 |
Race
Print Curriculum
Rubrics
Facilitation Guidelines
Goals/Structure
of Lessons
|

|
LESSON
ON DISCRIMINATION BASED ON RACE
(2-1/2 to 4 hours)
- Lesson Overview (goals, skills, time, etc.)
- Materials and Preparation (allow 10 minutes)
- Directions:
 |
LESSON OVERVIEW
|
 |
Description
This lesson explores discrimination based on race. The lesson is in
three sections, each framed by guiding questions:
A. Introduction to Race (What is race? What
are my beliefs about racial differences?)
B. Racial Discrimination: Influences and Impacts
(What are some of the causes and impacts of racial discrimination?)
C. Positive Steps Against Racial Discrimination (What is being
done to address Racial discrimination? What can I do?)
Section A begins with an experiential activity to help students reach
a common definition of race. Students then reflect on their beliefs
about racial differences and the sources of these beliefs. These activities
reinforce the concepts of stereotypes and biases presented in Lesson
1. In Section B, students explore some of the causes and impacts of
racial discrimination. First, students examine the historical use
of stereotypes to support racist beliefs. Next, students investigate
institutional racism by creating an illustrated timeline of apartheid
in South Africa and/or an illustrated timeline of the Holocaust in
Europe. Section C presents ways to combat racial discrimination at
the international, local, and individual levels. A variety of activities
and project ideas are provided.
|
Objectives.
After this lesson, students will be able to
· articulate their beliefs about racial differences.
· define race and its significance as a social group.
· describe the link between racist beliefs and actions using
historical examples.
· define institutional racism and provide examples of how it
is supported through economic, political, social, and cultural means.
· provide examples of positive actions to combat racial discrimination
at the individual, community, and international levels
· plan, carry out, and evaluate their own actions to combat
racial discrimination |
| |
Assessment
· A journal rubric is provided to assess students' journal
responses throughout the lesson. You can give the rubric to students
ahead of time if desired.
· The activities in Section B yield discussion questions, a
timeline, and other products for evaluation. Group work can be evaluated
using the Groupwork Observation Checklist.
· The activities in Section C provide opportunities for evaluation
through exhibit or portfolio.
Opportunities for student self-assessment are also included. |
Concepts
race; institutional racism; discrimination through economic, cultural,
and political means; scapegoating; dehumanization; apartheid; segregation;
oppression; resistance; boycott; civil rights; civil disobedience;
Holocaust; genocide |
| |
Consider
students' previous knowledge
Students may believe that racism is limited to individual actions;
they may be unfamiliar with the concept of institutional racism which
occurs when racism is supported by governmental policies and laws.
In addition, students may not realize that people of all colors have
worked to dismantle racism. This lesson will clarify the institutional
nature of racism and ways people organize for change. |
Skills
discussing; active listening; respecting others; working in small
groups; self-evaluation; document analysis; planning, implementing,
and evaluating actions
|
>
to top
 |
MATERIALS
AND PREPARATION
|
 |
Print and make one copy of these handouts for each student
· Students will need their journals and the handout
of definitions. They may already have these from previous lessons.
· the handouts for Introduction
to Race (used in Section A)
· the handout Beliefs Underlying
Racism (Used in Section B)
· the handout Introduction
to Apartheid and/or the handout Introduction
to the Holocaust (used in Section B)
· the handout Positive Steps Against
Racial Discrimination (used in Section C.)
· the handout Apartheid Timeline
and/or the handout Holocaust Timeline.
Cut them apart as directed.
|
| |
Additional
Preparations and Materials
· If possible, gather additional resources about apartheid
and the Holocaust. Look for resources that contain pictures as well
as information about how people resisted institutional racism in these
instances. Books in your school library or the websites below may
be helpful.
· a globe or map of the world· materials for drawing:
unlined paper, crayons, colored pencils, etc.
· If possible, gather census data on the racial make-up of
your community, region, or country. |
| |
Selected
websites on racial discrimination
· A set of links on racial
discrimination.
· International
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination
· A list of documents and treaties developed by the United
Nations High Commission for Human Rights.
· An overview
of different types of discrimination and international efforts to
combat it.
· Primary
source documents on Africa.
· Documents
from the African National Congress.
· Documents
of the UN in the struggle against Apartheid.
· Overview
of South African history.
· UN
historical images of Apartheid in South Africa.
