 |
| PHOTO
COURTESY OF UNV |
Lester
M. Salamon is a professor at The Johns Hopkins University
and Director of the Johns Hopkins Center for Civil Society
Studies. As a pioneer in the empirical study of the
non-profit sector in the United States and more recently
throughout the world, his 1982 book, The Federal Budget
and the Nonprofit Sector, was the first to document
the scale of the American non-profit sector and the
extent of government support to it. Mr. Salamon has
extended this analysis to the international sphere,
producing the first comparative empirical assessment
ever undertaken of the size, structure, financing and
role of the non-profit sector at the global level. The
initial results of this work were published in his 1994
book, The Emerging Sector, and in two subsequent volumes
of Global Civil Society. Based on this work, Mr. Salamon
led the team that helped the United Nations Statistics
Division prepare the new UN Handbook on Nonprofit Institutions
in the System of National Accounts (NPI Handbook).
Mr. Salamon spoke with Robert Leigh of the United Nations
Volunteers (UNV) Programme.
|
The Johns Hopkins Center and the UN Statistics Division
have partnered to develop the first NPI Handbook. What
prompted this partnership and what is the goal of the NPI
Handbook?
The goal of the NPI Handbook is to bring non-profit
organizations and volunteering out of the shadows to which
they have been consigned in official economic statistics.
Under the System of National Accounts, which guides the collection
and reporting of economic data around the world, these organizations
are allocated among different economic sectors based on their
principal source of income. Since fees and government support
are the major sources of non-profit revenue in most countries,
the majority of the economic activity of non-profits gets
lumped together in existing statistics with that of corporations
or Governments. In addition, the official statistics do not
capture volunteer labour at all. As a result, the non-profits
and volunteering are largely invisible in existing economic
statistics, making it virtually impossible to gain a true
understanding of the scope and scale of this increasingly
important set of organizations and the volunteer effort that
helps to support their work.
The NPI Handbook was developed to overcome this problem
and provide a more accurate view of the economic and social
importance of the non-profit sector and volunteering. The
UN Statistics Division agreed to partner with us in its development
after we presented evidence from research work we had with
local partners in more than 30 countries around the world-from
Argentina to Australia, from France to the Philippines. This
work demonstrated what many people already suspected: that
non-profit organizations and volunteering constitute a massive
economic force, making far more significant contributions
to the solution of public problems than existing official
statistics suggest. In response, the Statistics Division agreed
to organize an experts committee to consider how to capture
non-profit institutions and volunteering more effectively
in national income data systems. It invited us to serve as
the technical staff to this Committee.
Why is a better economic understanding of the non-profit
sector necessary?
Increasingly, the global community has come to recognize that
progress in achieving the Millennium Development Goals and
solving the serious social and economic problems that plague
our communities will require more than government action alone.
Also critical will be the ingenuity and initiative of the
world's growing non-profit sector and the millions of volunteers
it can help mobilize. They have the ability to extend the
Government's reach, engage grass-roots energies, build cross-sector
partnerships and reinvigorate democratic governance. Without
solid information, however, it is difficult to generate the
interest and attention that the sector needs to make its contribution.
To an increasing extent, what is not counted does not seem
to count. Solid data on the scale, composition, financing
and role of non-profit institutions and volunteering can thus
help bring this important resource to the attention of policymakers,
the media, the business community and the public at large.
This can, in turn, help policymakers design more effective
policy, stimulate greater public involvement and support,
promote more favourable policies and thereby increase the
contribution that the non-profits make in addressing social,
economic and environmental problems and enhancing democratic
practice.
What are the key changes to the System of National Accounts
that the
NPI Handbook proposes?
The NPI Handbook calls on countries to make two major
changes to their current national income work. First, to identify
the non-profit institutions now buried in other economic sectors
and publish regular "satellite accounts", which
pull together all the data on them in one place. Second, it
requires them to estimate the value of volunteer work and
report this in the satellite account picture of the non-profit
sector as well. Since there is reason to believe that existing
records fail to include many non-profit institutions and little
data are collected on volunteering, these steps will require
some significant updating of the existing listings and the
introduction of survey modules to capture the extent of volunteering.
Utilizing the System of National Accounts (SNA) as the vehicle
to generate these data has a number of advantages. For one
thing, national accounts statistics are already supposed to
cover non-profit institutions, even though they split them
among several different sectors. The new NPI Handbook
offers suggestions on how to carry out a responsibility that
national accounts statisticians already have. In addition,
the National Accounts data system has enormous credibility,
and policymakers regularly rely on it for their picture of
other facets of the economy.
Finally, this system is already in place, firmly institutionalized
and is staffed with thousands of competent professionals in
countries around the world. Incorporating a procedure for
regularly producing more explicit data on the non-profit sector
and volunteering within the System thus increases the chances
that such data will be produced regularly and that the resulting
information will be credible and consistent with other aspects
of economic life. At the same time, it is important to recognize
that SNA is a consensus system. Countries are encouraged but
are not required to abide by its guidelines. Thus, implementation
of the NPI Handbook at the country level is by no means automatic;
rather, it will require continuous encouragement and support.
What kind of information will satellite accounts yield
that was not available before?
The NPI Handbook promises to revolutionize the availability
of reliable data on non-profit institutions and volunteering
around the world. In addition to the data on non-profit employment,
overall expenditures and sources of revenue that have been
generated through the Johns Hopkins Comparative Nonprofit
Sector Project, the NPI Handbook will yield regular
data on non-profit assets, the composition of expenditures
and the value added by non-profit institutions, both overall
and by different fields, such as health, education, social
services, arts and culture. It will also provide the first
official statistics on the extent, value and distribution
of volunteer labour, making it possible to chart the growth
and the changing composition of civil society organizations
and volunteering, and to compute the civil society's contribution
to a country's gross domestic product (GDP) and the output
in particular fields. This will help government officials
target policies toward the civil society sector and highlight
areas where partnerships may be possible. It will also provide
a solid basis for attracting attention to the role that civil
society and volunteering play, and a foundation for policies
to enhance this role.
