|
By Ed Marks
Although I never had an office in the United
Nations Headquarters building, my work at the United Nations Children's Fund
(UNICEF) took me there frequently, and I always enjoyed the chance to view
its art treasures. I was awed by the ancient Peruvian burial mantle, still
in such pristine condition, and by the glorious Chagall stained glass window.
I had a special fondness for Nigeria's insouciant sculpture of a lady, the
Picasso tapestry in delicate pastel shades called "Woman on a Ladder" and
Denmark's gift of the sole replica made of a Bronze Age "Chariot of the Sun",
dug up by a farmer in 1902.
Taking friends
through the United Nations Headquarters after my retirement, I realized that
most of these works of art are not accessible to visitors taking the standard
tour. That led me to the idea of a book about the UN art collection.
When I seriously embarked on the project, I discovered that in the richness
and variety of its possessions, mostly gifts of Member States, the United
Nations had the equivalent of a fine small museum, and that the sculptures,
paintings, tapestries, mosaics and other works represent a veritable United
Nations of art.
"This art of all nations", said Secretary-General Kofi Annan, "reflects the
wonderful diversity of cultures and historical traditions that coexist at
the United Nations. It also speaks of universal themespeace, justice
and human rightsshared by all the world's peoples."
In making their gifts to the United Nations,
most nations have come forward with works of art reflecting the ideals and
expertise of their finest artists. Some objects are of ancient origin; others
illustrate the creativity of twentieth century artists. Some are purely
ornamental, while others speak to the principal aims and achievements of
the world Organization.
Appropriate decoration of the Headquarters was an early concern of the architects
who planned the buildings. The theme of peace was reflected in many of the
first offerings. Two huge murals representing "War" and "Peace", by the Brazilian
artist Candido Portinari, dominate the Delegates' Lobby of the General Assembly
building, along with Belgium's mural tapestry, "Triumph of Peace", one of
the largest ever woven (pictured above). Other early gifts included a bronze
equestrian statue of a woman, given by Yugoslavia, symbolizing peace, and
a bronze sculpture, "Let Us Beat Swords into Plowshares" from the Soviet
Union. In the Security Council Chamber is a mural by Norwegian artist Per
Krohg (pictured in background on page 78). A mural by Jose Vela Zanetti of
the Dominican Republic titled "Mankind's Struggle for a Lasting Peace" was
the gift of the Guggenheim Foundation. Outside the General Assembly entrance
is an 11th century sculpture from India and a 700 B.C. statuette of Osiris
given by Egypt (pictured at left). Iran, Iraq and Turkey have given interesting
replicas of ancient peace treaties.
Three of the finest items in the art collection
were gifts in memory of Dag Hammarsjköld after his death in an African
plane crash in 1961. Two are sculptures in the UN Plaza: a bronze statue
by Henry Moore called "Reclining Figure: Hand" and a 21-foot "Single Form"
sculpture by Barbara Hepworth. The third is the stained glass window by Marc
Chagall, located outside the Meditation Room in the General Assembly building
(pictured in background), a gift from Chagall and the UN Staff.
Fortunately, visitors to the United Nations can see the Hammarsjköld
memorials, as well as the Japanese Peace Bell and various sculptures in the
UN park. They can also view the mosaic called "The Golden Rule" based on
a painting by Norman Rockwell, China's gift of an ivory carving representing
the Kunming-Chungtu railroad, and a large reproduction of Thailand's Royal
Barge, because all these objects of art are located on the third floor.
Unfortunately, visitors do not have access to the second floor where many
of the finest works in the UN Headquarters collection have been placed.
Inevitably, a delicate matter is the placement of donated objects. Donors
generally want their gifts to be prominently displayed, and space is limited.
The UN Arts Committee was originally headed by C. V. Narasimhan. Brian Urquhart
took over from him and on his retirement, the responsibility was given to
Assistant Secretary-General Alvaro de Soto.
Not
all works of art offered to the United Nations are of prime quality. At
Headquarters, it is the task of the United Nations Arts Committee to decide
whether a particular object should be accepted. Sometimes extreme tact must
be called into play to avoid a diplomatic incident. Perhaps the donor will
consider an alternative selection. Individual artists and non-governmental
organizations often seek to present works of art to the United Nations. While
some were accepted in the past, a policy strictly observed for the last 20
years is to accept gifts only from Member States. In principle, Member States
are limited to one gift, but in a few instances, more than one offering has
been accepted.
While donors have always been responsible for installation of their gifts,
there was for many years no obligation to maintain them. As a consequence,
some became soiled by soot, coffee and other stains. The UN Arts Committee,
in its custodianship, does what it can but is badly handicapped by lack of
funds. In his 1990 report to the General Assembly's Fifth Committee, then
Secretary-General Javier Pérez de Cuéllar noted that the UN
art collection "has now reached a significant size and value monetarily,
artistically and culturally, yet no adequate arrangement has been made for
its systematic, professional control and conservation". Two years later,
in 1992, the Joint Inspection Unit made a report entitled "Managing works
of art in the United Nations".
This report recommended a modest budget for
art conservation, including the salary for a part-time curator. The report
went to the Fifth Committee of the forty-eighth General Assembly, with the
Secretary-General's comments, but no funds were voted. Instead, the Assembly
requested the Secretary-General "to continue to improve the management of
works of art in such a manner as to avoid additional costs to the regular
budget of the United Nations, with due regard to the quality of services
being provided". The Assembly also recommended "the strengthening of the
Arts Committee ... by the advice of local experts in honorary capacities".