· A
Teacher's Guide to the Holocaust:
An overview of the people and events of the Holocaust through photographs,
documents, art, music, movies, and literature.
·
Holocaust
Learning Center and the Center
for Advanced Holocaust Studies
Prepared by the United States Holocaust
Memorial Museum.
·
YIVO
Institute for Jewish Research -- Some photos from YIVO's vast
archive of Holocaust images.
·
iEARN's
Holocaust/Genocide Project: The Holocaust/Genocide Project is
an international, nonprofit, Internet project focusing on the study
of the Holocaust and other genocides.
·
The
History Place (Holocaust Timeline): Created and maintained by
The History Place, this timeline summarizes the major events of
the Holocaust and is an effort to be "a complete chronicle
of Nazi persecution of the Jews with over 150 photos and text."
·
Holocaust
& Jewish Studies Sites
·
We
Are Family: Educating our Children for a Safer World --Prepared
by Court TV. The resource guide offers classroom activities and
tools for teaching and learning about the critical issues of diversity
and acceptance.
·
Voices
of the Holocaust
This web resource consists of oral history testimonies gathered
from Jewish men and women who came to live in Britain. These testimonies
are personal, individual, true stories, which describe life during
the Holocaust.
|
>
to top
 |
DIRECTIONS
|
 |
|
(Note:
It is highly recommended that you do the activities in the order
listed.) |
Section
A: Exploring Race
(30-45 minutes; optional extension) Guiding questions: What is race?
What are my beliefs about racial differences?
Before you begin: Establish a safe climate. Race is a highly
charged topic, and students may feel some reluctance to discuss it
openly. To help establish a safe climate, ask the students what they
need to feel comfortable. The classroom guidelines provide a basic
list of suggested behaviours that you can use to establish a framework
for discussing this topic. Students can add their own ideas on how
to create a safe environment for discussing these issues. Or, if you
have already used these guidelines in other lessons, review them again
before beginning this lesson. |
| |
| 1.
Defining Race (10 mins)
Note: In this activity, students will be asked
to group themselves by arbitrary physical categories you read (i.e.,
people with long fingernails/people with short fingernails). Before
you begin, clear a large space in the room for students to move
around and change groups.
· Distribute the Introduction
to Race handout and have students complete the question at the
top (How would you define race?).
· Have students verbally share their definitions of race.
Write main ideas on the board. Point out similarities and differences.
Explain that you want to come to a common understanding of race
to use throughout the lesson.
· Clear space in the class. Have half the class stand on
one side and half on the other. The students should be in a line
facing each other.
· As you read the following pairs of characteristics, instruct
students to move to the right side of the room if the first trait
best describes them, and to the left side of the room if the second
trait best describes them:
-people
with long fingernails/people with short fingernails
- people with hair lighter than a paper bag; people with hair
darker than a paper bag- people who are double
-jointed; people who are not double-jointed
- people who are taller than 5'5''; people who are shorter than
that
- people who can bend over and touch their toes; people who can't(You
can add other categories if desired.)
·
Have students to return to their seats. Ask them what they think
the point of the activity was. (Possible response: It had no point.)
Ask if the categories mentioned are a logical way to group people.
(Students will likely respond that they aren't.)
· Further emphasize the senselessness by asking what it would
be like if society discriminated against people based on these categories.
What if, for example, people who could not touch their toes were
deemed less intelligent than those who could? Or if people with
long fingernails were prohibited from owning property? Would it
be fair? Would there be any justification?
· Direct students' attention back to the Introduction to
Race handout. As a class, read the definition of race and accompanying
paragraphs. Points to emphasize:
-
Race refers to differences in skin tone, hair texture, and facial
features. Racial differences are a normal and natural part of
humanity that contribute to our uniqueness.
- Because people can be grouped by any number of physical differences
(such as the ones in the category), race is an arbitrary and invented
way to group people.
- Throughout history, people have used racial differences as the
basis of discrimination.
(Note:
Some of ideas are also presented in Lesson 1 in the reading "Understanding
Discrimination." You may wish to review this reading with the
class at this time.)
·
If desired, continue with the next activity, which has students
articulate the messages they have received about race from the media,
their families, and other sources. This activity will reinforce
the concept of stereotypes from Lesson 1. |
| |
| 2.
Students reflect on their beliefs about race and the sources of
these beliefs (20-30 minutes) Note:
For this activity, students will continue working with the "Introduction
to Race" handout from Activity 1.
