The Court issued a similar adjudication in a
comparable case, also in Romania; in all probability, however,
the perpetrators will escape criminal prosecution appropriate
to a State governed by the rule of law.
 |
| Police raid
against Roma and Sinti protesters in Trebisov, Slovakia,
February 2004 PHOTO/PICTURE ALLIANCE |
The forced sterilization of Roma women, several hundred cases
of which have been documented in the Czech Republic and Slovakia
in recent years, represents a particularly serious case of human
rights violation. This practice was in general use under the
communist regimes and has been continued independently by many
doctors in the now democratically organized States. Although
the protests of human rights organizations and well known personalities,
such as United States Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton-the Commission
on Security and Cooperation of the American Government also
dealt with these cases in August 2006-have contributed to public
awareness of these human rights violations, they have unfortunately
not led to any effective countermeasures. This practice is all
the more monstrous, as the forced sterilization of thousands
of Roma and Sinti was an integral component of the policy of
genocide in the National Socialist State.
The expulsion of more than 100,000 Roma from Kosovo as part
of the so-called ethnic cleansing campaign, particularly during
the Kosovo war in 1999, is a tragedy whose extent is hardly
known. Members of the minority still live under the constant
danger of racist incursions by militant Albanian nationalists.
For years now, we have protested the continuation of the forcible
deportation of Roma refugees from Kosovo. Another serious case
of human rights violations of Roma and Sinti is the accommodation
of civil war refugees in various camps in Kosovo, which is under
the United Nations mandate. Since 1999, well over 500 members
of the minority have been living in these camps, which were
constructed by the UN administration on the site of a former
lead mine in Mitrovica. As a result of investigations by the
World Health Organization (WHO), it has been known since 2000
that the inhabitants of the camps suffer from life-threatening
heavy-metal poisoning and that children and pregnant women are
particularly affected. The United Nations Mission in Kosovo
(UNMIK) is responsible for the camps and after a worldwide protest
constructed an alternative camp for the Roma refugees in the
spring of 2006. However, this camp is only a few metres away
from the existing ones. As a result, the health of the inhabitants
is still under threat and no long-term solution of the situation
is in sight.
Politically responsible people still deny the existence of racism
and discrimination against Roma and Sinti, especially in the
countries of central and eastern Europe. Members of the minority
are mostly described as a "social problem" and therefore
have only themselves to blame for their marginalization and
frequently appalling living conditions. Instead of effectively
protecting the Roma minorities from discrimination and racism,
many politicians contribute to the dissemination of stereotypes
and stir up antiziganistic, as well as anti-Semitic, feeling
in the population. In addition, the media plays an important
role in the characterization of racist stereotypes, particularly
through the portrayal of criminals as "Roma" or "Sinti",
or other such discriminatory terms in press or television reports.
Moreover, the World Wide Web is increasingly being used by right-wing
extremists as a platform for the dissemination of hate propaganda
against Roma and Sinti, as well as Jews; and there is no internationally
effective legal provision against this. At the same time, the
denial of the Holocaust is a central component of the neo-Nazi
ideology.
The extreme right-wing propaganda is directed at people, who
frequently have inadequate water supply, electricity, heating
or sewage system and who have to live on demarcated housing
estates. Reforms of the social systems, such as in Slovakia
or the Czech Republic, have further intensified the existing
poverty of members of the Roma and Sinti minorities and worsened
the prospects of their right to self-determination. In addition,
the discriminatory practice of sending Roma children to special
schools for the mentally handicapped or concentrating them in
special Roma classes, which have worse facilities, is a scandal
that has deprived the largest minority in Europe of its long-term
future. Extensive studies provide documentary evidence of these
practices in many European States. Against this background,
it is hardly surprising that the rate of unemployment of Roma
and Sinti has also dramatically increased since the collapse
of the socialist economy, in which minority members were mostly
employed as industrial workers, and is as high as 90 per cent
in many regions. Roma and Sinti have de facto virtually no opportunity
to find an apprenticeship or a job in many places. In such social
exclusion, deeply-rooted patterns of prejudice play a role that
should not be underestimated.
 |
| An exhibition
on "The Holocaust against the Roma and Sinti and
present-day racism in Europe", at the European Parliament
in Strasbourg, France, January 2006 PHOTO/DOCUMENTATION
AND CULTURAL CENTRE OF GERMAN SINTI AND ROMA |
Educational attention to historical facts of the extermination
policy perpetrated against the Roma and Sinti in the National
Socialist State, including its ideological and social assumptions,
is urgently required to combat antiziganism and to subdue the
traditional clichés about this minority. It must be an
important component of ongoing strategies against racist-motivated
violence and marginalization. A new exhibition by the Documentary
and Cultural Centre of German Sinti and Roma, titled "The
Holocaust against the Roma and Sinti and present-day racism
in Europe", is dedicated to this objective and will open
at the United Nations Headquarters in New York on 30 January
2007 as part of the International Holocaust Memorial Day. Roman
Herzog, the former German Federal President, in a speech on
16 March 1997 about the extent and historical importance of
the crimes against humanity committed against the Roma and Sinti,
said: "The genocide of the Sinti and Roma was carried out
from the same motive of racist mania, with the same deliberation,
with the same intention of a planned and final extermination
as the genocide of the Jews. They were systematically murdered
in complete families from the very young to the very old over
the entire sphere of influence of the National Socialists."
The objective of the exhibition is to embed in the collective
memory of the nations of the world, a crime of genocide, which
has been suppressed for decades, and to raise awareness among
political decision-makers of the particular historical responsibility
they bear towards the Roma and Sinti minority.
In addition, the consistent implementation of international
protective provisions-in particular the "Framework Convention
for the Protection of National Minorities" and the "Charter
for Regional or Minority Languages" of the Council of Europe-and
an extension of the protection of minorities through new legal
arrangements are required for an improvement in the protection
of the Roma and Sinti from racism and discrimination. In conjunction
with other international organizations, the United Nations has
created an extensive system of conventions for the protection
of human rights that are binding under international law. However,
their effectiveness is based on the complete ratification, application
and monitoring of international legal obligations, something
that is still not the case in many countries. Extended legal
steps against racism and discrimination are also necessary-a
requirement supported by the United States Government within
the framework of the conferences of the Organization for Security
and Cooperation in Europe. This applies especially to the prohibition
of discriminatory practices in media law and the dissemination
of racist demagogic slogans on the Internet.
Building equal opportunities for Roma and Sinti minorities requires
the establishment of humane living conditions. National governments
must make clear their political will and support for the promotion
of these minorities through the implementation of adequate infrastructure
projects. The United Nations and other institutions, such as
the European Union, must also make a considerable contribution
to such programmes. Members of the minority and their own organizations
should be included, from the planning to the implementation
of an infrastructure for such projects, to a far greater extent
than has thus far been the case. Only if we systematically resist
racism and discrimination will majority and minority groups
be able to coexist peacefully, with equal rights in all countries
of the world.
|