What kind of information is emerging so far that we were
not privy to before, particularly on the extent and value
of volunteering?
Fortunately, 26 countries have already committed to implementing
the NPI Handbook. This includes Argentina, Australia, Belgium,
Brazil, Cameroon, Canada, Czech Republic, France, Ghana, India,
Israel, Italy, Japan, Kenya, Kyrgyzstan, Mali, Morocco, New
Zealand, Peru, Philippines, Republic of Korea, Slovakia, South
Africa, Uganda, United States and Zimbabwe. In addition, nine
countries have already issued at least a first non-profit
institution "satellite account", and six of these
include data on volunteering. The findings revealed in these
initial satellite accounts are quite striking. They show:
- The Belgian NPI sector is five and a half times larger
than what was formerly visible in existing national data
systems once the numerous non-profit health, social work
and related organizations allocated to the corporations
sector are included;
- Canada's NPIs account for nearly 8 per cent of the country's
GDP, of which about a quarter represents the contribution
of volunteers. In fact, the economic contribution of volunteers
alone in Canada is as large as that of the entire agricultural
sector. Even without volunteers, the GDP contribution of
Canadian NPIs exceeds that of agriculture, mining, oil and
gas extraction, retail trade, accommodations and food service,
and motor vehicle manufacturing sectors;
- The contribution of the NPI sector in Australia to the
country's economy exceeded that of the electricity, gas
and water supply, hotel accommodations and restaurants,
and the communications industries;
- In the fields in which they operate, the economic importance
of non-profit institutions is even greater: in Belgium,
NPIs account for 67 per cent of all value added in social
services and 43 per cent in health;
- The non-profit institutions sector is quite dynamic, exceeding
the overall growth of the economy in many countries. Thus,
between 2000 and 2003, the sector's average annual rate
of growth in Belgium outdistanced that of the overall economy
by a factor of 2:1 (6.7 versus 3.2 per cent). In the United
States, between 1996 and 2004, the non-profit sector grew
at a rate that was 20 per cent faster than the overall GDP.
Countries are not required to follow the UN Statistics
Division's guidelines. How are you addressing this challenge?
To encourage implementation of the NPI Handbook in
an initial target of 30 countries, the Statistics Division
authorized the Johns Hopkins Center to undertake a significant
mobilization, dissemination and technical assistance campaign.
Fortunately, the Center was able to forge a partnership with
UNV in this effort in a number of countries and also enlist
support from other institutions, including the UN Economic
Commissions for Latin America, Asia and Africa, and the Statistics
Division of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and
Development. Working with these institutional partners, the
Center has organized a series of regional briefings to introduce
the NPI Handbook to statisticians, stakeholders and
policymakers, conducted follow-up briefings and discussions
to secure implementation commitments in a group of target
countries, and followed up with training workshops with implementers
once countries have agreed to participate.
To help defray the local costs of this work in some developing
countries, UNV underwrites the costs of recruiting statistical
volunteers-in Brazil, Kenya, Morocco, Mali, Mozambique, South
Africa, the Philippines, India and Kyrgyzstan. In addition,
the Kellogg and Sasakawa Peace Foundations have committed
resources to cover some costs in Latin America and Asia, respectively.
Other support for the overall implementation effort has been
provided by the Ford and Skoll Foundations.
The implementation process includes the assignment of UNV
volunteers to national statistical offices in nine countries.
What have these assignments yielded so far?
UNV statistical volunteers are currently working in three
countries, and three additional States are now in the recruitment
process. These have proved immensely helpful to statistical
authorities in carrying out the initial tasks involved in
the implementation of the NPI Handbook. In Brazil,
UNV has made significant headway in compiling the first-ever
Brazilian satellite account on non-profit institutions, and
preliminary findings are scheduled for release shortly. In
the Philippines and Kenya, UNV volunteers have taken on the
arduous job of cross-checking official and unofficial registries
of non-profit institutions against national accounts data
systems, in order to make sure that these systems embrace
all the entities that satisfy the NPI Handbook definition
of a non-profit institution. UNV volunteers and programme
officers have also been helpful in mobilizing country support
for the NPI Handbook and in keeping the UN system at
the country level informed.
What do you hope to see happen in the next five years?
What are the key benchmarks you hope to have reached by then?
If all goes as I hope, the next five years will witness the
following major developments: (a) 30 countries will have produced
at least a preliminary version of the NPI satellite account,
and 12 of them will have produced at least one update; (b)
based on the initial results of this work, an additional 10
countries will have begun the process of implementing the
NPI Handbook; (c) a basic survey module for capturing
volunteer work will have been endorsed by the International
Labour Organization and integrated into labour force surveys
in at least ten countries; (d) a Civil Society Information
Network (CiviNet) will have been formed to link research units
interested in the scope and structure of the non-profit sector
internationally and provide access to the NPI satellite account
results; (e) the initial results of the implementation of
the NPI Handbook will have been published; (f) civil
society leaders in the 30 target countries will have absorbed
the data in the NPI satellite accounts on their countries
and begun to use them in their capacity-building and advocacy
efforts; (g) the media, the business community and Government
will evidence a new appreciation of the importance of non-profit
organizations in a significant share of the target countries
and make use of the results in their own work; (h) and an
NPI Handbook implementation fund will have been established
to help finance the implementation work in local areas.
|