· Direct students' attention to Activity 2 on the handout.
As noted, have students work individually to complete the table.
(They are to list images that come to mind when then think about
people of their race and other races, the associated values or judgments,
and the sources of their beliefs. Some students may feel more comfortable
talking about beliefs in the third person; for example, "What
do people think about this group?" Modify as you see fit.).
Allow 3-5 minutes to fill out the handout.
· Depending on the level of trust and safety in the class,
you can adjust the ensuing discussion for different levels of personal
disclosure as described below:
For a higher level of personal disclosure: After students
complete the table individually, have them share responses in
groups of three. Review the discussion guidelines provided. (Students
should use "I" statements; to speak honestly; to consider
the impacts of their words; and to listen without asking questions
or denying another students' experiences.) Emphasize that the
point of the exercise is to bear witness to others' experiences,
not to discuss and debate them. After students share in groups,
rejoin the class as a whole and have volunteers share key insights.
For a lower level of personal disclosure: Students can
use the third person to talk about this topic instead of using
"I" statements (e.g., "What do people think about
this group?") Or lead a class discussion on students' responses
to column c. only - the sources of their beliefs.
Regardless
of the discussion option you choose, place special emphasis on column
c., the sources of beliefs. Have the class generate a list of these
sources (ex: the media, school, peers, family, personal experience).
Through the discussion, emphasize the following points: (Note: These
points are covered in the Understanding
Discrimination reading from Lesson 1. If desired, you can have
students review this reading in class or as homework.)
-
We are not born with any beliefs about racial differences. Everything
we think or believe is learned throughout our lifetime.
- Sources of our beliefs about racial groups include the media,
school, peers, family, and our own experiences. These sources
are powerful influences on how we think about race.
- None of these sources provides a complete and accurate knowledge
of other people. Some sources may provide stereotypes and negative
images.
- Learning more about other people is one of the best ways to
dismantle stereotypes. (Explain that this will be covered more
later in the lesson.)
·
As noted on the handout, have students reflect on what they have
learned, and ask them to generate their thoughts or feelings about
the learning process. Emphasize the following points:
-
Race is a complicated topic and can bring up many kinds of feelings,
including anger, guilt, fear, and confusion.
- Learning about race is a journey. The road can be difficult
at times.
- Learning about why racism happens and what to do about it can
help turn negative feelings into empowerment and positive action.
·
Ask students for suggestions on how to support each other during
the journey. Re-emphasize the classroom guidelines.
· Close the section by thanking the students for their work.
Explain that the next section will help students deepen their understanding
of racial discrimination. Then continue to Section B. |
>
to top

SECTION B: Racial Discrimination: Influences and Impacts
(90-120 minutes) Guiding questions: What are some of the causes
and impacts of racial discrimination? |
| |
| 1.
Students explore the beliefs that underlie racism (15-20 minutes)
·
Distribute the handout Beliefs Underlying
Racism. Direct students' attention to the two sets of pictures
at the top. As noted, have students study the examples and respond
(orally or in writing) to the questions provided. The questions
and responses are provided below:
1.
What comparisons are being made? (Ex. 1 compares Africans to apes;
Ex. 2 compares Jews to rats.)
2. Are the comparisons favourable or unfavourable? (unfavourable)
3. What do you think is the purpose of making these comparisons?
(To dehumanize people. By portraying Jews and Africans as less
than human, the creators of the images also send the message that
they are superior.)
4. Look at the year each example was created. What was going on
at the time that may help explain the purpose of the image? (Ex.
1 was created during time when Europe was colonizing Africa and
the US was engaged in slavery. Ex. 2 was created during the Nazi
era. These images help justify the exploitation of Africans and
Jews during these periods.)
·
After discussing the questions, read the paragraphs under the images
(up under Activity 2). These paragraphs provide more background
on the use of imagery to dehumanize others. Emphasize the following:
-
A false belief in the superiority on one's own race is the cornerstone
of racism.
- Everyone is hurt by racism. Dehumanizing others can only happen
if we shut down part of our own humanity. Maintaining a hateful
attitude toward others is destructive to everyone.
·
To end the activity, have students respond to the reflection questions
at the bottom of the handout. You can use the questions for a discussion,
have students respond in their journals, or both. |
| |
| 2.