While it is to be hoped that a future General Assembly will vote the limited
funds required for proper conservation of the collection, I have an alternative
suggestion.
The United Nations
inherited from the League of Nations four huge paintings by French artists
that were re-installed in Geneva's Palais des Nations in 1938. One on "Peace
and the Arts" was painted by Edouard Vuilliard, a world-class artist. Two
are by Maurice Denis and Ker-Xavier Roussel, pioneers, with Vuilliard, among
the Nabi painters, and well regarded in the art world. These canvases, also
on the theme of Pedace, were removed from the walls of the Assembly Chamber
when that vast room was renovated in 1960. They were rolled up and put in
safe storage where they have remained for nearly 40 years, despite periodic
appeals for their return. If, as seems likely, there is no plan for their
re-installation, why not sell them and use the proceeds to maintain the art
collection?
Another possibility to raise funds would be
to stage at Headquarters, as a feature of the millennium year, a special
exhibit of art from the UN collection, including a number of choice works
that cannot be seen on the public tour. Proceeds from an entrance fee to
this exhibit could be applied to conservation of the collection.
It is a collection worth conserving. As Diana D. Brooks, President and Chief
Executive Officer of Sotheby's, said in her introduction to A World of
Artthe United Nations Collection: "In an age when art is big business,
the collection at the United Nations affords us the opportunity to turn our
attention away from record prices and blockbuster museum shows, and encourages
us to consider, in the spirit of diplomacy, the art of all nations."
Scrambled Eggs, Bugs Bunny . . .
. . . and a mantle from the edge of time
Just prior to
the opening of the General Assembly building in 1952, two abstract murals
designed by the French artist Fernand Leger were installed. Decorative, but
devoid of symbolism. One is thought to resemble Bugs Bunny. When he saw them,
United States President Harry Truman dubbed the other "Scrambled Eggs" (pictured
at left).
Perhaps the rarest of the treasures at Headquarters is a ceremonial burial
mantle, a gift of Peru, said to be from 2,000 to 3,000 years old (pictured
in background). Inca kings and nobles were wrapped in these mantles after
death, and the resulting "mummy bundles", buried in a very dry area, were
discovered about 60 years ago. The mantle is located in the south-west foyer,
outside the General Assembly Hall, on the second floor. Also exhibited in
this area are a lively modern tapestry from Senegal, two sandalwood statues
from Indonesia, and an elaborately embroidered black silk curtain from Saudi
Arabia, formerly the door covering of the Holy Kaaba in Mecca.
In the corridor
between the General Assembly and the Secretariat, staff members and delegates
are able to view the Nigerian sculpture of Benin bronze, a 600 B.C. amphora
of the Geometric Period from Cyprus, and a stunning brown tapestry reproduction
of Picasso's famous "Guernica" mural. Nearby in the Delegates' South Lounge
is the Picasso tapestry, "Woman on a Ladder".
The fiftieth anniversary celebration of the United Nations in 1995 brought
new gifts of art to the Headquarters from at least a dozen nations. Under
the present policy, new donors are required to maintain, as well as install,
their gifts. However, those officials responsible for the art collection
have other pressing duties, so that with the best will in the world, questions
of acquisition, placement and management of UN art are necessarily dealt
with in an ad hoc manner.
|
| Sotheby's ratings of United Nations Art
Collection
In 1991, department heads of the
renowned Sotheby's auction house made an informal rating of the works of
art at United Nations Headquarters. The following criteria were applied:
Class 1 Highly important work of art, sought after, historically
significant.
Class 2 Good work, but not as rare, interesting or valuable.
Class 3 Not an especially rare or valuable piece and, apart from being
in the UN collection, not particularly historically significant.
The following items were graded Class 1:
-
Indian statue of sun god Surya (pictured at left)
-
Belgian tapestry titled "Triumph of Peace"
-
Chagall's stained glass window
-
Krohg's mural in the Security Council chamber
-
Henry Moore's sculpture "Reclining Figure: Hand"
-
Leger's abstract murals in the General Assembly
-
Barbara Hepworth's sculpture "Single Form"
-
Peruvian Burial Mantle (given special mention)
-
Matisse's collage "Torch of Hope"
-
Rouault's painting of Crucifixion
-
Marisol's sculpture of Bolivar
-
Norman Rockwell's mosaic "The Golden Rule"
-
China's tapestry of Great Wall
-
Rufino Tamayo's painting "Brotherhood"
|
|
About the
Author: |
|
Edward B. Marks' career
of nearly fifty years in international humanitarian work has been divided
equally about the United Nations and the United States Government, with some
periods of service for non-governmental organizations. He has written for
the New Yorker, The New York Times Magazine, and other publications, and
is the author of A WORLD OF
ARTThe
United Nations Collection. His first UN job in 1947 was at the Geneva
headquarters of the International Refugee Organization (IRO) and he subsequently
served as IRO's Chief of Mission in Greece; a quarter century later he joined
the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), serving in Geneva and New York.
After his retirement in 1982, he served as interim President of the United
States Committee for UNICEF and as Chairman of the Immigration and Refugee
Services of America.
Everyone has the
right to participate in the cultural life of the community, to enjoy the
arts and to share in scientific advancement and its benefits. Everyone has
the right to the protection of the moral and material interests resulting
from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he is the author.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 27 |
|