Exploring Institutional Racism: The case of apartheid and the Holocaust
(60- 90 minutes per case study)
Note: This activity requires two handouts
for each case study. Each case study includes an Introduction and
Timeline. Before class, print and make one copy of the appropriate
introduction(s) and timeline(s) for each student. Cut the Timeline(s)
you are using as instructed on the handout.
Directions for using Apartheid handouts
· Begin the activity by circulating pictures from the apartheid
era (in books or from the websites listed). Ask students to describe
what they see, and if they know when and where the pictures are
from.
· Distribute the handout Introduction
to Apartheid. As a class, read the introduction. Have students
generate any previous knowledge they may have about South Africa
or apartheid.
· Ask students if they can think of other examples of racial
segregation (e.g., ghettos in Nazi Germany; the removal of Native
Americans from their homelands to reservations.) Emphasize that
apartheid in South Africa is an example of a minority group (whites)
dominating the majority (Africans, Asians, and people of mixed backgrounds.)
· Break students into eight groups. Give each group one of
the eight selections of the Apartheid Timeline. (The directions
for the timeline activity are on the Introduction
to Apartheid handout. Make sure students keep this handy.)
· Explain that each selection describes different events
in the history of apartheid. Together, the selections create a timeline
spanning almost 400 years. Have students pass their selection around
in their groups and identify the years covered.
· Tell students that their selection may describe examples
of discrimination, examples of resistance, or both. Choose a student
to read aloud a paragraph from his/her selection. Ask the class
to identify whether the paragraph describes an example of discrimination,
resistance, or both. (Acts of resistance that failed or were prevented
are also relevant.) As you discuss the example, use words students
will encounter in their reading: oppress, protest, persecute, dominate,
resist. Clarify vocabulary as needed (for example "Act"
meaning law).
· Direct students' attention to the "Directions for
the Timeline" on the "Introduction" handout. Review
the directions (summarized here): Working within their groups, students
take turns reading passages from their selection, and identify examples
of discrimination and/or resistance. Students then create at least
two illustrations of the events described on their selection and
write a summary incorporating key information. The goal is for students
to become experts on their selection in order to present their drawings
and summaries to the class.
· Allow at least 30 minutes for groups to work. Circulate
to provide assistance as needed. Make sure groups have identified
and are illustrating examples of discrimination and/or resistance,
including acts of resistance that failed or were prevented due to
repression.
· When groups are done, have them present their work chronologically,
from the earliest to the most recent events. In their presentations,
have students discuss examples of discrimination and how people
resisted. Have students take questions from the class. Ask additional
questions or provide additional commentary as necessary. Allow about
3 minutes for each group to keep the process running.
· When the timeline is complete, lead a discussion focusing
on the systematic nature of racism and the methods people use to
resist it. Use the "analysis and discussion" questions
on the "Introduction to Apartheid" handout to guide the
discussion. (Students can complete these for homework if desired.)
These questions are provided here:
-
Give examples of discrimination carried out through economic,
social, and political institutions.
- What prevented the early resistance efforts of Africans from
being effective?
- Describe some key acts of resistance against apartheid.
- Describe the role of the international community in ending apartheid.
- Describe some of the economic tactics used to protest apartheid.
·
Emphasize the following points during the discussion:
-
Apartheid used economic, social, and political institutions as
tools of discrimination. Institutional racism is systematic and
influences every aspect of society. Individual acts of discrimination
merely support larger patterns of exclusion.
- Efforts to resist discrimination are more difficult when people
are denied access to representation, education, political power,
respect, etc.
- People of all colors from all over the world worked to end apartheid.
In South Africa, black and white students opposed it. Around the
world, many countries used boycotts and other economic strategies
to protest it.
- International organizations, including the UN, also had a role.
- Use the Universal Declaration of Human Rights to describe the
rights that were violated by apartheid.
·
To end the activity, have students write in their journal about
how their understanding of racism has changed.
Directions
for using Holocaust handouts
· Begin the activity by circulating pictures from the Holocaust
era (in books or from the websites listed). Ask students to describe
what they see, and if they know when and where the pictures are from.
· Distribute the handout Introduction
to the Holocaust. As a class, read the introduction. Have students
generate any previous knowledge they may have about the Holocaust
or antisemitism.
· Ask students if they can think of other examples of racial
segregation (e.g., apartheid; the removal of Native Americans from
their homelands to reservations.)
· Break students into eight groups. Give each group one of
the eight selections of the Holocaust Timeline. (The directions for
the timeline activity are on the Introduction
to the Holocaust handout. Make sure students keep this handy.)
· Explain that each selection describes different events in
the history of the Holocaust. Together, the selections create a timeline
spanning almost 1700 years. Have students pass their selection around
in their groups and identify the years covered.
· Tell students that their selection may describe examples
of discrimination, examples of resistance, or both. Choose a student
to read aloud a paragraph from his/her selection. Ask the class to
identify whether the paragraph describes an example of discrimination,
resistance, or both. (Acts of resistance that failed or were prevented
are also relevant.) As you discuss the example, use words students
will encounter in their reading: e.g., antisemitism, Holocaust, genocide.
Clarify vocabulary as needed.
· Direct students' attention to the "Directions for the
Timeline" on the "Introduction" handout. Review the
directions (summarized here): Working within their groups, students
take turns reading passages from their selection, and identify examples
of discrimination and/or resistance. Students then create at least
two illustrations of the events described on their selection and write
a summary incorporating key information. The goal is for students
to become experts on their selection in order to present their drawings
and summaries to the class.
· Allow at least 30 minutes for groups to work. Circulate to
provide assistance as needed. Make sure groups have identified and
are illustrating examples of discrimination and/or resistance, including
acts of resistance that failed or were prevented due to repression.
· When groups are done, have them present their work chronologically,
from the earliest to the most recent events. In their presentations,
have students discuss examples of discrimination and how people resisted.
Have students take questions from the class. Ask additional questions
or provide additional commentary as necessary. Allow about 3 minutes
for each group to keep the process running.
· When the timeline is complete, lead a discussion focusing
on the systematic nature of racism and the methods people use to resist
it.
(Learn
more about the resistance from testimonies collected by the British
Library.)
Use the "analysis and discussion" questions on the "Introduction
to the Holocaust" handout to guide the discussion. (Students
can complete these for homework if desired.) These questions are provided
here:
-
Give examples of discrimination carried out through economic,
social, and political institutions.
- Describe some key acts of resistance against the Nazis.
- What prevented the resistance efforts from being more effective?
- Give examples of scapegoating and explain why you think it was
directed at the Jews?
- Use the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights to describe the rights that were violated
by the Nazis.
·
Emphasize the following points during the discussion:
-
The Nazis used economic, social, and political institutions as
tools of discrimination. Institutional racism is systematic and
influences every aspect of society. Individual acts of discrimination
merely support larger patterns of exclusion.
- Efforts to resist persecution and discrimination are more difficult
when people are denied civil, economic, and social rights.
- In opening remarks to a seminar on antisemitism, Secretary-General
Kofi Annan stated that "the United Nations emerged from the
ashes of the Holocaust" and that "this genocide was
the driving force behind the Universal Declaration of Human Rights"
that was adopted by the General Assembly in 1948.
-
A report issued by the European Monitoring Centre on Racism and
Xenophobia titled Manifestations
of Antisemitism in the EU 2002-2003 documented a serious increase
in acts of antisemitism in some parts of Europe. While not limited
to Europe, antisemitism is still a global problem that needs to
be addressed.
·
To end the activity, have students write in their journal about
how their understanding of racism has changed. |
>
to top
SECTION
C: Positive Steps Against Racial Discrimination (45 minutes; optional
projects) Guiding questions: What is being done to combat racial discrimination?
What can I do?
This section provides ways for students to combat against racial discrimination
at three levels: 1. personal, 2. community, and 3. international.
The activities are described below; clicking on each will take you
to the relevant student handouts. The directions for the activities
are self-explanatory and are provided on the students' handouts, as
are websites for on-line projects. |
| |
| Activity
1: Personal Actions: Students identify personal steps they
can take to address racial discrimination. Sample ideas are provided.
Activity 2: Using Skits to practise Responding
to Racist Remarks: Students write and perform skits to demonstrate
positive ways to respond to discriminatory remarks.
Activity 3: Learning About Community Efforts to Improve Race
Relations: Students interview a representative from a community
organization involved in anti-racism work.
Activity 4: Becoming Involved in a Global
Network of Young People: Students
can participate in on-line projects with classrooms around the world.
Websites are provided.
Activity 5: Creating a Racism-Free Society at the International
Level: To help answer the question, "What would a racism-free
society look like?", students illustrate excerpts from the
UN International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial
Discrimination. Students then conduct research to identify if their
country has ratified and/or implemented the Convention.
|
|
|